I'm sitting here thinking about how Troy got all of Ilya's empathy while Shane got none. Thinking about Ilya cozying up to a former racist homophobe and expecting Shane to be okay with it- chalking his negative reaction up to jealousy instead of the fact that Shane would have been a target of his for years. Mr. "I know the dark side of hockey" BRINGING THE DARK SIDE INTO SHANE'S SAFE SPACE (the cottage).
And all of this is treated as No Big Deal. Because Shane isn't allowed to do anything but what Ilya wants. Isn't allowed to feel anything but love for this man who resents and mistreats him, and anger at himself for his own perceived selfishness. Not one time is he given space by the narrative to push back on Ilya's behavior- instead he turns it back onto himself. Which, gee, sounds AN AWFUL LOT like what someone in an abusive relationship would do, by the way.
His own parents don't even appear to give a fuck about him. All we get is Yuna asking who accused him of tripping. All of the anxiety and pressure and pain that he endures through this book, and the only time he gets this weak-ass show of support is when it's directly related to hockey (I may be wrong on this point- I haven't reread TLG in ages).
"Shane has so much support!"
Does he?????
Mark my words if the same things that happened to Shane in TLG happened to a female protagonist in a romance with her shadow daddy BF everyone would be rolling their eyes and accusing fans of swooning over a toxic abusive character. But because it’s their favorite white man with 90% of the POV time, it’s just Fine and Normal.
Please I feel like sometimes Shane's fears, which were valid and true, was completely dismissed.
Every single fear of his came true.
Even Yuna asked him if he ever threw a game for Ilya??? Like ma'am that's your son???
Every time people read TLG , they seem to spontaneously forget that Shane was the one who told Ilya he liked him? Invited him to the cottage? Made long term plans for them to be together? My boy was working overtime.
I wish we had one scene where his team's response and the fallout was actually discussed. That people around him get righteously angry that Mr.Hockey himself was suspected of throwing games for his partner.
I wish that we were shown other teams trying to outbid each other to get Shane on their team and him making a conscious choice to sign with Ottawa.
I wish unrivaled shows that he's unstoppable, the best player of this generation, that he's Shane MF Holländer to you, actually.
















