I posed with tribal looking facepaint on for a few pictures in a photoshoot I did last year. The pictures turned out beautifully and the paint came out exactly as I had hoped. To my dismay, the photos were received rather poorly by many people on tumblr, and I’d like to discuss some of the reasons surrounding it. I posted on of the pictures with the caption “ Inspired from beautiful aspects of other cultures I respect and admire” and immediately got responses from strangers such as “Stop” and “Puke” and “That isn’t what respect or admiration look like.” I was very surprised and alarmed by these reactions because I never imagined I would be offending anyone and definitely didn’t expect that feedback. I am aware of the fact that hundreds of years ago white people took over America from the Native Americans causing bloodshed and loss of land, it was a travesty and doesn’t receive the attention it deserves within our school systems and other aspects of society. Many lies and genocides worldwide are often swept under the carpet - the winners write the history books and destroying cultures like that is ugly and unforgivable. I do not personally support any of the wrongdoing that the Native Americans went through then or the complications and racism that the remaining legacy of those Native Americans may face now. Its horrible and gross. However, posing with that facepaint on is a sign of admiration. I think that Native American culture was beautiful - the art, clothing, architecture, archery, languages, music, dancing, food, spiritual religions, not being wasteful, respect of elders, facepaint, etc. I believe it should be celebrated. If all people of other nationalities ignored and forgot about those beautiful cultural aspects to the African American society, they might be forgotten. The people were mistreated, but we cannot allow for them to be forgotten. No one is asking for forgiveness for what happened or for anyone to forget. My ancestors didn’t come to America until WW2, and if my family had stayed in Europe and I grew up there, I likely would have posed with face paint on anyway. Is the crime being a white American with facepaint? Or is it being literally anyone else in the world who isn’t a part of a Native American tribe? There are other cultures that have used facepaint for hundreds of generations, such as most African tribes and other cultures within Africa and other cultures in this world. I spent this summer in Africa volunteering at Big Cat sanctuaries and have friends with a Kenyon tribe. People there were very welcoming, and encouraged me to take part in their traditions, learn what mattered to them, join in the dances. Travelling is my biggest passion, I adore meeting foreign people and learning about their stories and cultures. I have studied hieroglyphics, most specifically Phoenician. America is supposed to be the melting pot of cultures. There are people from everywhere in the globe living in America and there is supposedly freedom of speech and religion, etc. I’m a triple language major at my university. Should I be punished for learning languages spoken in places my ancestors are not from? Should we be punished for trade? Eating imported foods and using imported fabrics? Should anyone who didn’t live during the 60s be forbidden to wear tie dye? Should women with Muslin ancestors never have the option to wear denim shorts in a western country? Should little girls who haven’t won pageants or been born into royalty and earned tiaras/crowns be forbidden to wear them? If a kid wears a Papal Mitre (Miter) or even a representation of the Papal Tiara, does it take any power away from the Pope? Is it offensive to doctors who went to med school and earned doctorates if kids put on lab coats and play doctor or the operation game? Should I be forbidden to salsa dance because it didn’t originate in New York? No. We grow as a world community when we share resources and ideas. Plenty of cultures borrow from each other and it makes them stronger. Exposure to various cultures is valuable. If white Americans ignored every other culture in the world and all of history, the problems would be much worse. I wore facepaint. I wore it in Africa, I’ve worn it in performances on stage, and I wore Native American inspired facepaint for a photoshoot. The intention was not to mock their culture, it was to celebrate it. At the same time I can’t fully expect intentions to strip away any feelings of hurt. Also, I am aware of the fact that Native peoples are not one monolithic culture. There are many variations between different regions and tribes and not all would even use facepaint, or use it in the same manors. Do not think that I am making the generalization that all Native American tribes are the same. I’d also like to make it clear that I am not wearing a Halloween costume or pretending to be a part of their race...this isn’t some disgusting blackface practice...I clearly wrote that the makeup was inspired by their culture. When I picture Native Americans, the adjectives that come to mind are wise, strong, independent. The wildness and freedom are qualities I’d be honored to bond with. I know that their land was taken unfairly and illegally, the towns in my area are all named after Native American tribes that once prospered here. They aren’t forgotten. I am not in support of how things played out between our ancestors. I wish there could have been peace, compromises, sharing, or just for us not to have expanded here where there were already civilizations existing. I have no control over that situation and I didn’t ask to be born on what was their land. I shouldn’t be punished because I was born white and happen to be interested in “non-white” cultures. I’m not some drunken sorority girl running around in a bikini and $4 knock-off headdress, I put on a few stripes of facepaint and posed in nature. Rather than being looked down on and being told what I cannot do or wear, how bout something constructive like “Ms. if you want to show your admiration and respect for our community by raising awareness somehow, could you try getting peoples attention on ______________ issue or volunteering with __________________ organizations?” And I’d be HAPPY to. My intention was never to denigrate, mock, or blindly support stereotypes. In general I would not consider myself to be an ignorant person. I personally have no respect for close minded people who choose to live within their simple ignorant bubbles. I am not a religious person, and though it is in different ways than Native Americans, I do consider myself to be spiritual and would love to learn more about their spiritual beliefs, possibly to expand my horizons and learn more about myself and what I connect with. I find other cultures inspiring. I want to make a clear apology to anyone who may have found my photography to be offensive. There is still plenty that I can be further educated on and I never meant to hurt or bother people. After reading this if people still believe I am a cruel racist and overstepping and see this as some sort of hate crime, feel free to message me and inform me of your concerns because I’d love to learn more and make sure it does not happen again - you will be heard and hopefully understood. I do not want you to think that I will approach it with a closed, defensive outlook. This is an issue that matters to me and I genuinely do not feel that I have overstepped. If the problems are regarding the pattern or colors used, again, please do not hesitate to let me know so that I can correct it in the future! If the problem is that I am wearing facepaint at all and have not earned the right, then consider these perspectives: In my life I do not believe I will ever be in the position to earn the right at all as I do not have Native American heritage and am not personally close with anyone who does. One of my big passions in life is acting. I understand that some people view wearing facepaint or headdresses as someone claiming to have earned a war honor etc. The fact is in movies and plays characters can earn war honors. All parties are aware of the fact that it is pretend, he/she is an actor, wearing a costume made to represent a scenario that is not based on that actor’s reality. I am not pretending I deserve to be able to put on Native American apparel whenever I feel like it because I’m an actress. That’s not how that works, but when I do photoshoots, I’m someone else. I step out of my body and history and into a fictional person’s. The facepaint pictures are posted on a blog called “Alter Ego.” She could be an important person in Native American, African, or other cultures. I went with what felt natural. People who are not Native American have played Native American roles in movies, and Native American actors shouldn’t be limited to exclusively Native American roles, unless they so choose - it is a matter of artistic freedom. Nowhere did I specify that the facepaint had to be Native American, but seeing as those are the people who were offended and had issues with the pictures, that is why this post is geared in that direction. I did not try to mimic designs of any specific culture or world region, but intentionally kept it generalized and fictional. From what I have read, the color white used in facepaint widely represents peace, and red - energy, happiness, and beauty. This may not be true of all societies, but from what I read in an effort to be somewhat politically correct I decided to let that influence my color choices. I think the problem may be that I am unaware of where the line should be drawn. In Native American sign language, a nod meant yes, head shake meant no, thumb to the chest was me, and index finger pointing meant you, etc. Everyone from every culture I know uses many of the signing I have read about and that is not taboo. Beaded jewelry is not taboo. It is clear that modern day wearing of headdresses is deemed taboo, and clearly facepaint is also looked down upon. Why are some things okay an others completely off limits? If I have the same, peaceful, good-hearted intentions, why are the actions so drastically different? Authentic headdresses etc should be made by and reserved for Native Americans who have authentically earned them. These young people who wear them because they are beautiful and connect to nature, aren’t wearing authentic ones. They are wearing representations. Lots of kids wear fire-hats out of admiration for their heroes. They aren’t wearing real hats/helmets and barging into a firehouse and getting in the way when the men need to leave promptly to rescue people...they are wearing representations in a non-legitimate environment. It is harmless. It is a compliment. I did not paint on a horrid Swastika or pose with a Confederate Flag. I’m not spreading messages of hate and violence. I never would. Through research I have read that “Congress has outlawed the unauthorized wearing of a purple heart but to the best of my knowledge has not outlawed the wearing of a war bonnet of any indigenous tribe.” I haven’t broken any laws or attacked anybody. I haven’t killed birds and tossed a headdress on and off at my own convenience like some baseball cap. The intention isn’t to undermine the meaning or significance of Native American peoples who HAVE earned the right. Just because I believe in my opinions does not mean that they are automatically correct or unchangeable. I hope that freedom of expression does not have to come at the cost of disrespecting others. I’d love to have someone calmly explain their concerns to me. I feel as though I am better educated on this subject than many of my peers, but not nearly as much as a could and should be. I’ll continue to do my research and talk with whomever I can. I know there are much more urgent and important issues, concerns, even crisis in the Native American population that deserve more attention than the misuse of traditional garb. I believe these conversations should be geared more toward those rather then something I currently see as harmless such as my wearing of facepaint. Fashion shouldn’t be a priority. So many people know about the headdress phenomenon and nothing about real dangers facing the Native American communities. Energy should go toward educating and putting an end to those issues first and foremost and if the borrowing and sharing (not taking) of their culture’s fashion is the only problem remaining, then sure, discipline some people for it if they are truly in the wrong. Thank you for reading, I appreciate it.