Plural Kit & Communicative Accommodations
Okay so due to a few posts we saw recently we realized the discussion of Plural Kit has come up once again. We made a post that was very poorly written a bit ago that we took down due to how ineffective it was to explain what our stance is as well as additional conversations this has reminded us of. To us this is a very important topic and something we are deeply interested in discussing.
Before we get into the meat of this post we want to clarify: We are not the one and only source of authority on this topic. We are a freshman in college and we often make false conclusions or have holes in our logic. We are VERY open to being critiqued and informed where our stance falls apart, or is wrong.
Plural kit is not and never will be an accessibility tool. Accessibility tools are things like screen readers, alternative text, image descriptions, etc. These are things that the lack of could make information fully inaccessible to a person with a disability. We often need to both hear and read information to understand it, now we don't always have to use subtitles or a screen reader, but we often do. This is a form of disability accommodation.
Plural kit, though very clearly capable of being moderated and easy to us, is not easy to everyone. It requires much more aggressive and intensive moderation than other things and many people do not have the time or energy for that. Previously we had written that it's not hard to moderate but we have realized that what is and isn't hard differs from person to person. Objectively PK requires more attention and excessive moderation than other things and as such it is reasonable to not wish to use it on your server. However we do not think this should be said because it is "hard" to moderate- we prefer the verbiage of "it is more taxing to moderate". (Which is just semantics).
What Plural Kit is however, is a communicative accommodation.
Communicative Accommodations
Now, what do we mean by this term? Much in the way that Howard Giles intended with his Communication Accommodation Theory (CAT), we believe there are things that people do to make communication, conversation, and discussion flow better and bring everyone to the same level.
We believe that this can be applied to types of disability accommodations- nowhere near as vital as accessibility tools or physical accommodations, they are still incredibly important to having strong relationships.
Another form of this would be tone indicators that people use within conversations that include autistics. We are autistic and we struggle to comprehend what people mean with their tone and can often misconstrue their statements due to this imbalance and differentiation in forms of communication. As such a good way for allistics and autistics to get along better in communication is the addition of tone indicators and tone tags (things such as: /gen, /sar, /pos, etc.)
We believe plural kit would fall into this grouping/category as well, alongside systems in close relationships with others simply stating who is fronting. Communication can become slightly difficult when switching and amnesia (for traumagenic systems specifically) is involved. In our experience, we often retell the same stories, ask the same questions, restate the same points, and confuse others by how different our personality can be. For a while we had been under the impression we had a mood or personality disorder, but somehow never fit any of the other symptoms.
Having an indicator the you have changed who you are talking to can be helpful to communicate more effectively. The way someone would better get along with Theodore/Theo is a lot different than they would with me, he cannot properly handle most discourse and struggles to sympathize (we all however have low empathy). I often sympathize with others and communicate very broadly and tend to get into the nitty gritty.
Someone who we are talking to would likely find it jarring for us to switch from him to me with no clear explanation. It could mess up the flow of conversation and eventually put a strain on a relationship or conversation.
We do not believe anyone is bad or wrong for not using PK on their server, nor are we saying your relationships will fall apart if you don't use it. Merely it can be helpful for better communication. We personally have seen it on servers that have a lot of political discussions or discourse due to the fact that these enviorments have very in depth conversations which need as much accommodations as possible to get everyone to the correct conclusions.
It is basically as effective as changing your nickname or tagging your posts/messages or signing off. It's just a way to try and improve communications.