Looking Ahead: Human Resources Trends to Watch in 2026
As organizations continue to recalibrate in a post-COVID era, 2026 is shaping up to be a year of refinement rather than reinvention. Recent industry reporting and analysis point to a shift away from the bright and shiny and toward practicality, compliance, and sustainable people operations. Below are my assessments of the HR trends that will define 2026.
AI Moves from Novelty to Necessity
Artificial intelligence will become less about experimentation and more about productivity and refinement. AI will not replace roles, but it will be embedded into HR workflows: resume screening, workforce planning, compliance tracking, and strategic decision-making. Thriving HR departments will leverage AI as a support tool, not a substitute for human judgment or skill.
In hospitality specifically, AI will continue to be critical to day-to-day operations. With systems like Legion already supporting time and attendance and workforce forecasting, we can expect further refinement across other HR functions such as applicant screening, interview scheduling, and compliance monitoring. For hotels and restaurants operating around the clock, AI will reduce administrative burden while supporting Fair Workweek compliance, scheduling accuracy, and staffing efficiency. The most successful operators will be those who balance technology with the human touch that defines hospitality.
Unionization Takes a Back Seat to Compliance
While labor organizing in hospitality has dominated headlines in recent years at companies like La Colombe, Starbucks, and Blank Street Coffee the greater opportunity lies in strengthening internal systems by investing in existing HR talent. Increased regulatory scrutiny from the EEOC, along with a rise in enforcement activity, has pushed organizations to shore up their fundamentals.
This is especially evident in wage-and-hour compliance, particularly for tipped employees. Additionally, new legislation around mandatory safe and sick time, retirement plans, and wage increases has, in many cases, reduced the urgency for organizing. In 2026, proactivity will be the differentiator. Organizations that avoid reactive approaches and instead build strong, compliant systems will be best positioned for success.
Credentials Matter Less
As industry organizations like SHRM face their own internal challenges, a noticeable decline in certification participation signals a broader reassessment of what truly matters in HR leadership. In this environment, experience is king. Employers are placing greater value on real-world application, industry knowledge, business acumen, and the ability to balance people strategy with operational demands.
Todayâs successful HR leader is expected to be a true business partner, someone who understands operations, finance, and culture, not just policy. In hospitality, the most effective HR leaders are those who understand the floor as well as the handbook.
The Rise of the Fractional CHRO
As companies aim to remain lean while maintaining strategic oversight, part-time and fractional CHRO roles are gaining traction. Organizations are prioritizing seasoned generalists who can oversee compliance, talent strategy, and leadership development without the cost of a full executive headcount. This model allows businesses especially in hospitality to stay nimble while still benefiting from senior-level HR expertise.
Lean Talent Acquisition Teams
Talent acquisition teams will likely see further reductions as hiring volumes continue to decline and automation continues to advance. Recruiting is becoming more centralized, metrics-driven, and aligned with actual business needs rather than growth-at-all-costs hiring. In 2026, HR teams will be expected to do more with less leveraging systems, data, and internal mobility instead of expanding headcount.
What This Means for HR Leaders
In 2026, HR will be less about reinvention and more about thoughtful, intentional execution. This means strong systems, compliant practices, and leaders who are deeply embedded in the business and understand people just as well as they understand operations.
Organizations that invest now in process discipline, technology literacy, and well-rounded HR leadership will be best positioned to navigate whatâs ahead. They balance the warmth, consistency, and excellence that hospitality demands.
In February of this year, I had the opportunity to interview the McNulty scholars at Hunter College to help them prepare for summer internships and grad school. In my career, Iâve interviewed, hired, and onboarded thousands of folks in hospitality, retail, and healthcare. Iâve learned a few things about what employers and hiring managers are looking for, so I decided to send them a guide to help them prepare based on the feedback I had for them and the questions they had for me and share it with all of you(Shocker, whatâs your weakness was asked by almost everyone!).Â
1. Create Your Elevator PitchÂ
Your elevator pitch is not only an opportunity to showcase the important work you do but also to convey your personal story. Your elevator pitch should have the three C's, clarity, conciseness, and confidence. If you don't believe in yourself no one else will. Consider adding what you do, how you do it, and why you do it, typically in less than 3 minutes. Here's some groundwork from Indeed on writing your next pitch. Always make sure to tailor it to your specific audience.Â
2. ABA (Always Be Asking)
The quickest way to lose engagement during an interview is not to have any questions prepared. Even if the interviewer has answered every question about the school/role, use this time to ask them a question about themself relative to their journey and lean on that interest to establish a connection. You can ask questions like:
What keeps you here?
What was your career trajectory?
What are three words you would use to describe working here?
What are some qualities that someone needs to have to be successful here?
What's one initiative you worked on this year that you're proud of?
These questions also give you insight into the company and any issues that may be present before jumping in. Is the person hesitant in their response? Doesnât speak positively about leadership or work-life balance? Doesnât have any good initiatives to share? You are interviewing them just as much as theyâre interviewing you! Be sure to be an active listener and ask follow-up questions to your interviewer. Here's a good list of other questions to ask if you're ever stuck keep these in your arsenal.Â
3. Be PC When Discussing Former Employers You Despise
We all have employers/bosses that weren't our favorite. Avoid going on rants that bash them. Instead, focus on what you learned from that experience and why this particular employer/school entices you. You can use phrases like the ones below to convey that it was a difficult experience without outright expressing it.
Working/being there was an interesting experience
I learned a lot about myself and my expectations for my next roleÂ
I believe everyone deserves a safe environment and that's why I'm interested in being here
I was allowed to do things outside of my job description to enhance my skillsÂ
Heather at Glassdoor has written some tips that include avoiding giving unnecessary information. (I agree!)
4. Answering Common Questions Like What's Your Weakness?
Instead of using cookie-cutter answers like I work too much or I'm too dedicated, use this as an opportunity to show self-awareness and positivity. You can say, I wouldn't define these as weaknesses because they make me who I am but this year I am working on x skill.Â
Time Management - Managing competing priorities has always been difficult for me due to time constraints but being more organized and aligning with leaders/peers on what needs to get done helps me push through.Â
Patience - I am self-sufficient so at times I find it difficult to work on a team if the pace is not as fast as I would like it to be. I've been working on this through team-building workshops and seeking out opportunities to work in groups.Â
Delegation - I struggled with delegation because I felt as if I could do a better job faster. I'm learning that there is beauty in the process of helping others grow and learn. I use project management tools to maintain a sense of control while allowing my team to work at their own pace.
Conflict Averse - I avoided giving feedback because I thought it would start a conflict or I would be looked at in a negative light. I'm working on balancing feedback with empathy and understanding that no one grows in their comfort zone including myself.
5. Brag About Yourself!
"Stories enable us to give credence to reality" - Ingram
When bragging about yourself, share your experiences, contributions, results, and of course challenges. Itâs okay to be vulnerable about obstacles and opportunities faced(appropriately, of course). Your vulnerability displays resilience and problem-solving skills. Be sure to phrase statements as open-ended questions to engage folks and encourage dialogue about your story. Emphasize the importance of your community by mentioning mentors, teachers, peers, and collaborators. You all are incredibly smart, resourceful, and impactful!
Navigating the Evolving Landscape of Hybrid Work: Insights from Microsoft and Industry Leaders
Submitted to Rutgers February 2024
By: Rana Seabrook
Introduction
The corporate environment we once knew has witnessed volatility due to many external shifts in the socio-economic and technological landscape. The COVID-19 pandemic has changed how companies conduct business, view their products, interact with their communities, and attract and retain their employees. The leaders of today now have to address a myriad of obstacles in how they collaborate with Human Resource leaders to create policies that are nurturing and inclusive to address their diverse employee populationâs needs. These shifts have forced leaders to be intentional with how they operate and consider long-term implications instead of creating policies that are symptomatic and creating short-term or band-aid solutions.
Challenges in the Work Environment
Numerous companies and industry leaders have grappled publicly about the state of work pleading their case for either side. James Gorman, Chief Executive at Morgan Stanley, stated âIf you can eat out, you can come into the officeâ(Economist, 2022) in support of return-to-work initiatives. Employees have openly vocalized their concerns and the importance of their work environment on their mental health and overall well-being. Google, Slack, Zillow, Salesforce, and many other organizations celebrated remote work at the beginning of the pandemic. The evolution of Googleâs and many other organizations' transition from remote championing to enforcing return-to-office mandates demonstrates the complexities of managing a hybrid workforce. Shifts like Googleâs crack-down on hybrid offenders(Elisa, 2023) can exacerbate feelings of apathy as employees navigating competing priorities like family and work-life balance could be pushed to seek other employment. These complexities lead to the need for nuanced policies and practices that display sensitivity.
Industry Leader Response
While some companies struggled to adapt to the evolving landscape and return to work mandates, others like Microsoft embraced change and seized the opportunity to foster an environment that was conducive to employee growth and innovation. Microsoft has always been at the forefront of innovation and has always displayed adaptability and led the charge with technological innovation. Since the 1980s, it has evolved into one of the worldâs largest tech companies through strategic partnerships, acquisitions, industry dominance through monopolies, and innovation that keeps its competitors on their toes. Their relentless pursuit of innovation has allowed them to weather many industry changes including the dot-com bubble, the AOL days, and today, cloud computing. Microsoft has continuously set the tone for the market especially how we function at work with 1.2 billion people worldwide using the Microsoft suite. (Zipdo, 2021)
The Microsoft Approach
Much like any other company, Microsoft did have a fully remote model at the beginning of the pandemic. Instead of focusing on what leadership or market influences, they followed three key principles to create a plan that would work best for their population:
Focus on employee empowerment - Microsoft focused on how they could create environments in which their employees could become the best version of themselves and for each employee this may look different.Â
Respond to a rapidly changing environment - COVID regulations were changing rapidly in the United States and abroad, Microsoft sought to provide ways in which employees still felt connected, empowered, and worthy.Â
Center innovation and improvement - Microsoft harnessed the power of its physical spaces, technological prowess, and culture to bring new ideas and ways of collaboration for its global teams to life.
Benefits & Drawbacks of Hybrid Work
According to Webex, âHybrid work is a flexible work model that supports a blend of in-office, remote, and on-the-go workers. It offers employees the autonomy to choose to work wherever and however they are most productive.â While hybrid and remote work has always existed, the COVID-19 pandemic forced more companies to adopt this model to get work done while the world was essentially âshut downâ. Once employees discovered that their workday did not need to consist of sitting in hours of traffic or being chained to a desk in downtown San Fran, a shift happened in the needs of employees across the US and globally. Studies also found that office mandates did not contribute to the bottom line(Abril,2024) and cost the company more through office space costs.
As many benefits as there are in support of hybrid work for employees, there are also potential drawbacks for employers. Overemployment happens when employees work multiple salaried jobs at the same time. The work-from-home environment has created ideal conditions for those who are not satisfied with one aspect of their employment to multi-task at home. Additionally, some other negative aspects of hybrid work include isolation, lack of productivity, apathy through reduced social interaction, and less brand loyalty. Despite these drawbacks, the obvious benefits outweigh potential concerns.
Microsoft recognized that its most important asset is not the $400B they have in assets but the human capital propelling the company forward. The only way that Microsoft can continue to exert dominance in the industry is to continue to empower its staff to learn, grow, and be more productive. Because of this, Microsoft invested in its IT infrastructure and prioritized an employee-first experience that focused on productivity, well-being, and of course, collaboration.Â
They first invested in Microsoft Viva and Microsoft Copilot both within the 365 suite. These tools assisted employees with generative AI to support productivity and reimagine the entire experience. Microsoft Viva is âan integrated employee experience platform built within Microsoft 365 and Microsoft Teams that gives you the ability to support connection, insight, purpose, and growth in your organization using your existing infrastructureâ (Microsoft, 2023). Through the integration of apps and open API products, the flow of work, innovation, and news exists in one place. AI was used to enhance emails, and presentations and to summarize documents and meetings. A time saver and enhancer overall in a hybrid environment. For in-person interactions, collaboration with their GWS(Global Workplace Services) team technology was used to improve check-ins as physical locations, and app capabilities in order, and streamline the lunch process through ordering ahead. This not only provided a sense of safety and security from COVID-19 but also less time waiting for food to be created and more time resting. Microsoft also introduced real-time directions and âwayfindingâ in those apps to reduce time spent looking for people or destinations in the office. Regarding the Teams platform and meeting capabilities, Microsoft increased products that allowed collaboration such as whiteboarding, the raise hand functionality, and the addition of polling during the meetings. This allowed participation and inclusivity without being disruptive and distracting. On the security front, Microsoft tightened its security protocols to protect assets and provide a safe and secure work environment even for those who are working remotely or in hybrid arrangements.Â
Conclusion
The recent events in the world including the COVID-19 pandemic have prompted a shift in how companies operate and the way employees engage in their work. Companies are battling multiple challenges at once having to redefine what success looks like in a post covid, hybrid environment. While many companies have faced difficulties in adapting to these changes, many others have embraced and even grown with the times producing innovation and creating policies that nurture and foster development in their people.Â
Microsoftâs success story post-COVID is driven by adaptability, innovation, and centering the needs of their team. They have proven that they are ready to respond to ever-changing environments keeping true to their culture of integrating technology in solutions and strategic investments in data and open API products. The company has empowered its people to not only survive but to thrive in a hybrid work environment. As the business world continues to evolve and companies try to adapt to new challenges, Microsoft serves as a blueprint for other organizations who are looking to successfully navigate the complexities and support the most important investment â their people.Â
Bibliography
We Work Remotely. (n.d.). We work remotely: 21 companies that now allow their employees to work from home permanently. https://weworkremotely.com/21-companies-that-now-allow-their-employees-to-work-from-home-permanently
Kelly, J. (2020, May 24). Here are the companies leading the Work-From-Home Revolution. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2020/05/24/the-work-from-home-revolution-is-quickly-gaining-momentum/?sh=3aff50751848
The Economist. (2022, July 28). Is hybrid work the worst of both worlds? The Economist. https://www.economist.com/business/2022/03/12/is-hybrid-work-the-worst-of-both-worlds?utm_medium=cpc.adword.pd&utm_source=google&ppccampaignID=17210591673&ppcadID=&utm_campaign=a.22brand_pmax&utm_content=conversion.direct-response.anonymous&gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiA8sauBhB3EiwAruTRJvkzCus6NjIXAobUQ7TT0ecc1PERWgP7NCuV69h9tsuvvW8R_ZtBORoCH4MQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds
Haas, M. (2023, February 6). 5 Challenges of hybrid work â and how to overcome them. Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2022/02/5-challenges-of-hybrid-work-and-how-to-overcome-them
Microsoft (MSFT) - Total assets. (n.d.). https://companiesmarketcap.com/microsoft/total-assets/#google_vignette
LoreenLa. (2023, November 1). Microsoft Viva Overview. Microsoft Learn. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/viva/microsoft-viva-overview
Disadvantages & challenges of remote work | Remote Work Guide. (n.d.). https://www.wrike.com/remote-work-guide/remote-working-disadvantages-challenges/
NI Business Info. (n.d.). Advantages and disadvantages of employees working at home | nibusinessinfo.co.uk. https://www.nibusinessinfo.co.uk/content/advantages-and-disadvantages-employees-working-home
Kelly, J. (2021, August 15). The remote trend of working two jobs at the same time without both companies knowing. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2021/08/15/the-remote-trend-of-working-two-jobs-at-the-same-time-without-both-companies-knowing/?sh=4997670e17f3
Webex. (2023, May 30). What is hybrid work and what are hybrid work models? Webex. https://www.webex.com/what-is-hybrid-work.html#:~:text=Definition%3A%20Hybrid%20work%20is%20a,however%20they%20are%20most%20productive.
Boyd, K. (2023, December 20). Reinventing Microsoftâs employee experience for a hybrid world. Inside Track Blog. https://www.microsoft.com/insidetrack/blog/reinventing-microsofts-employee-experience-for-a-hybrid-world/
Nadella, S. (2021, May 21). The hybrid work paradox. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/hybrid-work-paradox-satya-nadella/
Riccardi, G. (2023, June 9). Google has officially changed its mind about remote work. Quartz. https://qz.com/google-remote-work-policy-reversal-ironic-1850520264
Hybrid work is just work. Are we doing it wrong? (n.d.). https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/worklab/work-trend-index/hybrid-work-is-just-work
Elias, J. (2023, June 8). Google to crack down on office attendance, asks remote workers to reconsider. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/08/google-to-crack-down-on-hybrid-work-asks-remote-workers-to-reconsider.html
IBM is one of the worldâs largest, longest-standing technological firms. In its over 100 year history, it has withstood the test of time continuing to create quality products and a leader amongst giants. In todayâs world, market share in the tech space has become increasingly difficult as companies fight for resources in manufacturing and top talent while battling regulatory challenges and evolution that happens faster than they can produce. Â
Problem
Although IBM has been in operation for quite some time, it has not taken the proper steps to invest in its people the way other competitors have in the space. Outdated training practices, inefficient review systems, lack of career ladders and transparency surrounding upward mobility plagues the organization. These practices make the company vulnerable and susceptible to quiet quitting, disengagement and stagnation due to the lack of investment in learning and development.Â
In order to transform IBM into a learning organization, we propose that IBM:
Introduces a revised appraisal system by incorporating recognition through regular review cycles and a holistic approach
Foster a diverse environment and embrace a learning culture by investing in and incorporating cutting edge technology
Invest in employeeâs well being by rolling out new initiatives that contribute to the creation of a continuous learning culture
Value
A study conducted by Forbes showed that happy employees are 20% more productive in the workplace than unhappy employees. 61% of HR employees listed training and development as one of their top three reasons for leaving a company.(SHRM, 2022)
Investing in learning and development initiatives reduces turnover, increases creativity and as a result leads to increased profits and reduced costs.
In order to stay competitive, IBM needs to return to its roots of being innovative, thinking outside of the box and being ahead of the curve.Â
Industry Background
The tech industry is a broad and dynamic sector that encompasses companies involved in developing, producing, and distributing technology-based goods and services. This industry plays a crucial role in shaping the modern world by driving innovation and economic growth. It is currently one of the fastest-growing industries with ongoing innovation and a major scope for growth. Our focus is on the software industry, which encompasses creating programs, applications, and operating systems. This sector includes both system software and application software. Companies like Apple, Google, Microsoft, Amazon, and Facebook (Meta) are currently among the most influential and valuable in the industry. The tech industry is also known for its vibrant startup ecosystem, with emerging companies bringing disruptive ideas and technologies to the market. Advances in AI and ML are transforming various sectors, including healthcare, finance, and manufacturing. The shift towards cloud-based services allows businesses to access and deploy applications and data more efficiently.Â
SWOT Analysis
Strengths
Innovation: The tech industry is synonymous with innovation, constantly pushing boundaries and introducing new technologies that drive economic growth and societal advancements.
Talent Pool: The industry attracts some of the brightest minds globally, fostering a rich talent pool of skilled professionals and entrepreneurs.
Global Reach: Tech companies often have a global presence, allowing them to tap into diverse markets and customer bases.
Rapid Evolution: The fast-paced nature of the industry enables quick adaptation to market trends and emerging technologies.
Weaknesses
Rapid Obsolescence: Products and technologies can become outdated quickly, requiring continuous investment in research and development to stay competitive.
High Costs of Investment: Developing and bringing cutting-edge technologies to market often involves significant upfront costs, making it challenging for smaller players.
Dependency on Supply Chains: The tech industry relies on complex global supply chains, making it susceptible to disruptions, as seen in events like semiconductor shortages.
Regulatory Challenges: Increasing scrutiny and regulatory challenges, such as antitrust concerns and data privacy regulations, pose risks to tech companies.
Opportunities
Emerging Technologies: Opportunities lie in emerging technologies like artificial intelligence, blockchain, quantum computing, and biotechnology.
Digital Transformation: Businesses across industries are undergoing digital transformation, creating a demand for technology solutions and services.
Global Connectivity: The expansion of internet access and the development of 5G networks create opportunities for new services and applications.
E-commerce Growth: The continued growth of e-commerce presents opportunities for companies providing online platforms, payment solutions, and logistics services.
Threats
Competition: Intense competition within the industry can lead to price wars and margin pressures, particularly for hardware manufacturers.
Cybersecurity Threats: With the increasing reliance on digital technologies, the industry faces constant threats from cyberattacks, data breaches, and other security vulnerabilities.
Geopolitical Tensions: Trade tensions and geopolitical conflicts can impact the global supply chain and market access for tech companies.
Economic Downturn: Economic recessions or downturns can affect consumer spending and corporate investments in technology, impacting the industry's growth.
IBM, or International Business Machines Corporation, is a globally renowned American multinational technology and consulting company. IBM has played a pivotal role in shaping the technology landscape over the decades. The company is known for its innovation and contributions to the tech industry at large. IBM has been a pioneer in the development of mainframe computers, personal computers, and more recently, in areas such as artificial intelligence and quantum computing. The company offers a wide range of products and services, including hardware, software, cloud computing, and cognitive computing solutions. IBM has consistently been at the forefront of technological advancements, fostering research and development, and maintaining a significant presence in the business and enterprise sectors worldwide.
Current HR structure and Practice
IBM's organization is structured in such a way that HR, as well as other functions, report directly to the leadership of the current President, Arvind Krishna. According to the 2022 annual report, IBM has a presence in 175 countries, of which 172 countries have approximately 2,700 employees involved in Human Resources. Currently, 288,300 employees work for the company, which equates to about 1% of the total workforce working in HR. According to the Workforce Analytics: A Critical Evaluation: How Organizational Staff Size Influences HR Metrics (SHRM, 2015), the average employee to-HR ratio, by staff size, is 2.57, indicating that IBM already has a lean HR organization. In addition, the news in May 2023 that about 30% of the HR positions will be able to handle AI and automation in the next five years with the development of AI technology indicates that IBM's HR organization will undergo further dramatic changes in the future. Positions that are likely to change will be those that are not customer facing, such as those in charge of documentation and data preparation, which will likely change as the external environment changes and technology becomes more pervasive.
IBM is implementing development practices as part of its talent strategy. Due to the rapid changes in technology and IBM's strong commitment to change, they are continually investing in personalized training programs using Watson AI, peer-to-peer collaboration and internal social sharing functionality. As a CHRO discussed in the video, as technology develops and AI becomes mainstream, it is imperative to embody a growth mindset and an attitude of continuous learning to be able to use AI. Learning new skills and being able to leverage them will lead to career growth and it also leads to increased employee engagement. In addition to the learning platform provided by the company, having business acumen and expertise, enjoying changes, and being flexible to continue learning are essential for evolution and growth of each employee.
What Does a Best-in-class Global HR Organization Do?
By aligning appraisal and training closely with a company's strategy and designing it around the company's goals, it can be more effective in designing training and developing employees. Furthermore, by utilizing modern technology, evaluations and data can be accurately measured and efficiently analyzed. By accumulating data, comparisons can be made, and adjustments and improvements can be made in an agile manner as the business evolves. Improving the infrastructure used by HR to facilitate seamless sharing or automation of data also improves the user experience and has a synergistic effect on the experience of employees who receive training. As more employees become more positive about training and development efforts, everyone will actively take actions that lead to improvement and growth in a culture of autonomy, improving skills and competencies and leading to corporate growth.
What is important in appraisal is not only to be based on corporate strategy and job type, but also to ensure fairness, transparency, objectivity, and integrity. Criteria, procedures, and feedback are all important practices at every step, and if even one element is missing, it will be difficult to gain the trust and acceptance of employees. Once training and development needs are assessed and identified, programs can be developed, deployed, measured, evaluated, and analyzed, and linked to a cycle of improvement. There is a wide range of training and development programs offered by companies. The most frequently used are classroom courses, coaching, mentoring, and leadership forums. Others include high-visibility assignments, matching employees with stretch opportunities, and job rotation. The appropriate selection of these options will vary from company to company, so best-in-class global HR organizations will carefully examine the company's situation and execute needs assessment. The development of training and development programs and post-implementation outcome measurement is where critical information can be obtained to not only measure effectiveness but also to measure the effectiveness and improve the accuracy of training programs. There is no single method that is appropriate, as there are differences among cultures, sizes, and countries for a case of a global company. Therefore, involving stakeholders, clarifying the definition of the best talents in accordance with the corporate strategy, and then formulating evaluations based on the strategy, and continuously implementing and reviewing training and development programs will lead to continuous corporate growth. Considering IBM's business situation, organizational structure, and the corporate strategy announced in May 2023, the recommended methodology is the corporate university model, which is conducted face-to-face, to be adopted to continuously develop key talents. These initiatives will not only develop talents, but will also effectively serve as employee branding, enhance external recognition, and increase corporate visibility.
Business and HR Recommendations for IBM
Changing Human Capital in the Technology Sector
In the ever-changing technology industry, IBM must evolve its Human Resource strategies to foster creativity, flexibility, and long-term growth. The following recommendations, tailored to IBM's needs, provide nuanced adjustments to performance management, training and development, and appraisal procedures, with an emphasis on the incorporation of a Corporate University Model and an increased emphasis on in-person engagement.
Revised Appraisal System
1.  Change to Holistic Evaluation
IBM needs to implement a more comprehensive approach rather than merely depending on financial measures. This includes qualitative measures like creativity, adaptability, and employee satisfaction.
Surveys can be used to measure employee satisfaction, and project contributions and the capacity to adopt new technologies and methods can be used to measure innovation and adaptability.
2. Constant Feedback and Development Plans
IBM's fast-paced technology environment makes it imperative to establish regular, continuous feedback systems. Make use of project evaluations, frequent check-ins, and real-time communication tools to guarantee prompt and helpful feedback.
Work with employees to develop personalized development plans that are in line with their goals and align with IBM's technology-driven objectives. Setting specific skill development goals and identifying relevant training opportunities could be part of this.
3.  Recognition of Innovation and Cooperation
Create a system that actively encourages and rewards innovation. This includes incorporating an innovation metric into the evaluation system, which could track the number of implemented ideas, successful patents, or contributions to game-changing projects.
Recognize and reward collaboration in cross-functional teams by incorporating collaboration metrics, recognizing team accomplishments in performance reviews, and cultivating a team-oriented culture.
Performance Management in the Tech Sector
1.  Technology-Oriented Objective
Ensure that individual and group goals are in line with IBM's technology-driven objectives. This alignment can be seen in performance metrics that track contributions to technological progress and the successful implementation of cutting-edge solutions.
Create clear career paths within emerging technology industries, offering training programs and mentorship to ensure IBM has the necessary expertise for future growth.
2.  Continuous Learning Culture
Create a culture of lifelong learning by making resources available for employees to improve their skills. This could include providing online courses, workshops, and mentoring programs.
Use metrics to recognize and reward proactive skill development. This could include tracking certification completion, participation in training programs, and the successful application of new skills in projects.
3.  Using Inclusion and Diversity as Performance Measures
Incorporate inclusion and diversity into performance metrics to emphasize their significance. Evaluating how well diversity is supported and encouraged through performance management techniques and cultivating a diverse and encouraging work environment through inclusive leadership practices.
Supporting Training and Development
1.  Investing in Cutting-Edge Training Tools
Allocate funds within IBM for cutting-edge training tools, including immersive learning environments, virtual reality simulations, and advanced training aids. Collaborate with outside experts to provide specialized training and insights, enhancing IBM's technological capabilities.
2.  Technology-Infused Learning Programs:
Implement AI-powered adaptive learning systems at IBM, personalizing training experiences to individual needs. Place a strong emphasis on experiential learning through practical projects and teamwork, ensuring employees can effectively apply their knowledge to real-world challenges.
3.  Initiatives for Employee Well-Being:
Acknowledge the stressful nature of the tech industry at IBM and implement comprehensive well-being initiatives. This includes programs supporting a healthy work-life balance, flexible work schedules, and mental health support. Stress the integral role these initiatives play in establishing continuous organizational growth.
Corporate University Model and In-Person Engagement:
IBM should consider the adoption of a Corporate University Model to consolidate learning resources and provide a centralized hub for training. Also, increasing in-person engagement through meetings and training sessions is crucial to foster collaboration, community, and employee well-being.
Aligning these recommendations with IBM's unique characteristics, such as implementing a Corporate University Model and enhancing in-person engagement, will elevate HR practices. This approach not only drives innovation and competitiveness but also ensures IBM's readiness for technological advancements, securing a thriving future in the ever-evolving tech industry.
ROI and how do these new practices advance the competitive advantage of IBM?
Measuring ROI in human capital, especially in a dynamic company like IBM, involves balancing tangible and intangible factors in the tech sector. IBM's history of innovation, rooted in applying science to real-world problems, emphasizes their focus on advancements that matter for both business and society. This approach extends to their human capital investments, where they lead in computing frontiers and its relationship to business, science, professions, and society. IBM's commitment to these areas includes significant technological investments, such as in AI, quantum computing, and hybrid cloud, aligning with their strategic goals and enhancing their competitive edge. Such initiatives not only foster a culture of innovation and continuous learning but also play a key role in attracting and retaining top talent, which is crucial in the competitive tech industry. By focusing on these areas, IBM ensures that their investments in human capital yield high returns, both financially and in terms of their innovative capacityâ (Gil, 2022). The ROI formula (ROI = (Net Benefits / Cost of Investment) Ă 100) is particularly significant in the tech industry due to the high costs and potentially high returns of tech talent investment. Crucial qualitative elements include the ability to innovate and adapt to technology advancements, employee loyalty in a competitive talent landscape, and brand building in the tech industry. Initiatives to teach employees in new programming languages or agile processes, for instance, not only enhance skill sets but also encourage brand advocacy by helping employees feel more invested in the company's tech-centric objective.
Advancing Competitive Advantage
In the tech sector, investing in human capital extends beyond traditional training and development. It entails developing a workforce that is tech-savvy, flexible, and able to keep up with the quick speed of technology advancement. In tech organizations, improved performance management systems play a crucial role in coordinating employees' goals and abilities with the organization's technology-driven goals. Establishing distinct career pathways in specialized fields like cloud computing, cybersecurity, and artificial intelligence is part of this, as these are essential to the expansion and innovation of a digital organization. In the tech sector, a continual learning culture is essential. For IBM, this means not just traditional training but developing a workforce adept in key areas like cloud computing, cybersecurity, and AI. These fields are integral to IBM's growth and innovation strategy, reflecting their focus on leading the frontiers of computing. IBM's investment in continuous learning and development programs ensures their workforce remains adaptable and skilled in the latest technologies. This approach is pivotal in a rapidly evolving tech landscape where customer needs and technological capabilities constantly change. IBM's emphasis on creating a diverse and inclusive culture further enriches their innovation potential, drawing from a broad spectrum of perspectives and ideas, essential for meeting the diverse needs of their global clientele and staying ahead in the competitive tech industry (Gil, 2022). It entails routine upskilling in new techniques and technology, cultivating a workforce that is not only knowledgeable but also adaptable and creative. This attitude is essential to staying competitive in a market where customer needs are always changing and technology is always evolving. The development of an atmosphere that fosters creativity, critical thinking, and problem-solving abilitiesâskills crucial for digital innovationâis another aspect of the tech industry's investments in human resources. Furthermore, a varied and inclusive workplace culture is supported by an emphasis on equitable and inclusive performance management techniques. In addition to being morally required, diversity is also a commercial strategy since it generates a range of viewpoints and ideas that may serve a larger client base and enhance the company's ability to innovate.
Measuring the Success
Traditional and tech-specific criteria must be combined in order to assess the effectiveness of human capital initiatives in the IT sector. While productivity gains and staff turnover rates are still important metrics, there is also more attention focused on employee happiness in tech-specific roles and the caliber of the services or products provided. The success of human capital investments can be determined by looking at metrics such as the rate of innovation in product development, the efficiency of tech support teams, and the effectiveness of software development procedures. The incorporation of sophisticated analytics and big data into these assessments offers a thorough understanding of their influence. By using predictive analytics, proactive strategic decisions can be made by anticipating future patterns in tech staff performance and attrition. The tech industry experiences measurable benefits including higher-quality products, more efficient tech processes, and lower operating expenses as a result of better human capital strategies. Improved staff morale is one of the intangible benefits; this is especially important in the tech sector because of the high levels of stress and the demand for original and creative ideas. An organization's competitive edge is directly attributed to its talented, efficient, and motivated workforce, which helps it thrive in a fast-paced, technologically-driven work environment. Assessing the effectiveness of human capital initiatives at IBM involves a blend of traditional and tech-specific metrics. Beyond productivity gains and turnover rates, IBM places significant emphasis on employee satisfaction in tech-specific roles and the quality of its services and products. Metrics such as innovation in product development, tech support team efficiency, and software development effectiveness are key indicators. IBM leverages advanced analytics and big data to gain insights into these areas, using predictive analytics for strategic decision-making. This approach leads to tangible benefits like higher-quality products, more efficient processes, and lower operational costs, while also enhancing staff morale, a critical factor given the demanding nature of the tech sector. IBM's focus on human capital management aligns with its strategic goals, fostering a culture of innovation, adaptability, and continuous learning.Â
Human capital management has special potential and challenges in the digital sector. A staff that is not just technically skilled but also flexible, creative, and in line with the company's strategic goals is imperative given the speed at which technology is changing. The return on investment (ROI) in human capital in the technology sector is a complex metric that incorporates qualitative factors like brand loyalty, staff engagement, and innovation potential in addition to straightforward financial calculations. In the tech sector, human capital investments should be strategically matched to the organization's long-term objectives, with an emphasis on creating a culture of innovation, adaptability, and ongoing learning. These programs' effectiveness is assessed using a combination of conventional measurements and tech-specific indicators, utilizing advanced data analytics to provide a thorough picture of their effects.
Implementation Issues
When it comes to implementing suggestions that transform company culture specifically, the learning and development space, there is no shortage of challenges that the HR team and company will face as a whole. With IBM, there are many nuances to consider especially the size of the HR team relative to the companyâs population and the ability to produce results while running that lean. IBM has a spatial global team so factors like the adoption of innovative and creative solutions such as the Corporate University Model will determine the success of the program. Additionally, There will need to be major considerations concerning the cost and overall investment in the training department and program to see tangible results. Lastly, the increasing development of growing technologies like AI also adds complications to implementation.
Challenges to Implementing the Revised Appraisal System
Change to Holistic Evaluation
Successfully implementing a holistic approach requires a larger team of specialists, not generalists who have increased bandwidth to carry out the project to completion.
A change to the way a company views or thinks about its policies or procedures especially when it comes to learning and development requires buy-in and participation from senior leaders and key stakeholders. Effective change starts from the top down.
Even with the adoption and buy-in from senior leaders, employees need to feel connected and have trust in the company and the process. This requires a bit of a culture shift.Â
âJust a fat package will not keep your employees satisfied. They must feel as a part of the family. Organizational culture is also linked to high employee morale and better retention ratesâ (Pratap, 2018)
Constant Feedback & Development Plans
Timeliness is important. Reviews need to be predictable and remain on schedule to be useful and effective. Teams will have to prioritize conducting reviews and recapping survey results.
Due to the small size of the HR team in comparison to the team they serve, not having enough support can be a blocker in implementing regular review segments and development plans.
If there is not a performance program already in place or the current one has limitations, a blocker to implementation could be facilitating such a massive process and introducing a new technology to the population.Â
Training management on consistency and standardization of the review process and system is a big component of rolling out a new performance initiative. The alternative could bring potential discrimination and unequal pay liabilities.
Recognition of Innovation & Cooperation
The most successful review programs provide an intrinsic value to their employees. With this comes increased potential costs through salary increases, bonuses, or other financial compensation.Â
Rewarding cross-function collaboration requires in-depth knowledge of cross-functional requirements and opportunities to accurately assess effectiveness.Â
Change doesnât happen overnight, especially for a company that has historically valued profits and finance over a comprehensive approach. It will be an uphill battle proving worth to subjective measures like creativity and employee satisfaction.Â
Performance Management in the Tech Sector
If IBM is not able to implement changes quickly, employees may become disengaged, which will lead to turnover.
Filling roles with the right people is crucial in pushing technology-driven objectives. Teams not having enough resources or time to recruit will impact productivity.Â
Diversity is a selling point to the industryâs top talent, lack of diversity can thwart the curation and development of a learning culture.Â
Employees may see training as a distraction from work not enrichment which will make them closed off to the idea of training.Â
There is a lack of oversight and visibility due to the size of the learning & development team. Even with consultants, a large-scale program can be difficult to maintain long-term.Â
Potential increased costs like pulling employees away from work to conduct reviews, time managers spend on reviews, paying for additional technology, employee well-being, and additional headcount for trainers or consultants.Â
The more debilitating challenges center around changing the culture and investment of the teams either in additional headcount, technology, or training. To overcome some of the challenges IBM needs to:
View the additional costs as an investment and not an expense
Understand that being a leader in the technology space also encompasses providing a stellar experience for people
Understand that transformative change does not happen overnight
Be prepared to pivot if members of the organization arenât adapting to the processes
Overall, IBM has a promising future if it can continue to grow at the proper pace and continue to invest in their craft and their employees.Â
Reference:
Mrinmay Dey in Bengaluru, âIBM to pause hiring in plan to replace 7,800 jobs with AI, Bloomberg reportsâ, Bloomberg, May 2, 2023,Â
âWhat is training and development?â, IBM, https://www.ibm.com/topics/training-development
Aneesh Raman, âHow IBM Centered Its Talent Strategy on Skills â and Advice for Other Organizations Just Getting Startedâ, Linked in, May 11, 2023,Â
IBM embraced a skills-first approach to talent with an apprenticeship program that encompasses roles in cybersecurity, software development,
âGenerative AI and the future of work in Americaâ, McKinsey Global Institute, July 26, 2023
Generative AI has the potential to change the future of work in America. We look at which jobs will be in demand and which ones may be at ri
Maribel LopezâIt's Time To Reinvent Your Human Resources Strategy And IBM Wants Watson To Be Your Guideâ. Forbes, December 2, 2018
IBM provides new artificial intelligence offering to improve talent acquisition, retention and retraining of the workforce. AI training is p
âOrg chartâ, Orgio https://theorg.com/org/ibm
âHR Tech 2022: IBM: Digital Transformation and HR Elevationâ, Human Resource Executive, September 21, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCHUJ3-k3TE
âIBM chief human resources officer discusses her company's employee experienceâ, HR training, Human Resource Executive, October 27, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUr_97bOYU4
Human Resource Executive, https://www.ibm.com/ibm/history/documents/pdf/hr.pdfă
Martin Reeves, Mihnea Moldoveanu, and Adam Job, âWhy Conflicting Ideas Can Make Your Strategy Strongerâ Harvard Business Review, May 31, 2023,
In a volatile, uncertain world, successful strategies are those conceived as portfolios of options rather than as roadmaps. But to successfu
Katherine C. Kellogg and Constance Noonan Hadley âHow AI Can Help Stressed-Out Managers Be Better Coachesâ Harvard Business Review, June 21, 2023
The expectations placed on managers to assess and guide their employeesâ performance have increased, a trend amplified by generational shift
âIBM Annual Report 2022â, IBM
âWORKFORCE ANALYTICS: A CRITICAL EVALUATION: How Organizational Staff Size Influences HR Metricsâ, SHRM,
Gil, D. (2022, August 3). Building on our history of innovation for the future of IBM. IBM Research Blog. https://research.ibm.com/blog/future-of-ibm-innovation Â
Gurchiek, K. (2022, November 18). Report: HR Pros Rank Top Reasons for Turnover. SHRM. Retrieved December 10, 2023, from https://www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-news/pages/report-hr-pros-rank-top-reasons-for-turnover.aspx
Aldina, S., Dr. (2023, December 5). WHY ARE HAPPY EMPLOYEES MORE PRODUCTIVE IN THE WORKPLACE? Well Steps. Retrieved December 10, 2023, from https://www.wellsteps.com/blog/2022/05/17/happy-employees-more-productive/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CHappy%20employees%20are%20productive%20employees,the%20workplace%20than%20unhappy%20employees.
Murray, R. (2018). Workplace communications â five ways for leaders to make it better. NZ Business + Management, 32(7), M16.
Changing a Company's Culture - Brief History of Starbucks
Submitted to CSU
01/17/2021.
Starbucks has always been a company that goes above and beyond for its employees. In the early 2000s, Starbucks offered employee benefits such as tuition reimbursement and was one of the few hospitality companies that offered line-level employees pay above the minimum wage threshold. Their employee-first approach ideology began well before that, dating back to 1988, when they gave both full-time and part-time employees benefits. Starbucksâ inclusivity did not stop there, throughout the years, the positivity of their environment created ERGs for employees from all walks of life that garnered thousands of participants on a global scale. Starbucks was also active in hiring over 10,000 military veterans and their spouses creating spaces for employees with disabilities to learn and expand their skills. While all of these initiatives seemed to give equity to all of their employees, there was a particular group that seemed to be missed.
In December of 2014, Starbucks held an open forum to address the issue of âRace in Americaâ, then President Howard Schultz hosted an impromptu meeting in the Seattle offices to discuss some of the travesties that were occurring across the United States. Schultz created a safe place in an uncommon setting for people to share their experiences. Noting that âDespite the raw emotion around the events and their underlying racial issues, we at Starbucks should be willing to talk about them internally. Not to point fingers or to place blame, and not because we have answers, but because staying silent is not who we areâ(Starbucks, 2014). Shortly after in 2017, Schultz left his position as the President of Starbucks for the second time in the companyâs history. In 2018, a firestorm occurred that sent the media into a frenzy. Two African American men were asked to leave a Starbucks after being accused of not buying anything and ultimately were arrested after a manager decided to call the cops on charges of âtrespassingâ. Historically, Starbucks has always been a gathering place and has not traditionally forced patrons to purchase food or drink to lounge in their seating area. From then on, several reports came out about unfair and biased treatment towards customers of color. One suit alleged, âthat Starbucks not only treats its Caucasian customers more favorably than African-American customers but also calls local law enforcement to surveil and intimidate African-American women who are peacefully requesting equal treatment and equal serviceâ(Forthright, 2020). After forcing baristas to wear pride shirts in June of 2020(and firing one for her refusal due to religious reasons), Starbucks also denied baristas to wear BLM shirts to show support at a very sensitive time. Their statement in support of their decisions was that âThere are agitators who misconstrue the fundamental principles of the Black Lives Matter movement â and in certain circumstances, intentionally repurpose them to amplify divisiveness.â White privilege is rooted in having the privilege to define whatâs divisive by simultaneously gaslighting and dividing another protected class.
Creating a culture of accountability is truly the only way to ensure that initiatives arenât just performative and for the moment. However, I would not have taken the same route Starbucks did. To have an employee call the cops on patrons due to their skin color is not just a training issue itâs a structural issue. From the first incident in 2017, Starbucks should have used some of its resources to sufficiently train people on how to be proper humans specifically to black and brown people. It was unacceptable and irresponsible for them to say that speaking out against police brutality is âdivisiveâ. Racism is insidious and it doesnât act on its own. Most instances of racism in a work environment occur because the company welcomes racism. It is welcomed and encouraged through jokes, discriminatory hiring practices, progressive discipline, and all aspects of the managerial and HR function. That incident shouldâve launched a company-wide investigation starting at the executive level to weed out those who operate with implicit bias. A zero-tolerance initiative and accountability for senior leaders would have accompanied it. From there, Starbucks would have been able to enact diverse hiring without waiting 5 entire years. A well-thought-out and fully flushed plan including training to address gaps, quarterly talent reviews to remove folks from the organization, intentional hiring, and the continuation of the prioritization of the ERGs can certainly help retention but only over time and only if the ones responsible for propelling the culture forward are willing participants. Starbuck's changes are not overnight and the organization still has a lot of change to undergo and tons more work to do in the DE&I space. I recommend any company that has retention issues to assess pay, benefits, and leadership and if those are in place, thereâs probably a missed opportunity with equity and diversity.Â
References
Cramer, M. (2020) Baristas at Starbucks Accuse Service Company of Abuse and Pay Gaps, New York Times
Denham, Hammon. (2020) In reversal, Starbucks will allow employees to wear âBlack Lives Matterâ T-shirts, Washington Post
Dingle, D. (2020) TWO YEARS AFTER LANDMARK RACIAL BIAS TRAINING, STARBUCKS ADVANCES CIVIL RIGHTS AND INCLUSION AGENDA, Black Enterprise
Forthright Law, P.C. African-American Customer Sues Starbucks For Racially Biased Service
Lee, A. (2020) Lawsuit claims Starbucks employee fired for stance on religion, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Leinward, P. & Davidson, V. (2016) How Starbucksâs Culture Brings Its Strategy to Life, Harvard Business Review
Pratap, Abhijeet. (2018) Organizational Culture at Starbucks: An Analysis, Notesmatic
Starbucks,(2020) Starbucks Equity, Inclusion, and Diversity Timeline, Stories and News https://stories.starbucks.com/press/2019/starbucks-equity-and-inclusion-timeline/
Starbucks,(2020) Civil Rights Assessment Summary, Stories and News https://stories.starbucks.com/uploads/2020/02/Civil-Rights-Assessment-Summary.pdfTyko, Kelly. (2020) Starbucks to tie executive pay to diversity goals as it announces mentorship program, anti-bias training requirements, USA Today
Your work as head of HR for Lemonade Inc. has been exceptional so far. In fact, your video presentation went so well that your CEO has asked you to begin crafting monthly tips for the entire organization of topics that they should consider with respect to best practices in minimizing employee relations problems in the future. The CEO has asked you to put together a short simple checklist of important issues to consider with respect to guidelines for each of the stand managers to consider when establishing wages, hours and best practices in managing the largely young, mostly part time and often transitory employees at our stands. The CEO is a big fan of simple one or two pages of bullet points that provide general guidance or 'things to think about'. This summer Lemonade Inc. will be hiring 50 interns (both paid and unpaid) to join our team. The CEO wants you to help craft this policy and highlight 10 tips to managers that they should always consider relating to managing our upcoming summer hiring initiative to bring in Interns to work at each of our stands.
Below is an outline of content to be delivered over the next 4 months. The idea is to deliver short, palatable tips in an order than makes sense and aligns with the review cycle of the company. We know through multiple studies that employees tend to leave companies for quite a few reasons but mainly because of a bad leader(s), better pay or an opportunity for growth. Proximity is the easiest way to not only mitigate turnover but to also minimize employee relations issues.Â
Effective 1:1s
Reset behavior, address quick gains, collaboratively prioritize, and create alignment
Create an easy and palatable shared agenda
Practice reviewing SMART goals as a function of the agenda
Preventing Burnout
Understanding the causes:
Conflicting demands
Unclear Objectives
Boredom
Conflict
Lack of Balance
Pointing out the symptoms of burnout:
Frustration
Lashing out
Withdrawal from work/co-workers
Change in behavior or performance
What can managers do?
Intercept at early warnings
Determine the source
Build Connections
Foster inclusion
Develop an action plan
Continuously follow up
Inclusive Leadership
Valuing and celebrating dissenting opinions
Seeking out opportunities to be more inclusive in thought, words, and action
Reviewing the impact of unconscious biasÂ
Exploring exclusionary and inclusive behaviorsÂ
Taking initiative
Create a culture of civility and respect
Publicly acknowledge individual contributions
Provide opportunities for career growth and job expansion
Conducting Reviews
Continuously gather information throughout the whole year and avoid recency bias
Provide honest feedback
Review objectively and be specific using dates, times, and examples
Conversations should be 50% performance and feedback-based and 50% future goals
Schedule interrupted time to have the performance conversation and allow some time for two-way dialogueÂ
Dear Lemonaders,
Intern season is upon us! While that means tons of excitement, engagement, and everything under the sun, it also means reminders from your favorite team, the people team. This season is short, itâs only 3 months so make it count!Â
This year we will have both paid and unpaid interns. Our paid interns will all start at the same starting rate (wage transparency and equality matter). They will be considered employees and have access to company perks within their designated level. All unpaid interns must work in accordance with all FLSA rules. There are quite a few, hereâs a few reminders for our veteran Lemonaders and some new information for our newbies:
Intern's work must complement not replace employees
This means your intern should not be crafting your PowerPoint presi for the marketing team!
They must have a significant educational purpose for the intern
They should be gaining substantial knowledge from the internship, not just filing papers!
They must be able to receive academic credit at their current educational institutionÂ
This requires them to be enrolled in an eligible higher education program!
Interns are not eligible for employee perks but will receive a travel and lunch stipend
FLSA rules not ours!
We will help facilitate the necessary paperwork from your interns prior to their start date. Unfortunately, we can not allow interns to work (not even for a minute, no exceptions) without the proper paperwork. If you have a question about whether or not your intern is paid or unpaid, please see this sheet linked here and reach out if you have any further questions.
Outside of the FLSA, there are some additional items to keep in mind throughout the process and the season!
Review the attached recruiting kit and know the ins & outs of interviewing (and also what to say versus what not to say).
You should know:
There are questions we are not allowed to ask, you need to know these.Â
Keep the process consistent for each person, and have your question guidelines handy.Â
Be on time and show up as the best version of yourself, they are interviewing us just as much as we are interviewing them.
Brush up on company policies and rules. Weâre always here to help but the handbook was created for reference!Â
You should know:
Time off policies & procedures including PTO, parental leave, and bereavement.
Our policy on fraternization and siblings.
All employees receive health benefits the first after 30 days of hire. Most interns will be on their parent plan, but this is still important to give them.Â
Our payday is Friday, this is important!
How can you prepare?
Take the manager refresher course on harassmentÂ
Take the managing different groups in the workforce course
Review our latest newsletter on preventing and managing burnout(attached)
Weâre here to help! If anything is confusing or overwhelming, please do not hesitate to reach out to us for assistance. We will send out weekly newsletters with valuable information on Friday afternoons. During intern season, we will also have office hours on Weds mornings and Thursday afternoons, with invites to follow.Â
As a woman of color, I find it difficult to not have my identities intersect and affect multiple parts of my life simultaneously. My experience at my last employer is exactly this personified. As I've discussed on my personal TikTok page, I made the difficult decision to leave my job after working there for a little over 2 years. It pains me to be a habitual job hopper but it's my unfortunate reality. If you don't identify with a marginalized identity, then it's difficult to comprehend what the black experience in white corporate America is like. Goredema talks about the reason why many black workers job-hop.
Not everyone is having the same experience, but fatigue, exhaustion, frustration, and isolation are taking their toll and [SHRM] research data shows that.(Gonzales, 2022)
Black people and people of color in general often become teachers in roles that don't require them to teach. They become professors in all the isms, respectability politics, microaggressions, and overall professionalism. They take on the mental load that becomes physically exhausting.
Most white people have never had to look for people who look like them in an environment. They do not understand why representation is important because they've never experienced an absence of it. In my Racial Justice Fellowship at Rutgers University, we were painfully tasked with watching White People, a documentary on MTV. There was an interesting part in which there were almost exclusively white teachers who taught students on native land. The dichotomy between traditional educational structures and this one presented an interesting power dynamic. It required the teachers to assess not just race but colonialism with a different lens whereas if they taught in a traditional public school setting this would not be the case. Yet, this is another example of how people of color become teachers. Although the actual teachers should be teaching, they are learning bits and pieces of history from the students. The responsibility of teaching and mental anguish starts from a young age.
When you work in Human Resources, you are an advocate against the mistreatment of others while often being mistreated yourself. Companies bitch about desiring their teams to bring their authentic selves to work but my authentic self is having uncomfortable conversations about race and not talking about why my hair grew 12 inches since the last time you all saw me. But on to the thoughts..
These thoughts are written from my perspective as a black woman but may be useful to anyone experiencing trauma at work and needing to heal.
1. Speak up even if you are afraid of losing your job. (And document)
There were so many instances where I talked myself out of speaking up or waited until something had gotten way out of hand before saying anything. Don't just be vocal in meetings or in person, make sure to keep an electronic trail as well. Send fully fleshed re-caps. Link articles to support your point. Repeat if you need to. Your voice could prevent someone else from experiencing the same thing. Ask for the things that you need. Companies are constantly dishing out disparate treatment, ask! And if you are declined, remind them that you know they've done these things before and can do it for you.
2. Organizations hire racists, and you don't have to accept it.
I changed my original text about organizations being racist. Of course, there are some organizations that were built on racism, slavery, and oppression like Unilever but most organizational culture at companies is built by the people. It's not a stand-alone institution. Companies do hire racists and you don't have to work somewhere that does. There came a point when I compared my then-current state to my past ones. I would often say at least I'm not in a basement(I was stuck in a basement for like 4 hours twice a week as a consultant). Or, at least I'm not the ONLY black person(I would become the only black person in HR or in my role at several companies). Or at least the racism is packaged in microaggressions(I was asked for feedback and then told I always have something to say). I wrote about the illusion of inclusion nearly 2 years ago, and unfortunately, this concept still rings true. There is no value in accepting the lesser of two evils, especially when it comes to your mental health.
3. Workplace trauma is not your norm, nor should it ever be.
As a society, we've normalized hustle culture, working crazy hours, and chasing the bag amongst many other ridiculous things. When you're accustomed to living in chaos, it becomes a component of who you are. It becomes embedded in your personality.
Repeated micro-aggressions in the workplace and in some cases outright retaliation and bullying that induces trauma (Gorgla, 2020)
Dealing with an erratic narcissist became a regular occurrence for me. Before I left my position at my most recent employer, I reviewed old emails that were obviously a cry for help from this person at "it again" with no one to curtail their behavior. After almost a year, it turned into textbook retaliation that occurred until the end of my duration there. Citing that during my last week, this individual removed me from meetings to prevent me from saying farewell.
4. Remember that we are not trying to convince them to change, simply pointing out the error of their ways.
This was so helpful to me later on after the onset of frustration. We know the world is inherently racist, and it's not likely that I am going to change the racism that lives inside of someone. But, my goal in advocating for myself is to let them know that the behavior is not acceptable. PERIOD.
5. If you can afford to, take time off and touch grass, seriously.
If your job can not grant you a leave of absence and you're able to negotiate a severance or get some sort of unemployment income to leave, take it! My first month was an adjustment. I hadn't known life without chaos in such a long time it was hard to figure out what to do. Part of my personality became this job and I clearly had Stockholm syndrome. I had no idea what to do without my abuser. This is month 3 of leaving my job and I've accomplished so much. I am slowly remembering bits and pieces of myself pre-job and even discovering new interests as a result.
If you are experiencing some of the things mentioned in this post and would like to chat, feel free to hit the ask button or message me on social media. Also, know your rights. Discrimination and harassment are illegal and in most cases, retaliation is a form of harassment. I always recommend taking legal action. Not enough of us do.
Pierce v. Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp. 84 N.J. 58 (1980)
Facts of the Case
This case argues whether or not an employee who submitted a resignation can seek damages for wrongful termination. In short, the employee in question had consistently pointed out that the project she was working on contained a product that was medically debatable and one she deemed unethical for use.
With the exception of whistle-blower protections or an explicit contract, common law does not have protections for employees who are at-will. The whistle-blower statutes under OSHA require that there be a violation of federal consumer product safety in order to grant protections. Although throughout the case there were questions of morals and ethics, it is not confirmed that there were any accusations or confirmations of law-breaking in the creation of this product.Â
Dr. Pierce was a medical doctor employed with Ortho who manufactures and develops therapeutic and reproductive drugs. She started working for them in 1973, as an Associate Director of Medical Research. Within two years, she was promoted to the Director of Medical Research, Therapeutics where she led one of the three major sections of the company. She was to oversee the products from concept to consumption including safety, marketing and effectiveness.Â
In 1975, after being in her role for almost two years, Dr. Pierce was leading a product named loperamide, a liquid drug that was supposed to ease diarrhea in infants and adults. The product contained similar ingredients as its European counterpart, however, it contained an ingredient(saccharin)that was unsuitable for the US version. The production team agreed that it needed to be reformulated with a lesser amount of saccharin and that it would be done in the next 3 months. Â
In March, the product team decided to move forward with creating the liquid drug as is with the exception of Dr. Pierce. The marketing dept had sent a directive to the team that sparked this decision. Continuing to formulate this version meant that they would file for FDA approval to have the product tested on humans, once approved.Â
On April 23, Dr. Pierce sent in a letter of disapproval to the project team affirming her disagreement with the decision citing that âthere was no justification for seeking FDA permission to use the drug in light of medical controversy over the safety of saccharinâ. On May 9th, she met with her supervisor Dr. Pasquale to again discuss her concerns about the product. She stated that working on this product was in violation of her Hippocratic oath, and that it could potentially be harmful to elderly folks and infants. She said the risk didnât make sense since they were going to be working on a reformulation. They agreed to have dissenting opinions on the matter and after the meeting, Dr. Pierce was removed from the project. On May 15, Dr. Pasquale asked her to choose other projects to work on and on Jun 16, they met to discuss said projects. During the meeting, Dr. Pierce did not choose a new and project and the next day sent a letter of resignation outlining her impression of the meeting on the previous day.Â
âUpon learning in our meeting June 16, 1975, that you believe I have not `acted as a Director', have displayed inadequacies as to my competence, responsibility, productivity, inability to relate to the Marketing Personnel, that you, and *64 reportedly Dr. George Braun and Mr. Verne Willaman consider me to be non-promotable and that I am now or soon will be demoted, I find it impossible to continue my employment at Ortho.âÂ
Dr. Pierce sought damages on the following basis:
Her former employer and constituents asked her to behave in a way that violated the Hipprocratic oath she took
Because she was a physician, she was governed by ethical standards in accrodance with federal and state, statutory and case law to protect human health and public well-being
In accordance with common law, there is no issue terminating an employee at will. Ortho moved to petition for a summary judgment attempting to avoid going to trial which was granted under the following basis: a resignation was not a termination and Dr. Pierce was an at-will employee.Â
âIn reversing the trial court, the Appellate Division ruled that a plenary hearing was necessary before deciding whether to adopt an exception to the common law rule permitting an employer to fire an employee at will for any reason. 166 N.J. Super. at 342, 399 A.2d 1023.â
Issues
Was Dr. Pierce wrongfully discharged for bringing up issues of ethics or morality that she felt violated her oath?
Was there a mention of a public health or safety issue?
Do at will employees have protections for issues of sworn ethics or morality?
Because Dr. Pierce willingly resigned and it was not clear or explicitly stated that she was asked or forced to resign, there was no evidence stating that her resignation was more than it was, a resignation. Furthermore, without Dr. Pierce mentioning the legality or the potential of litigation, the consequences of moving forward werenât clear to the organization and Dr. Pierceâs supervisors. Technically, although the levels of the particular drug were being debated internally, it wasnât fully expressed that there would be negative effects, that it was illegal or harmful, since the formulated drug was accepted in Europe. Additionally, the project team had already agreed to formulate a different version of the product, so in this instance, the company was ready to fix an issue they had already identified and the product was not in trials yet.
Decisions
Although loperamide had previously been tested on humans, Ortho never submitted an IND to the FDA for approval. So although Dr. Pierce was asked to continue work she did not agree with, this work would not have been cleared to be tested on humans without FDA approval which was impossible without an application for it. Unfortunately, Dr. Pierce did not outline which law or morality was broken by her work and ultimately the oath does not prevent doing work that is not completed by humans. Furthermore, preventing companies from doing research would hinder their ability to find groundbreaking drugs.Â
Reasoning
Dr. Pierce never explicitly stated that the product would cause harm, only that it was a controversial product that she did not support. During testimony, Dr. Pierceâs council admitted that there was no intention to submit a question of safety for the ingredient to the jury. Additionally, common law does not prohibit the exploration of drugs that are not favorable or legal(a clear public policy or mandate); it only makes recommendations based on testing and sales to the general public.Â
Separate Opinions
The majority ruling was that a professional employee should not be discharged for refusing to violate moral, ethical, or legal obligations imposed on them. Judge Pashman entered a dissenting opinion. It was that Dr. Pierce was not eligible for any protections because of the lack of clear public policy and that this ruling was applied incorrectly in this case. While Dr. Pierce expected Ortho to understand and abide by her opinion, they were not required to do so and were not required to keep her employed. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on the Principles of Medical Ethics, American Medical Association 3 (1979). An employee does not have a right to continued employment when he or she refuses to conduct research simply because it would contravene his or her personal morals.Â
Analysis
I believe a summary judgment should not have been granted in this case and it should have gone to trial. Both opinions affirmed the status quo but they applied the logic differently due to the review of the facts.Â
This is a multi-paper project. This portion was submitted to Rutgers on 10/10/2023.
The United States ranks last amongst developed nations for their benefits for employees. With a low federal minimum wage and low minimum wages in the country's largest localities, minimum sick pay and leave options, the US is not a desirable place for the majority of hourly workers. States also increase wages and add different coverages but as of today, 15 states have the federal minimum wage as their minimum wage, only 15 states have mandated sick pay and only 9 states still have COVID-mandated covid sick pay. Georgia and Wyomingâs minimum wage is currently at $5.15 but they must abide by the FLSA rules when paying employees. When it comes to parental leave, employees have to work a year for FMLA which is unpaid, and in most areas that have short-term disability, you have to be employed for a minimum of 6 months. Even with the protection, there are still some workarounds that an employer could employ in order to terminate someone on a protected leave. Currently, there are no widely accepted legal paid programs for non-birthing parents in the United States at this time. Some employees may be eligible for paid family leave in states like New York and Pennsylvania.
When it comes to healthcare, the United States does have Medicaid and Medicare, generally for the unemployed, disabled, and individuals over the age of 65. The working class is allowed to elect their employer's plan(if the employer is required to/decides to offer a plan) but has to pay an exorbitant amount of money for minimal health coverage. The average working American pays about $111 for employer-sponsored medical coverage (USA Today, 2023). Someone making the federal minimum wage would have to work nearly 16 hours to pay for healthcare. This doesnât account for co-pays, deductibles, co-insurance or out-of-pocket maximums for the plan. When it comes to end-of-life or retirement programs, only 11 states have mandated plans. Even in states with mandated plans, it is not required to have an employer match. Social Security is an option depending on the number of work credits obtained throughout the years and the maximum for someone who is retiring at the latest age of 70 is $4,555(Orem, 2023). In New York, the average rent for a studio apartment is $3,430(Renthop, 2023), just to put it in perspective. Â
Portugal on the other hand ranks extremely high for employee benefits and protections(ITUC-CSI, 2020). Portuguese laws dictate that employees should work 40 hours per week and 8 hours a day. There are exceptions for overtime but the overtime can not be consistent. In terms of time off, Portugal has a robust time off plan. There are 13 recognized public holidays that are off with pay, 22 days of paid leave after a year of employment, 120 or 150 days of paid parental leave, 30 days of pre-natal leave and 42 days of leave after birth, 15 days for marriage, 2-20 days for bereavement and 1095 days for illness paid at a percentage of the salary. There are also protections for the amount of work or overtime that an employee can do when they return from leave.Â
Portugal welcomes collective bargaining agreements or CBAs by industry which gives all folks in the same industry/position access to equal pay and benefits. For industries without a CBA, the statutory benefits mandated to all employees include all types of employees and do not differentiate between part-time, full-time, or remote. Contractors and self-employers are also protected if they meet certain provisions under the law like if the company provides tools for the work i.e. a computer or phone, if clock-in and out times are recorded, and if exchange for the work money is given regularly. Employers are not allowed to arbitrarily dismiss employees and allow employees to take Garden Leave upon exiting an organization if both parties agree. Garden leave is when an employee is severed from the company but is still receiving pay in the form of severance, regular pay, or paid time off. Portugal also has protections for dismissal including the employee's right to agree or disagree with the end of an assignment. Portugal also has universal healthcare, so paying for healthcare is not a concern of the employee or employer. Although Portugal has a ton of benefits for employees, their hourly rates are low. The minimum wage in Portugal is 760 Euros per month and 10,640 per year which translates to $806.03 and $11,284.36 respectively. Portugal does have a state-funded retirement fund with a max of 395 euros per month and companies are also allowed to have private funds. Portugalâs estimated cost of living is $652.10 monthly.Â
Itâs clear that the United States pales in comparison to Portugal despite having a higher rate of pay From first glance, it appears that operating in Portugal while beneficial for the employees will be extremely expensive for the company. Although the cost of healthcare is not dependent upon the firm, the amount of time off that is required to be paid is astronomical and potentially disruptive. Not having an employee for a month could be detrimental to an operation but not having them for up to 1000 days is not conducive to a successful business operation. Especially with the idea that not only do you have to pay that individualâs salary but you will also have to find another person to replace them.Â
An obstacle that we would need to be extremely prepared and buttoned up for is the laws governing termination in the organization. The majority of the United States is at-will and Starbucks has a reputation for exercising that right. New processes and procedures need to be created and new habits need to be formed in order to be compliant with those laws.Â
References
Iacurci, G. (2021, February 4). U.S. Is worst among developed nations for worker benefits. CNBC. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.cnbc.com/2021/02/04/us-is-worst-among-rich-nations-for-worker-benefits.html
Rogers, L. (2023, March 31). U.S. Is worst among developed nations for worker benefits. Employers Lawyers Blog. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.employerslawyersblog.com/2023/03/states-that-still-require-paid-sick-leave-for-covid-19.html
(2023, January 1). Paid Sick Leave Laws By State for 2023. Paycor. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.paycor.com/resource-center/articles/paid-sick-leave-laws-by-state/#:~:text=Which%20states%20have%20mandatory%20paid,mandatory%20paid%20sick%20leave%20laws.
Anderson, G. (2023, August 18). Minimum Wage by State in 2023 and Beyond â All You Need to Know. Workforce. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://workforce.com/news/minimum-wage-by-state-2022-all-you-need-to-know
Tretina, K. (2023, June 23). How much does health insurance cost in 2023? USA Today. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.usatoday.com/money/blueprint/health-insurance/how-much-is-health-insurance/#:~:text=On%20average%2C%20a%20single%20person,spending%20to%20meet%20your%20deductible.
Martin, S. (n.d.). Employment and Labour Law Portugal. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://iclg.com/practice-areas/employment-and-labour-laws-and-regulations/portugal
(n.d.). Portugal Labor Law: For Hiring And Managing Employees. Multiplier. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.usemultiplier.com/portugal/employment-laws#:~:text=Portugal's%20employment%20law%20obliges%20employers,paid%20leaves%20after%20six%20months.
Orem, T. (2023, April 4). The Maximum Social Security Benefit in 2023. Nerd Wallet. Retrieved October 10, 2023, from https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/social-security/maximum-social-security-benefit#:~:text=The%20maximum%20Social%20Security%20benefit%20in%202023%20is%20%243%2C627%20at,and%20when%20they%20take%20benefits.
E-learning can be considered effective learning when it is comprised of multiple learning methods. Two years ago, I was attending a different University for my Master's program and the E-Learning did not have different aspects. We were required to do discussions, read our books, and write papers but there were no lectures or audio or video content for us to consume. It was very one-dimensional in terms of content and was also solely asynchronous and self-driven. Of course, it could be considered learning but in traditional classes, you are accustomed to seeing a variety of mediums. I do believe E-Learning is learning. I donât think how or where you receive information determines whether or not you are learning.Â
In E-Learning programs, there are many things that can alter the effectiveness of the program. Incorporating elements of active learning has been proven to be an effective method. When there is a two-way dialogue, training content is absorbed and remembered by the learner more easily. Multimedia is an excellent addition to the E-Learning outline because different people learn through a variety of mediums. Community interaction is also a huge part of the effectiveness of E-Learning. Using platforms like YouTube to share content also provides an increased level of accessibility as YouTube is widely available and allows exposure to different viewpoints on a set topic. Learners who are intrigued or fascinated by the material can also share it with their peers or on their own social media, engaging in meaningful discourse as we do during our discussions. Regarding the timing of videos, studies show that shorter videos are also more effective allowing for greater recall and processing. In E-learning, components of it can be interactive and are effective like clicking through lectures or answering a quiz at the end or middle of a chapter, whereas traditional classroom material is usually disseminated top-down.
There are certain parts of E-Learning that I think or ineffective and this is really based on the intention of the learning and type of content. For instance, itâs more difficult to teach competencies like how to use heavy machinery safely through video. There are tiny nuances or adjustments that would be caught by an in-person instructor that would be crucial to the job or in fact life-saving. When it comes to changing training content like videos, itâs much easier to change content in person over re-shooting and uploading a video. There are so many factors to consider in a private organization for example, if the previous trainer moved on, the new content would be shot in someone else's voice or likeness and wouldnât have continuity or consistent branding. As someone who has also created materials for PowerPoint and material for online courses, the asynchronous material needs to be much more developed and takes a longer time to create. When someone is presenting a presentation, they can speak through slides and present ideas on the fly but something recorded needs to have more information available visually.
Iâm sure this has been a question for every black person that has ever had to work under white leadership. Weâve all heard the buzzwords concerning diversity, equity and inclusion and as a black person, I have yet to work in an environment that encompassed all three of those. The way that DE&I happens in most companies pushes forth the narrative that black people are the difficult ones to work with. We are the ones with âattitudesâ because our voices lack vocal fry, we are the ones who arenât friendly because we are honest and authentic or refuse to be spoken to like children. Where is the disconnect?
Working in the hospitality space for the last 7 years has given me a unique opportunity to see the makeup of 15+ hospitality companies. The people of color are primarily at the bottom of the totem pole, some make it to mid positions after an excessive amount of experience, usually paid at a significantly lower rate than white counterparts, given more duties/expectations for performance and usually under a white facing or white person. The employees who do the work that actually brings in income are paid/treated the worst, as disposable garbage. While the individuals at the corporate level uphold discriminatory, unjust and classist practices. In Human Resources, the person above me has always been a white woman who just didnât get it. They were responsible for overseeing policies, procedures, health insurance, 401k for people whose plight they couldnât understand due to privilege. They have never had to work for the amount of the money the lowest paid person in the company is receiving at the age they are now. The majority of my peers have been gossipy white women that lack the capacity to comprehend the reason why a comment like âwho looks good in Indian colorsâ is racist. These are the types of things we carry with us home from toxic work environments as black people. White employees donât realize that the black experience is very different from their own says Ross, author of Everyday Bias: Identifying and Navigating Unconscious Judgments in Our Daily Lives (Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2014). Noting that while 65% of us say we have to work harder(which we do), only 13% of white people agree. (Roepe, 2021)
The field of HR is uniquely positioned to undo some of the systemic inequities that have been embedded in the workplace for generations. Despite this, the track record of HR departments driving social change and equity has been less than stellar, known more for protecting companies over employees and letting bad behaviors go unchecked. (Schmidt 2020)
Iâve always maintained that the structure behind recruiting was racist and intentionally created to keep black and brown people out of spaces of change and power. When you look at a companyâs retention rate especially when you break it out to include race, youâll find alarming patterns of black and brown people being pushed out of their positions through racists leaders who make work life so unbearable that they leave or they are performanced out. It is not a coincidence that a lot of black and brown people donât stay long at companies or canât get jobs but yet the positions that have the capacity to influence change require 20 years of experience when DE&I initiatives are barely 10 years old.Â
Iâve experienced the âillusion of inclusionâ at several places but most recently Aurify Brands. The illusion of inclusion happens when companies hire a few token individuals to meet their diversity quota. These roles are dedicated to people of color and when the previous person is pushed out, they usually replace it with a person of the same ethnicity. This gives the idea that the environment is inclusive when it actually isnât. Here, when I stated that I was experiencing racial gaslighting from a team member, who happened to be white woman in which my boss did nothing but recommend that we did mediation as if that was a fix for racism. The person in a similar position to mine previously position was constantly yelled at harassed by my boss and the person before that ended up quitting. Shortly after announcing my departure another person of color left the team. My experience there was personal to me but, Iâve witnessed the insidious racism inside of the organization as low of a level as supervisor and trickling up to the top.
African-Americans continue to face both explicit racism â stoked by the rise of white nationalism in the past few years â and subtle racism on the job. In the latter category, University of Utah professor emeritus Arthur Brief points to âaversiveâ racism (when people avoid those of different races or change their behavior around them) along with âmodernâ racism (when people believe that because blacks can now compete in the marketplace, they no longer face discrimination). (Roberts, 2019)
The confusion regarding racism is that white people think you have to wear a KKK hoodie in order to be a racist. Thatâs simply not the case. Making comments about someoneâs âethnicâ features including their hair, nose, eyes or lips are all rooted in racism. The surprising part is that white women understand sexism but pretend not to understand racism and colorism.Â
...according to both quantitative and qualitative data, working African-Americans â from those laboring in factories and on shop floors to those setting C-suite strategy â still face obstacles to advancement that other minorities and white women donât. They are less likely than their white peers to be hired, developed, and promoted. And their lived experience at work is demonstrably worse even than that of other people of color.(Roberts, 2019)
I always recommend that people of color leave environments that adversely affect their mental health. One life hack that I can share that will void the various changes on your resume is to partner with a recruiting company or headhunter for your search. Theyâre motivated by money not by color and if you are a solid candidate they will def get you a job, at least until we find a unicorn company like Bravely that actively welcomes and includes people of color.Â
âWhen âallyshipâ is defined as âusing oneâs power or position to support or advocate for coworkers with less power or status,â more than 80 percent of white women and men say that they see themselves as allies to colleagues of other races and ethnicities.â (Leanin, 2020) Unfortunately, less than half of Hispanic and black women acknowledge that they have an ally in their workplace. The math isnât mathing. Hypothetically, in an organization of 100 employees, with 10 that identify as BIPOC, that means less than 5 people acknowledge one of 90 people as an ally, thatâs a huge problem.Â
While allyship has been identified as a buzzword when it comes to race in the workplace, white people are confused about what being an ally fully encompasses. A more fleshed out definition of allyship is âa strategic mechanism used by individuals to become collaborators, accomplices, and coconspirators who fight injustice and promote equity in the workplace through supportive personal relationships and public acts of sponsorship and advocacyâ (HBR, 2020) Being an ally or having allyship is a lot more than just not being racist, sexist, or transphobic. Itâs being active, meaning you consistently stand up for those who are discriminated against. It means that you continuously hold those who make inappropriate comments and jokes accountable. It also looks like supporting people at the moment, calling out toxic and discriminatory behaviors in a group setting, and refusing to check toxic behavior in private. It also does not look like playing both sides and trying to deescalate a situation when someone is being gaslighted.Â
Being an ally is not a title you give yourself, itâs a title that must be given to you by a marginalized group. (Atcheson, 2018) Some signs that you could use more work before being considered an ally is if 1.you call yourself an ally but simultaneously proclaim that you need to do more to support the cause and 2. if people of color in your organization have never identified you as an âallyâ but are constantly giving you feedback about what you could be doing better. Being an ally means showing up to causes, events, and employee resource groups that you donât necessarily relate to but your effort shows everyone that is not a âyouâ problem but an âusâ problem.Â
While organizations have been quick to create bland and unactionable âactionâ plans relating to diversity, these items do not address the root of the problem. Superficially and performatively donating money to a black organization does not stop discrimination in your organization. Appointing a diversity leader to take on the burden of change that the leaders of the organization should be absorbing is contributing to maintaining the status quo. (Castelli, 2020)
Craig Forman wrote an article for Culture Amp outlining some practices to allyship. The first practice he recommended was to ask questions, I highly discourage asking questions and challenge white people to use the resources available at their fingertips to answer any questions. Asking a person of color why touching their hair is racist is unnecessary when a quick google search tells you everything you need to know about it.
One of the most important components of being an ally is believing experiences shared by marginalized individuals and avoid centering yourself. If someone shares a vulnerable story about being affected by racism or injustice, this is not a cue for you to talk about yourself. It is not a cue for you to minimize that individualâs experience by discussing something that youâve experienced in your life or to say that their experience could have been worst. In conclusion, dismantling the barriers of racism should be the responsibility of those who have had the luxury of experiencing white privilege and using it to their advantage whether inadvertently or purposely. In the case of racism, silence is compliance.Â
Resources:
Atcheson, S (2018), Allyship - The Key To Unlocking The Power Of Diversity
Forbes
Forman, C (n.d.), Four practices for being an equality allyÂ
How White Leaders Can Support Black Employees in 2021 & Beyond
Deciding to officially launch this blog on the first day of Black History month may seem a little cliche, but given the year that black people had to endure, I think itâs more than appropriate. And before you, as a white person, white facing person, POC thatâs not black says âeveryone had to endure this yearâ, I want you, for once to not make everything about you. This year, companies should learn that being inclusive is not a PR stunt or something you say to shut your minority employees up. It shouldnât be performative. Letâs not forget, Starbucks firing a young woman for refusing to wear an LGBT Pride shirt because it was against her religion, but the same Starbucks refusing to let employees of color wear Black Lives Matter shirts because supporting black lives is divisive. Go figure.Â
If you can lead with empathy like many of you claim, you should be able to extend that empathy as hard as you do for your white employees, to everyone. When your black employees start resigning from your organization but donât mention race at their exit interviews understand that it is 10/10 usually the reason they left. You donât have an inclusive environment that supports them. Your white team members spew hatred and racism without even realizing it because they are so used to living in their whiteness. If there is someone at your organization brave enough to force these conversations about race, you make it about your experience. You have never had to worry about being protected or being afraid to speak your mind. You have never had to worry about being blackballed or being threatened due to your âaggressiveâ tone, appearance, or demeanor. Pay attention.
The title is leading to only place blame on White leaders but the truth is there are so many people complicit. Asians, Pacific Islanders, Hispanics, and ânon-threateningâ black people are also complicit in insidious discrimination. Those who were adopted and grew up in white households, those who were privileged enough to attend white schools, those who have been protected, and essentially are products of white privilege. These recommendations are very surface level. The reason for that is that black people have done the work for white people time and time again, for free. Weâre tired. If you want more in-depth help, please reach out to a qualified, black, DE&I coach and pay them to help.
1. Avoid starting DE&I initiatives until your organization stops being racist
When it comes to DE&I initiatives, most companies think they are not the issue. Iâve heard CEOs say things like they canât find good diverse talent or that their culture isnât a fit for diversity. What that translates to is we like to be racist without repercussions and we do not want an environment that includes people that donât think/look like us. You canât retain diverse talent when your organization makes inappropriate jokes about race or calls a black personâs tone via email aggressive.Â
2. Stop thinking that DE&I initiatives are separate from HR
HR is recruiting, onboarding, progressive discipline, engagement, the whole employee lifecycle. DE&I is the surety that HR is being compliant in anti-racism and discrimination in those functions. Itâs that simple. Theyâre not separate. Your DE&I partner should be included in any meeting that includes your senior HR person.Â
3. White people can not effectively and efficiently determine what behaviors are discriminatory/racist
Someone who has never experienced bias, discrimination, or racism can not identify what it is. I have super thick, and kinky natural hair. Iâve had a senior leader ask me when I was going to get my hair done. Iâve also had someone tell me that my hair looks better when I straighten it. Iâve had someone ask if I stuck my finger in an electrical outlet. While those all sound like harmless jabs in a workplace, they are not. They are rooted in hatred and discrimination. The need to get my hair done insinuates that the way my hair grows out of my head is unacceptable. Imposing European standards of beauty upon a black person is downright disrespectful. These are very light-hearted examples but I have seen and experienced how gross it can be.Â
4. Martin Luther King Day is a non-negotiable, paid holiday for everyone
PERIOD. If your locations are open on MLK day, pay time and a half. If 80% of the workforce is people of color, this is a huge non-negotiable.Â
5. Stop demeaning black peopleâs experiences and LISTEN
You donât have to insert your experience of âdiscriminationâ every time a black person talks about racism. If someone says they experienced something, stop telling them that theyâre overreacting or making it about race.Â
The last point is truly the one that is the most impactful. Educate yourself. If you can head to google for anything, head to google to arm yourself with education about racism. Educate yourself about the history of America. Understand the experience of Black people in this country. Be an actual ally to them, not a performative one. I recommend putting the E first in DE&I. Itâs easier for people to understand equity than it is for them to understand diversity. That is a conversation for another day.Â
4 BENEFIT CHANGES YOUR COMPANY SHOULD CONSIDER IN 2021 IN RESPONSE TO COVID-19
2020 was a year filled with change and uncertainty. Most employers were not ready or equipped to deal with the ever-changing leave laws in their state, the complexity of the FFCRA, or the rapid shift in their employee needs. While the FFCRA expired back on December 31, 2020, there have been no known extensions or considerations. That leaves employers in limbo. While employees are still affected by COVID whether through contracting the virus itself, being close to those who have tested positive, or those whose small children have been impacted by school closures, "employers should be prepared to have a plan in place for 2021 that contemplates COVID-19-related leave scenarios and be prepared to comply with applicable state and federal leave laws," - Adam Kemper (2020)
There has been guidance from OSHA on what instances of COVID constitute a workplace injury however, without testing it is virtually impossible to determine the exact place of contraction(*excluding CA specific to healthcare workers). In addition to OSHA, there is the question of whether or not a positive COVID diagnosis is covered under the ADA and subject to the rule of reasonable accommodation. Due to this uncertainty, employers should be proactive by creating plans for different situations and relying on their HR team to deliver solid, equitable, and sound guidance.
Adding a provision of paid time off for employees exposed or diagnosed with COVID
In most states, companies can create different buckets of days of paid time off. Consult with legal counsel to see if adding an amount that is equal to the length of the quarantine period in the operational state either front-loaded or accrued is permissible. Depending on how companies classify this time, it may be subjected to payouts or rollovers depending on the laws in that particular state.
Adopt the Paid Family Leave provisions internally and extend eligibility
There's no law(except probably in California, kidding!)that says companies are not allowed to create an internal leave program. Adopting the Paid Family Leave provisions allows employers to stay consistent in regards to the level of pay and expectations but also allows the additional scenarios that aren't necessarily covered under state family leave. One of these additional instances could include extending leave to parents who do blended learning(online & in person) Â As always, consult with legal counsel before rolling our a new leave program.
Extending Bereavement Leave
With the high death tolls, it's imperative that employees feel supported during this time in more ways than one. If there are no paid bereavement leave offerings, now is probably the time to add this benefit on. For those who have bereavement leave available, there should be considerations to extend the paid amount of days for extra travel time and mourning as well. Companies are allowed to add documentation provisions for this leave, be sure to update any handbooks or PTO time, and to consult with legal before rolling out. Â
Adding additional free medical services
Money has been tight for everyone this year. Most organizations have to deal with increases in prices through their traditional medical insurance. If money is an issue, a way to be more generous without taking on hundreds of thousands in additional costs is employing a company like One Medical, which provides free rapid COVID testing at several locations. They can provide corporate rates and one-year contracts so that the organization can evaluate the usefulness of the program at the end of its life.
In this time of uncertainty, budget constraints are at the top of mind but the lingering results from the lack of employee morale can be expensive. The real cost of losing an employee hits astronomical amounts once hitting the 100k mark. "Up to 213 percent of annual salary for highly-educated executive positions. For example, the cost to replace a $100k CEO is $213,000." Real considerations should be made to make sure the employees that you do have feel valued, covered, and supported by their employer.
Articles
Coronavirus Relief Package Includes Key Workplace Provisions | Allen J. Smith J.D.
Record Workplace Exposures to COVID-19 | OSHA
Employee Retention the Real Cost of Losing an Employee | Christina Merhar