pairing: college!foggy nelson x f!reader x college!matt murdock
summary: you love your boyfriend, but you're not even sure if his best friend likes you. something's got to give. (6.6k wc)
tags/warnings: 18+ only pls! mdni. threesome, spitroasting, double vaginal penetration, sweaty sex. unprotected sex. oral sex f&m receiving, cum eating. matt loses control for a bit but reader likes it and is okay with it. soft dom bf!foggy, jealous subby puppy boy matt <3, mattfoggy propaganda heh...
a/n: completely unedited bc i wrote this with one hand down my pants
Heat addles the mind but heightens sensation—isn't that what they say?
You can't remember the last voluntary movement you made. Time and memory have since become a foreign concept. There's only before the AC died and after, the latter of which stretches long and molten and winding around you, like pulled taffy.
"I'm going to die here," you mumble. "M'gonna die here and— and they're gonna find my body. And it's going to be"—you lift your head, realizing you've been muffling your voice in the pillow—"fused to this mattress."
There's space though, at least. Regarding the mattress in question, the two twin beds—Foggy's and Matt's—have been shoved together since April, a dubious project held in place by the wall on one side and dogged hope on the other. Even the sheets don't match—one's navy and one's a truly tragic shade of beige.
Right now, you're sprawled out and sweating across the seam where they meet, wearing nothing but a pair of cotton shorts and an oversized t-shirt of Foggy's.
"Aw," Matt remarks from his desk. He's got his earbuds around his neck, one of them plugged in, listening to what you're pretty sure is a contracts textbook. In this heat. For fun. The angle with which he's leaning back in his chair makes you nervous. "Maybe the RA'll put a little memorial up. 'Here she melted. She was okay.'"
"Okay?!"
"Ah, I didn't wanna oversell it."
Oh, Matt.
Even after months of dating Foggy, you can't seem to parse Matt completely. Your boyfriend's best friend has never been fully hostile to you, and you know these little jokes are supposed to be just him teasing, but in actuality—you can never tell with Matt. One moment he's okay, one moment he's provoking you again: joking that you're stealing Foggy from him, teasing you, ignoring you. Bumping into you and crowding you. You're not even sure what you've done to him.
It's not like you can bring it up to Foggy, though. Just thinking of all the little things that've made you come to this conclusion is enough to know that you're going to sound crazy and delusional if you do.
Right now though: if you tease Matt back hard enough, you can ignore the fact that his shirt is off. Not that you're trying hard to not notice too much about his unclothed body. It's just— his skin's faintly sheened in the syrupy light coming through the window.
You'd grumbled about it: how guys always seemed to lose that battle so easily just because they had the option.
But it's okay—you can be normal, right? It's just bodies. It's just bodies.
"Hey," Foggy grunts from beside you. He's shirtless, too, clad only in basketball shorts. "She's more than okay, thank you very much. She's the love of my life and she'll be remembered as such."
You bat your eyes at him exaggeratedly. "Aw, Fog."
"'Here she melted. She was pretty hot.'" He turns his head back to grin at you, eyes crinkling. "Matt's just dramatic."
"You're both dramatic," Matt says.
"Says the man who pointed the single fan at himself," you shoot back.
The oscillating fan has indeed been hogged, rotating by the corner of Matt's desk in agreement. It ruffles the dark hair at his forehead before swiveling away again.
"I'm studying," he says mildly. As if that has anything to do with anything.
"You're hogging the breeze is what you are, Murdock."
Under the thick, stifling comforter of heat, though, it only just then occurs to you that Foggy's hand has been on your thigh, rubbing along the inside of it.
"Hey," he says to you, rolling onto his side to face you. His eyes are half-lidded.
You know this look. You know exactly what it means. It's the one that usually precedes him kissing your neck hotly and talking you out of whatever you were doing.
And the thing is, there's actually nothing you'd want more than to pull Foggy's shorts down now and ride him, but fuck. Matt's right there.
"Foggy. No."
"I didn't say anything."
"Your hand's saying plenty." You grab his wrist and lift it off your leg, depositing it back on his own chest. "It's a thousand degrees," you say, and then lower your voice in warning, "Matt's right there."
Foggy makes a sound like a deflating balloon. "Matt doesn't care. He's basically furniture right now. He's a lamp." And louder, he calls, "No offense, buddy."
"None taken." And then lighter, "I've endured worse from him."
"See?" Foggy's hand migrates back, and this time it lands on your hip, squeezing through the fabric of your shorts. "Lamp says it's fine."
"Yeah. You deal with the wandering hands for a few hours. I've had years of this."
Ignoring Matt, you swat at Foggy again, harder, trying for propriety, and he retreats with a dramatic wince.
"You are so— it's too hot, Fog. I'll literally melt. Do you wanna lose your girlfriend to, um— entropy?"
"Thermodynamics," Matt contributes from the distance, needling.
"Thank you, Lamp."
He shrugs. Foggy flops onto his back with a theatrical groan, arms thrown wide.
For a while, there's nothing but the faint whirring off the fan, and the muffled sounds of the dormitory drifting through the open window. Someone's playing Ke$ha downstairs.
You close your eyes. It's so, so hot. Your thoughts go slow and syrupy, circling into the ever-perilous drain of sleep.
"...anyway," Foggy's saying. And you realize that you missed the start of some conversation he and Matt have drifted into. "I'm just saying, you can't cite that for that proposition."
"But you're thinking of the Seventh Circuit dissent, not the—"
"Oh, the dissent, he says—"
"It's a famous one, Foggy."
"Famous doesn't mean right."
"Neither does loud."
You crack one eye open and find that they're grinning at each other. Jesus. It's your favorite thing about them, at least: the way they bicker like an old married couple that secretly enjoy it. Foggy catches you looking and winks.
"Back me up here, babe."
You shudder at the name. "I have no idea what you're talking about." Planting a kiss on his cheek, you say, "And I refuse to learn."
Matt barks a laugh at that. "Good, you know Foggy's a worse influence than he lets on."
"Oh, I'm the bad influence? That's rich coming from—" Foggy cuts himself off, waving a hand. "You know what, no. I'm not taking that bait."
"What bait?" you ask.
"Matt-bait. He does this thing where, you know, he says something provocative then he sits back and lets you—"
"Oh, come on, man. I don't do 'a thing.'"
"—crash and burn and flail. You know what this reminds me of?" Foggy rolls his head toward you, conspiratorial. "There was a time sophomore year— wait, was it sophomore year? Matt, was it sophomore year when the power went out in Carman the whole heatwave?"
"Yeah, uh," Matt taps his fingers on the table, licking his lips, "freshman year, I think?"
"Right, right. And we had to sleep with the door open and there was this guy from down the hall who kept walking by in his boxers—"
"I don't think he was even wearing boxers."
"Wow, I blocked that part out, thanks for that." Foggy waves a hand. "Anyway, we drank endless shots because Matt kept saying, you know, I don't even think you can handle it, over and over, so I kept doing it and he kept doing it, over and over, and then we ended up—" Foggy stops. "Uh. Anyway, it was a weird night."
Matt's fingers have stopped drumming on the desk.
"Ended up what?" you ask lazily, only half-listening.
"Nothing. Just— just talking. We stayed up talking."
You look between them, and find Matt grinning, like the cat who ate the canary.
"What?" you say, and now you're propping up on your elbow, curious. "What happened?"
"Nothing! Matt's just being— Man, you're being weird."
"I'm not being anything!" Matt leans back in his chair and tips it back onto two legs. His mouth's curled at the corners. "I'm just saying. It was a good night."
"It was a normal night—"
Matt scoffs.
"—that we don't need to—"
"Wait," you say. Something's assembling itself in your head, puzzle pieces slowly clicking into place. Foggy's blush. Matt's smirk. Even the conspicuous way Foggy derailed his own anecdote. Ended up—? "Wait. Hold on. Matt. What happened freshman year?"
Matt turns to face you. Without his glasses, those unfocused eyes are warm and brown, with flecks of pretty amber.
"We kissed," he says simply.
The fan clicks. Clicks. Clicks.
"You—" You sit up fully. "What?"
"MATT." Foggy jackknifes upright on the bed beside you, so fast the whole mattress-island wobbles, as if he's only just woken up from some dreamlike trance. "We had a pact!"
"That was two years ago!"
"What— When was—" You can't even gather your thoughts up quick enough to substantiate anything you're saying. Matt's kissed Foggy? Foggy's kissed Matt? "Sorry, what happened exactly?"
"It was— It was before you," Matt says, all quickly, like he's had that at the ready. "Obviously."
"Obviously," you echo, looking at Foggy. He's rubbing the back of his neck, not meeting your eyes. The flush is spreading from his cheeks down to his freckled chest.
"We were drunk," Foggy says. He drags both hands down his face. "It was one time— It was stupid, it didn't mean— I mean, it meant something, but not like— not like you mean something—"
"It was more than one time," Matt says pleasantly.
Foggy falters, losing his words. Meanwhile, something's happening in your chest. It's a mix of intrigue and jealousy, though decidedly not betrayal, not any of the things you should probably be feeling upon learning your boyfriend's kissed his best friend. What it is is more like a door opening, a window thrown wide in a room already hot, flushed with heat. Electric.
"More than once," you say.
Your boyfriend's blue eyes are so, so wide and worried, brow crumpled, looking so guilty. You can practically see the gears grinding behind his eyes.
"Was it good?"
Matt's eyebrows lift and Foggy's mouth opens, closes, and opens again.
"I—" He blinks. "What?"
"Was it good?" You cross your legs on the bed, your shorts riding up. "The kiss. Was it good?"
There's only silence.
And then Matt says, "It wasn't bad."
Foggy makes an indignant noise. "Wasn't bad? I'll have you know—" He sighs, giving up, and turns back to you. "Why aren't you mad?"
You consider this honestly. "I don't know. I don't know," you say. Your voice sounds different. "I think it's... It's actually kind of hot?"
Matt's chair comes down on all four legs with a soft thud.
Foggy's staring at you. "You— I, uh, what?"
"I get it. Matt's not hard on the eyes," you say. You drag your thumb along the ridge of his knuckles, feeling each soft dip and indentation. "So how many times? Three? Four?"
Foggy glances at Matt, then back at you. "I— Yeah? Why are you asking me this...?"
"Because I want you to do again."
Matt hasn't moved, but you can see the shift in his posture.
"Do it again," Foggy repeats.
"Yeah. Kiss him again. If you want."
"In front of—"
"Yeah."
He rubs his face again with both hands. "This is— Okay, this is insane. Matt?"
"I mean," Matt's tongue darts across his lower lip, quick and unconscious, "I'm not opposed."
"Oh, you're not opposed? Come on, back me up here—"
"Come on, Fog." Matt stands from the desk. He pads across the tiny room barefoot, and the orange-white sun from the window catches the planes of his stomach, the dark trail of hair below his navel. He stops at the edge of the pushed-together beds, standing over both of you. "She did ask nicely."
For a second, there's a beat where Foggy just looks up at him. You see something pass between them, some well-worn frequency that predates you. A contemplative look of shared history. Then Foggy exhales, long and slow, and tilts his chin up.
"If this is weird after," he warns, pointing a finger at Matt, "that's on you."
"Everything's on me," Matt says, and he leans down and kisses him.
It's careful at first. Almost... Chaste? Respectful. Matt's hand finds the curve of Foggy's jaw, and they press their mouths together so softly, so easily that it makes you stomach flip. Very clearly having done this before.
Then Matt makes a sound—quiet, like a suppressed groan—and kisses deeper, and Foggy's lips part, and suddenly it isn't chaste at all.
Your breath catches. Watching them from inches away, it's all close enough to see the way Matt's hand comes down to caress Foggy's neck. Foggy, in seeming retaliation, reaches up to grip the back of Matt's neck, pulling him closer.
Matt's on one knee on the mattress now, half-bracing himself over Foggy. The way their mouths are moving together makes you feel like you can't breathe. Foggy kisses the way you know, the way he does everything. Warm and generous, open-mouthed and giving. Matt's rougher, though. Like he's taking.
You press your thighs together. It's as if the heat in the room has narrowed to a single, pulsing point low in your belly.
Matt pulls back just enough to breathe, and his lower lip drags against Foggy's. And then he's kissing him again, much deeper this time. His tongue slides into Foggy's mouth. Your boyfriend makes a muffled sound, and from Matt's neck, his hand slides up into his hair, gripping. Matt shivers, and you watch the muscles in his shoulders flex.
"Don't stop," you breathe.
Matt smiles smugly against Foggy's mouth, and you suddenly know it for what it is: he's performing at least a little, and you don't mind at all. His hand plants itself on Foggy's bare chest, fingers spread wide over his pecs. Then it slides lower, palm dragging through the sheen of sweat, the downy blond hair of Foggy's soft stomach—
"Okay," Foggy breathes. He breaks the kiss and turns his head, eyes finding yours. They're dark. Heavy-lidded. Unmistakably turned on. "You— Come here."
You're lost in the daze, though, and Foggy knows you enough to not wait for you to obey. As Matt makes room for you, Foggy reaches out to hook the back of your neck and pull you in, and then his mouth's on yours. Hot and slick and tastes faintly of lemonade, of salty spit. Matt's spit, you think hazily. His tongue pushes past your lips and you make a sound into his mouth, only for him to deepen it. Kissing you like he's claiming you back. Like he needs to know the difference.
You slide your own hands up your boyfriend's chest, over his nipples and his stomach. His skin's so sticky under your palms and you love it, how alive he feels between the two of you.
But even as Foggy's tongue slides against yours, you feel Matt. His hands are on your hips from behind, chest pressing against your back, palms skimming up your sides beneath the oversized t-shirt. His fingers are long, longer than Foggy's, and they leave trails of heat across your ribs. He's so warm. Skin-on-skin where your top's ridden up, and you can feel his cock pressing against your ass through the thin layers between you.
"Easy, easy," Foggy mumbles into your mouth, directed past you. But Matt doesn't listen: his hands coast up higher, thumbs grazing the undersides of your breasts, and you jolt, gasping against Foggy's mouth.
"Not fair," Matt mutters behind you. His mouth finds the curve of your neck, open and hot, teeth dragging, and you shudder between them. "Share."
You break from Foggy—who chases your mouth with a lazy, half-lidded look to him—and turn your head. Matt must sense the movement, because he stops his groping and fondling, and tilts his head toward you.
"Hi," Matt says hoarsely, close enough that you feel the word on your mouth.
"Hi."
"You wanna?"
You do. Fuck, you do.
You tip your head and kiss Matt Murdock for the first time. It's absolutely nothing like kissing your boyfriend. Matt is teeth and tongue immediately, sharp and searching. Hot. Hypnotizing. A little mean about it, too. He bites your bottom lip and you make a startled sound, and feel Foggy laugh weakly between you.
"Yeah," Foggy says. "Yeah, he's like that."
"Mm-hmm," you mumble, having lost all language, and then Matt's back to kissing you.
When you break apart, you're panting. Foggy's turned his face to you and you kiss him again. It's easier. Home. He sighs into your mouth the way he does when you're alone. But even as he kisses you his hips are rocking forward into Matt's hand, which has snaked around from behind you.
Matt's other hand slides up your stomach again, and between the two of them your shirt gets tugged up over your head. And like that, you're bare from the waist up, sweaty and breathless. The feeling of being freed from your clothes is almost as good as the feeling of Foggy's eyes on you.
"Jesus Christ," Foggy breathes, so clearly ogling your tits.
Matt's hands drag across your nipples, pinching firmly just to see what noise you make. From the front, Foggy's mouth drops to your chest, tongue darting out to lick at one peaked bud. You cry out, hand fisting in his long hair.
Everything's slippery. Matt's chest against your bare back. Foggy's mouth on your skin. Hands, everywhere—you lose track of whose is whose.
You slide one hand down the front of Foggy's body—down, past the trail of hair at his navel—until your fingers bump the back of Matt's wrist where it's still under the waistband of Foggy's shorts. Matt stills. You can feel Foggy's thick cock under his hand, hot and heavy and straining, and the angle's awkward but you slip your fingers under alongside Matt's and feel your boyfriend twitch hard against both of you at once.
"Oh God," Foggy says hoarsely.
Matt pulls his hand out first, fingers bumping yours as he goes. You get off Foggy, and then Matt's hooking both thumbs into the waistband of Foggy's shorts and tugging.
"Up," he says. "C'mon. C'mon."
"Fuck, I can't believe this is happening," Foggy mutters, but he plants his hands on the mattress and lifts his hips anyway. Matt drags the shorts down his thighs in one pull, and Foggy's cock springs up against his stomach. Leaking already at the tip.
Matt's hand goes right back to where it was, working Foggy's cock so loosely, slick with precome and sweat, pulling pained groans from your boyfriend's pretty, pretty mouth. He turns his face toward yours and grins.
"You want a turn?" he asks you sweetly. Insufferably smug.
"Don't be rude," you spit at him, even as you're reaching.
Your hand closes over Matt's, closes over Foggy, who's making these tiny helpless hitches of breath, eyes squeezed shut. And when you grip him a little harder, he whimpers.
"See," Matt says to you, "he likes this sound."
"I know, Matt."
"Yeah? Do you know how to get five of 'em in a row?"
"Matt, stop— Stop being mean," Foggy says through gritted teeth. You laugh, and you can't help the little squirm you do. You're so turned on you're lightheaded. You want out of your shorts, out of your panties, now.
You wriggle out of them in an undignified sort of shimmy, and your bare thighs stick instantly to the beige sheet. God, it's so hot in here you're going to combust. Seeing you're naked, Foggy reaches back and shoves Matt aside, grabbing your thigh and hauling it over his hip. Hooking you around him, and making you fit yourself against his hardness. You grind down once and cry out.
"Matt," you rasp. "Come back."
He crawls back in, a long lean creature stalking up the seam of the sheets, and when he gets close enough, you grab the waistband of his shorts yourself and tug. Like a cat being lifted out of a lap, he lifts up obligingly and you drag down his hips and he kicks out of them and then he's bare too, all three of you bare. The head of Matt's cock is flushed an angry pink. He's leaking onto himself.
"What a mess," you say teasingly. "All for us, huh?"
But your teasing's barely potent: Matt's smirking, and you kind of want to slap him and also kind of want to climb him.
"Here," Foggy says, pushing you off again to gentle you down against the mattress. "I'm gonna move you, okay?"
You go where he puts you—with him behind you, cradling your body. Another round of kisses with your face turned to him: deep and slow, the way he kisses you when he's about to fuck you.
You expect Matt to crawl up in front of you, ostensibly to fuck you, or kiss you too. Instead, he's between your thighs and nudges your legs open with his shoulders. You suck in a breath so hard you make yourself dizzy.
"Wait, wait, wait..."
"Mm?" Matt tips his head up, all puppy-like. "I can stop."
You look down your body and there he is. His cheek almost on your thigh, and he's waiting. For you; your permission.
"Don't stop," you say. Twice now you've said that—you're starting to think it might be your permanent answer from here on out.
Matt smiles and drops his face to you.
You don't get much more than one swipe of his tongue, though, before Foggy's mouth is back on yours, catching all your noise. Your hand flies out to grab Matt's hair and hold him there.
"Mm, oh my God," you gasp. "Foggy, he's—"
"I know, I know. He's showing off, huh?"
"A little, a little..." Matt keeps at it, and he's good at it. The worst part, you think, is that he knows he's good at it. You can feel him smiling smugly against your cunt every time your thighs twitch around his ears. Foggy's got his hand in your hair, petting you, stroking you, whispering sweet, dumb things in your face—that's it, no, I know, he's being such a show-off, isn't he? you're doing so, so good, sweetheart—and you don't even feel real anymore. Swimming in heat.
Matt pulls off, and you make a noise in protest.
"Don't be selfish," he says. Mouth slick and eyes glassy. "Save some for Foggy."
"Matt, don't be an asshole."
"I'm not."
"Yes, you are. Come here."
Matt obeys. He crawls up your body, heavy over you, and Foggy drags him into a kiss so filthy right from the jump. You lie there with your chest heaving and watch two men who have known each other longer than they've known you eat each other's mouths above your face. Matt's tongue flicks out and there's a smear of you on his chin. Foggy licks it off him.
"Jesus," you breathe.
They break apart and Matt sinks back on his heels. Foggy leans down and gives you a peck, almost apologetically, and then he's sliding back. Adjusting you until you're on all fours on wrinkled sheets. And just like that, he's lining himself up with you and you're so wet it's embarrassing. He slides against you twice just to coat himself, and you whimper.
"Please, Foggy..."
"I got you, baby." He pushes himself in, one slow slide and you push yourself back onto him, feeling him stretch you out. "Jesus fuck," he curses loudly, as he starts to move. "You're so wet, babe."
"S'Matt..." you mumble. "S'all Matt..."
Kneeling by your hip, Matt's still there, stroking himself slowly to the sound of Foggy fucking you. Little wet catches of sound, your panting, Foggy's groaning. The bed squeaks under you, creaking every time Foggy thrusts into you, and you don't even care if the whole thing collapses, as long as Foggy's using you to feel good.
"Matt," Foggy pants, not looking away from you. "Get up there."
"Hmm?"
"Her— Her mouth." He palms your ass, gripping it as he fucks you. "Okay, right, baby? You want—?"
You nod so fast, and drop your head against the pillow. "Yes, yes please—!"
"Mm, I don't know," Matt says, tugging at your hair to lift your head back up. He's fucking smiling. "Should I? Do you want it?"
"Uhuh, uhuh, please..."
"Say it, then. 'Matt, I want you to fuck my mouth.'"
Behind you, Foggy groans, his rhythm faltering for half a second before recovering. You swallow, peering up at Matt with big, wet eyes. "I— I want you t— Please..." Matt laughs as you falter and stutter, smiling at you so coyly. "I want you to fuck my mouth—!" you finally yelp, as Foggy drives into you especially deep.
Matt doesn't say anything more, though. He kneels in front of you, cock bobbing above your mouth. You open for him immediately. Tongue out, hungry—and you must look wild. Must look half-gone already. Matt breathes out hard above you, and slaps his cock on your lips once, twice, before feeding himself into your mouth.
"Open up," he grunts. "Suck. Yeah, just like that—"
Your eyes sting at the stretch of him. He's big, but not as thick as Foggy. Still, he's long, and doesn't give you a lot of warning before he's nudging the back of your throat. You breathe through your nose and fist the sheets, letting him set the pace, and his hand comes down to cup your cheek.
"Taking me so well, Jesus," Matt hisses. "So good at this, huh?"
Foggy's fucking you harder now, like Matt's praise has him wound up. The angle changes and he hits that place inside you that makes your throat close up, and you try to moan around Matt's cock and end up just making a gurgled sound that's got Matt swearing above you.
"Do it again," he pants.
"Working on it."
Foggy does it again. And again. And Matt rocks down to meet your mouth and the three of you find a rhythm for about thirty seconds before it devolves into something messier. More animal and desperate. With Foggy's hips slapping against your thighs, and Matt's balls brushing your chin, your hands grope blindly for any purchase you can find: Matt's hip, the bunched-up sheet beneath you.
And Matt— Matt who's been holding himself in careful check, at least, loses it. His hand tightens in your hair and his thrusts go shorter, sharper. He stops pulling back far enough for you to catch your breath.
"Matt," Foggy warns. "Hey. Easy."
"I'm being easy," he lies, voice ragged, and rocks forward again so deep your eyes water. Your fingers scratch at his thighs and you gag, and instead of pulling back he shudders and pushes deeper.
Your eyes sting and you're making sounds you can't control—high, broken things—and you feel yourself starting to slip, the world going hazy at the edges, too much heat and too much Matt and—
Foggy snaps at him. "Matt. Hey. Off."
"I'm fine, she's fine—"
"Off. Now." It's the voice Foggy uses when he means it. Not Foggy being silly or Foggy being sweet, but the one who'll go to the mat for you without thinking twice. Matt goes still above you, breath heaving, and then reluctantly pulls out of your mouth.
You gasp, spluttering. Coughing. Your jaw aches and there's spit all down your chin. Matt sits back on his heels, his cock bobbing wet against his stomach, and he looks—chastened. Pouting, like a kid who's had his favorite toy taken away.
"She was fine," he mutters.
"She was crying."
"She liked it." You did.
"Not for you to decide, buddy." Foggy's slowed inside you but he hasn't pulled out, and his hand comes to your back, stroking affectionately. So gentle that it's at odds with the filthy state of you. "Hey. You okay, baby?"
You nod, still catching your breath. "M'okay. M'good. Really good."
"Yeah?"
"Yeah, Fog, I promise."
Foggy looks down at you so tenderly, and he pulls out and the sudden emptiness makes you whine.
"C'mere," he says, shifting onto his back. "Come up here, baby. You ride me."
Yes. God, yes.
You crawl over him on shaky limbs—your knees are shot, thighs trembling—and Foggy's hands find your hips and guide you down. You sink down onto him and oh, oh— you always forget how thick he is until you're taking him from this angle, feeling yourself stretch and spread around the fat head of him.
"There you go," Foggy murmurs, stroking your sides lovingly. "You set the pace, okay? There you go, that's it. Take your time."
You don't though. With an impulsiveness you realize is more aligned with Matt, actually— you bottom out in one slow slide and Foggy groans beneath you, hands clamping down. You plant your palms on his chest and start to move.
The pace you set is filthy, almost punishing. You roll your hips and lift up until he almost slips out, before slamming back down. The two beds are definitely drifting apart beneath you, the gap at the seam widening with every bounce, and Foggy's hands are everywhere. Waist, your tits, your thighs.
"Fuck!" he says. "Fuck, baby, you feel so—"
Foggy's eyes are so dark they're almost black, and his hips start to rock up into you, hard.
You glance over your shoulder and find Matt where you left him—and he's got one hand wrapped around himself, working himself fast and rough. His lips are parted, brows drawn up, and he's making these soft little whimpers, as if he can't stand being excluded.
"Fog," he says, and his voice cracks.
So that's what Matt sounds like when he's desperate.
"Matt," Foggy says, not unkindly. Watching him.
Matt's hand drops from himself, shifting forward on his knees until he's pressing up against Foggy's leg, straddling it. Cock dragging against the sweaty muscle of Foggy's calf, and he starts to rut. Grinding himself into Foggy's leg like a dog, whining so reedily. You clench so hard around Foggy that he chokes.
"Jesus," Foggy breathes, watching Matt rub himself off on his leg. "Matt. Matt, hey, come here—"
"Wanna—" Matt's voice is barely there. He's flushed from his ears down to his strong stomach, and there's precome smeared all along Foggy's leg. "Foggy, I wanna—"
"I know you do, puppy. C'mere. Come up here."
Matt crawls up behind you again, and you feel his chest against your back. Bare and scorching skin. His cock presses into the curve of your ass, and he's so hard it must hurt. His mouth finds the crook of your neck and he whimpers against your pulse point.
And then he shifts, adjusting his angle. His cock slides down and nudges against where Foggy's already inside you.
You freeze.
"—Oh," you whimper.
"Mm," Matt mumbles against your throat, rubbing his cock along your entrance, right alongside Foggy's shaft.
"Matt, mm!"
"Please." It doesn't even sound like Matt anymore. "Please, I need—"
Foggy's looking up at you, and then past you, at Matt's face over your shoulder.
"Baby," he groans, "You could— You could let him in too."
Your heart's pounding in your chest. You can barely even think. "Both of— both of you?"
"Mm-hmm. Both of us."
"At the same... time...?"
"We'll—" Foggy's chest heaves. "We'll go slow. I promise. We'll go so slow, baby. What do you think?" He glances at Matt again. "I think you can take it. Can you take it for me, baby?"
You should say no. You're already stretched around Foggy and he's thick, and Matt isn't small—
"Yes," you say.
"Yeah?" His voice drops, so sweetly. "Okay?"
"Mm-hmm. Okay."
"Good girl." Foggy licks at his lips, and turns to Matt. "Okay, Matt. Slow, okay? You hear me? Slow and easy."
"I know, I know."
"She tells you to stop, stop."
"I'll stop. I'll stop." Matt's forehead drops to the back of your neck. You feel his breath shuddering out. "I promise, Foggy. I promise."
"Good boy."
Feeling him twitch hard against you, the blunt head of his cock nudges insistently at where you're already full. You breathe out. Trying to relax, to let yourself go soft— but it's hard. Every instinct's telling you there isn't room, there can't possibly.
Matt pushes in anyway.
Just the head, just the very tip of him. Pressing in alongside Foggy.
"Oh God—" Your nails dig into Foggy's shoulders. "Oh my God, oh fuck!"
"Breathe, baby. Breathe for me. It's a lot, huh?"
"Mmm..."
"Mmm. I know. I know it is, you're doing so good, huh? So brave."
Matt's hips push forward another inch and you cry out. Almost pained.
"Sorry, sorry—" Matt grits out, trembling against your back. You can feel the effort it takes him to not rut the way he was rutting before. "Sorry. I'll wait. I'm waiting."
You breathe. In, out, in, out. Foggy's still whispering to you, so good, Jesus, I'm so proud of you, baby—and you feel yourself softening. The stretch going from painfully full to something warm. You press your forehead against Foggy's collarbone and nod.
"Okay," you whisper. "Okay, I can take more."
Slowly, Matt slides all the way in, and all three of you stop breathing.
Full. You're so full it's like you can feel them everywhere. Foggy's cock and Matt's cock and the way they're pressed together inside you. Separated by nothing. Skin on skin through the slick squeezing of your body, feeling them against each other. They're so close together inside you that every movement's shared.
"Fog," Matt breathes into your shoulder. "Can feel you."
"I know, man. Can feel you too."
Matt presses a kiss into your cheek, more into your hair, really. "Can I move?"
You nod.
They don't coordinate, and they can't, you think—it feels too new and strange and overwhelmingly good. So what happens instead is a kind of stuttered rhythm. Matt pulls back and Foggy pushes up; Foggy drops, Matt thrusts forward—so that you're never empty. Never not full. One of them's always bottomed out inside you while the other slides against him.
The friction of them moving against each other in your cunt is—
You can't think anymore.
You're dripping. Around them, between them, all over Foggy's thighs. Every thrust pushes more out of you, slick and warm and running down your skin. They're both losing it. Foggy's hands bruise at your hips, pulling you down onto them both, and Matt's arms are locked around your waist from behind, his face buried in your hair.
"You're so good," Foggy pants up at you. This awful sticking melting heat's turned you fully stupid, and sweat is dripping from your chin onto Foggy's chest and he doesn't care. "You're so good, baby, you're taking both of us, you're perfect, you're—"
"Harder," you cry.
Matt answers; it seems he always answers when you tell him to be worse. His hips snap forward and Foggy's eyes fly wide because he can feel it—Matt's cock shoving alongside his own, the friction and the pressure doubling—and both of them groan in unison.
They find it, then. The rhythm. Not staggered anymore but together, both of them thrusting up into you at the same time, splitting you open on every upstroke, and you're not bouncing anymore, you're being fucked, held in place between their bodies and fucked open by two cocks that slide and press and rub against each other inside you with every stroke.
"Me too, buddy. Hold on. Baby—" Foggy grabs your chin and makes you look at him and his eyes are blown wide and desperate. "You close? Can you come for us?"
"Yeah—yes—please, Fog, please—"
"Come on, then. Let go for me. Let go."
So you do.
Like a wave. A wall. Like the floor dropping out from under you. It's these you feel, clenching so hard around both of them that Matt groans and Foggy's hips bow off the mattress as your cunt spasms around them, milking them, squeezing them together inside you.
"Fuck—fuck, baby, I'm—"
You can't tell anymore who comes first. At once, they're both pulsing inside you at almost the same time, filling you up from both sides. There's so much of it, and you sob against Foggy's chest and feel them throb as they empty into you.
And then it's very quiet after.
Quiet except for breathing.
Matt pulls out first, and you feel a rush of warmth follow him out. It drips down over Foggy where he's still inside you. Matt collapses beside you both like a marionette with its strings cut, spent arms splayed out, chest heaving.
"Holy shit," he pants to the ceiling.
Foggy lifts you gently, so gently and slips out of you himself, and another gush of warmth follows. It's running out of you in thick, lazy rivulets of white, pooling on the sheets and on Foggy's thighs.
"Oh my God," you mumble into the pillow. You genuinely can't move. Ruined and leaking cum onto the tragic beige sheet; you're never getting up again.
Maybe you were right; this is where they'll find your body after all.
Foggy tucks you against his side, his hand strokes up and down your arm. Your eyelids are already dragging shut.
"Hey, Matt?" Foggy says, after a minute. Matt lifts his head. "Wanna clean her up?"
There's a pause. A long one. Matt blinks, and wordlessly—he shifts down the bed.
You feel his hands on your thighs, parting them carefully. You shiver; you're so oversensitive you think a strong breeze could finish you off. He settles between your legs and you feel his hot breath ghost over you and you twitch.
"It's okay," Foggy murmurs into your hair. "Just let him. He's gonna take care of you."
Matt's mouth starts on you and you whimper. He's gentle this time, at least. There's none of the earlier show-off bravado, only slow, careful licks, cleaning you up, lapping at the mess of cum leaking out of your swollen, fucked-open cunt. His tongue dips inside you and you jerk, and Foggy's arm tightens around your shoulders. Holding you still.
"Good boy," Foggy says quietly, and it's directed at Matt.
You lie there and shake. Matt eats you out until there's nothing left to clean, and then he keeps going, just enough that a second orgasm catches you by surprise. It's just a soft, warming thing that barely makes you gasp, a slow tightening and release. Foggy presses a kiss to your forehead as you come down from it.
Matt crawls back up the mattress and collapses on Foggy's other side. He throws an arm across Foggy's chest and his fingertips brush your shoulder. The three of you lie there in the terrible heat, sweating and sticky and wrecked, breathing together.
"I can't believe," Foggy says slowly, staring at the ceiling, "that we just did that."
Matt grins, loose and lazy and entirely too pleased with himself, and you watch his hand find Foggy's on the mattress. Their fingers lace together. You drape your arm over Foggy's stomach and let your hand rest on top of theirs and nobody says anything about it.
"Hey, Matt," you say, drowsy.
"Hm."
"You're more than okay, you know."
A pause. Matt's fingers twitch against yours. He barks a laugh and says, "Yeah, you too."
a/n: average college dorm activities be like...
tagging ppl that have shown interest! @moth-murdock @sunshine-daydreams0809 @foxmurdock @lambmurdock @angelmurdock
Still can’t get over how cool it is that the aspect ratio changes to reflect Matt focusing his hearing. Such a cool detail that immerses you in the action.
tangentwithtanner
jacobvanloon
prguitarman
turnnoffyourmind
