Fairly Oddparents: After Fairy Fairy Quite Contrary
Since A New Wish, I have returned to the FOP fandom. Recently, I've been re-watching some old episodes when something occurred to me.
So at the end of Season 2, Episode 9 (Fairy Fairy Quite Contrary), Remy loses the magical duel, losing Juandissimo and getting his memory wiped. Timmy, feeling bad, wishes for Remy and his parents to spend more time together. The ending shows Remy and his parents on a deserted island, where he meets Juandissimo again, who is disguised as a turtle, and he briefly has a moment of realization before deciding to eat him.
In Season 5, Episode 16, Remy returns. It's later revealed that Remy's parents somehow started a resort and oil business on the deserted island and went back to ignoring him. Juandissimo, disguised as a coconut, hits Remy on the head, resulting in him regaining his memories. It's also revealed that it was Jorgen's plan to get Juandissimo to be Remy's godparent again but that's not what I'm focused on.
My question is: how long were Remy and his parents on that deserted island? The show doesn't exactly state how long they were stranded. Juandissimo says he roamed around Fairy World for many months. But how long is "many months"?
I know this might be a stupid question but I'm curious. Did no one care that the Buxaplentys were missing? They must have known they were missing because Chester asked what the deal was with their disappearance. Remy says they were on an uncharted island but did no one think they might've been dead? Did Timmy not care that he could've accidentally killed the Buxaplenty because it was on an uncharted deserted island and Remy did not have Juandissimo to help him?
Okay, yeah his parents started businesses on the island but how? How were they able to do that in the first place? Did the Yacht still have intact communication? Did they just choose to stay on the island? If they started a resort and an oil business on the island, people must've known where they were...meaning they weren't missing. Did Remy not go to school or did they hire someone to take his place like in Season 9, Episode 16 (Country Clubbed)?
It might not matter because the show's continuity is inconsistent. It might've been a one-off thing for Remy Rides Again but the thought randomly came to my head.
Edit: I just re-watched "Scary Godparents," it now hit me that we have seen the Buxplentys again when Timmy is trick-or-tricking. Remy's dad is at their mansion; meaning they got off the island (I wonder when 'Fairy Fairy Quite Contrary' takes place; I'm going to assume late winter/early spring because of the April Fool's Day episode that came out before the Halloween special). Now I'm wondering why Chester asked about their disappearance or why Timmy does not remember that he already saw Remy's dad and thus should put together that Remy himself would also be there too. I assume they didn't have any plans to bring back Remy after 'Fairy Fairy Quite Contrary' or at least not too soon. Until "Remy Rides Again', Remy would have no memory of Juandissimo and have altered memories of Timmy, they could've had some scene of Remy beefing with Timmy but not knowing the exact reason why. Maybe some mention of him throughout the seasons.
