Am I Thinking Critically?
Most of us have deeply held beliefs and opinions about the world that we feel justified in defending without thinking critically about what conventions have led us to believe them. I drafted this quick list of questions to cause you to think critically about an issue (i.e ethics and morality in pornography, womenâs reproductive rights, gay marriage). This is short and doesnât even begin to cover a comprehensive method of analyzing belief systemsâŠ.so feel free to add more!!!
1. Who taught me to believe this? 2. Is the person who encouraged me to believe this in a position of power over me or are they a peer? (i.e a parent, boss, or teacher versus a coworker, friend, sibling) 3. Who/what group of people is the most widely known supporter of this belief? 4. What would the proponents of this belief stand to gain from my enforcement/complacency in this belief? 5. What would they stand to lose? 6. Who is harmed from this belief? (Think VERY hard before answering âno oneâ- most contested issues throughout history put at least one group at a disadvantage/directly harms them socioeconomically/physically/emotionally) 7. Have I pursued both sides of this issue in a reasonable, open manner or have I been too upset or frustrated to consider new ideas? 8. Are peopleâs safety, bodily autonomy, basic human rights such as food, clean water, freedom to express their own opinions at stake in my enforcement or complacency of this belief? 9. Am I using logical fallacies/propaganda/stereotyping/âbuzz wordsâ/slurs/threats to enforce this belief? (In my own thoughts and out loud) 10. Do I believe most of the same things of my friends/family/colleagues/social media tell me or do I challenge the status quo and think for myself by doing my own research and seeking unbiased information?
11. How quickly has this belief spread to popular media and acceptance, especially in comparison to other beliefs that challenge the status quo? Can the speed of this acceptance have to do with the fact that it works hand in hand with already-existing power structures?
12. Do I have a firm grasp of the historical context behind my belief? Am I supporting regressive movements?
13. Who do I feel opposed to most? Is the group I feel opposed to made up mostly of marginalized people who are speaking out against my belief?
14. Do I have a clear understanding of why I believe the things I do? If someone asks me to explain my stance, will I be able to do so in a logical manner?
15. If someone has a point I disagree with but I donât have reasoning against, is my goal to do whatever is necessary to cement my belief and âwinâ the argument, or am I willing to consider and research their point so I have a clearer understanding of the matter?
16. Am I using ahistorical language? Am I referring to a marginalized group using words that render that group an acceptable target?
17. Do I value looking at the facts to make an informed decision, or do I value pushing my viewpoint as the truth?Â
18. Am I staying aware of misinformation, and how/why that misinformation may be being spread?


























