Second DSMP lore post of the day, welcome back 2022 BUT-
There's something that always puzzles me about people who claim cTechno could have just gotten both himself and cTubbo out of the Red Festival situation.
If that was an option, why wouldn't he have?
The answer is because it wasn't an option. ccTechno confirmed this. cTechno confirmed this. Using your brain confirms this.
ccTechno didn't even know his fireworks could kill people in one hit before his first shot - he assumed he'd have to shoot multiple times to kill Tubbo, let alone kill multiple people with one shot. By extension, cTechno didn't know either. Tubbo was unarmed and without armor. Techno would have needed to 1v2 while also keeping Tubbo safe, and that's assuming the crowd wouldn't have also joined the fight (which they did). The chances of either one or both of them dying anyway were practically 99%. So he chose to persevere his single life
Now, you can still argue about the morality of that choice. When Techno does apologise for the Red Festival during the Revenger stream, he doesn't say "sorry for not saving you" or even "sorry for not getting us both out". He says, "I should have been willing to die for my beliefs". cTechno knows he most likely couldn't have gotten them both out safely, but feels he should have risked dying in the attempt.
(this post isn't about the character development that led him to that statement, but just know it makes me lose it a bit /pos)
ccTechno spoke in length about how one of his annoyances with how some people regarded his character was that they assumed, because he was good at PVP, he could just effortlessly 1v1 multiple people, while that's not true. cTechno got his ass kicked during the prison escape, the Green Festival, and during Doomsday, even losing all but 1 heart on some occasions.
So it's frustrating when people claim cTechno could have just fought his way out of the Red Festival while also keeping Tubbo safe, without any proof to back that up. "He should have fought his way out," they say. "How? I don't know, he just should have. He's just that strong, I guess (<- never mind the fact cTechno also did flee the Red Festival itself because he dropped to below 3 hearts). No, I don't have proof that he could, or proof that cTechno thought he could but made a deliberate choice not to do so. I'm just saying it's so."
But let's pretend for a bit. Let's pretend that cTechno could have fought his way out with Tubbo safe and sound. Let's pretend that was an option and cTechno was fully aware of it being an option...
Why wouldn't he have?
What possible explanation is there for cTechno in character (or even ccTechno out of character) to not take that option?
This is the guy who tried to talk his way out of the situation, stalled for over three minutes in the hopes allies would intervene (to the point that cSchlatt called him out on it), and tried to leave the stage only for his way to be barred. Why would cTechno do all that, then see a chance to get both himself and Tubbo out without either of them needing to die, and then decide to kill Tubbo anyway? It makes no sense. And absolutely never have I gotten a proper response to this from anybody who has this 'lore opinion' (in quotations because if it's objectively untrue it's not an opinion lol, that's just making shit up).
cTechno didn't gain anything from killing cTubbo at the Red Festival. If anything, it made Pogtopia more divided and made the rebellion more stressed. It ruined his relationship with several people. Techno gave no indication that he wanted to kill Tubbo or took pleasure out of it, he tried to avoid it, he didn't plan for it to happen or want to be there. If he could have not done it, why would he? Like, it makes no sense for cTechno as a character unless you're claiming he just wanted to do it for shits and giggles? He's just an asshole, I guess? Which, if that's your takeaway of the character, it's dumb and doesn't add up.
It definitely makes no sense from a writing standpoint unless you're claiming you know cTechno better than ccTechno does or are somehow claiming ccTechno was lying when he said that cTechno didn't see any other way out of that situation. In which case, like, I think that's really disrespectful. Plus, if ccTechno didn't even know, how could cTechno possibly know?
So yeah, that's my two cents on why "cTechno could have just fought his way out of the Red Festival while keeping cTubbo safe" isn't just completely inaccurate to events, it also has no narrative basis.



















