So I wanted to post my own quick response to this post by @rokukazuyaâ discussing whether Jesse started developing Stockholm Syndrome during his captivity ordeal with Todd. Specifically in regards to the symptoms that Jesse exhibits in the scene where he has the power to kill Todd and yet doesnât shoot him. A reddit poster described Jesseâs condition rather perfectly as - âlearned helplessnessâ. And it wasnât just Todd who inflicted this mentality on Jesse. It was Walt (or rather Heisenberg) who conditioned Jesse into thinking that if he ever tries to fight back, then he (or someone he cares about) will pay the price. So even when Jesse has the power to win and overthrow his captor, he wonât take it because heâs convinced itâll result in failure and punishments.   Â
The scene with Todd in the desert reminded me most of Jesse at the end of Rabid Dog when Hank has him wired up for the sting. In that moment, Walt was a sitting duck. Jesse could have walked over, let Walt spill his guts and it would have been over. But by that point, Jesse couldnât conceive of Walt not being all powerful. Walt had done so many evil ruthless things and gotten away with it. So Jesse couldnât imagine himself in a position of power. All he was seeing were the ways Walt could hurt him, punish him or kill him if he even tried anything.
Of course, Jesse did proceed to fight back. But only by first vowing not to do anything that Walt wanted. Jesse felt sure that he could only beat Walt by first refusing to be drawn into that perceived trap. Even though as it turned out, the meeting at the Plaza was no trap at all. And then Jesse came up with a trap of his own. And it worked. But then all went horribly wrong. Because you canât go up against the Devil and win. Todd and his gang were the manifestation of that unstoppable Heisenberg power that Jesse had feared during Hankâs sting.Â
I see Jesseâs abuse at the hands of Todd as an extension of the victimization he was already suffering from Walt. Todd might not be half as smart as Walt, but he doesnât have to be. You donât have to be a genius to use the tactic of threatening somebodyâs loved ones in order to control them. By the time Jesse was Toddâs prisoner, he knew that Jane had died and Brock had been poisoned so that Walt could deliberately make Jesse feel helpless and have power over him. Todd did the exact same thing when he murdered Andrea to break Jesseâs will.
The only difference between Jesseâs two abusers is that Toddâs abuse is far more naked and simplistic. Todd lamely offering Jesse a pizza to talk him down is just a dumber blunter version of all Waltâs little shows of fatherly caring and appreciation towards Jesse when he wanted to bring him to heel. In El Camino I even felt like they were mirroring the moment Walt hugs Jesse in Confessions. In both scenes Jesse tried to take a stand against his abuser and he expects to be punished for it. Jesse flinches and recoils when both Walt and Todd get close to him. When they force affection on him, he can only stiffen and cry. I donât think Todd alone brought Jesse to this state. But Todd didnât even need to be a master manipulator to gain crippling psychological power over Jesse. Walt had already conditioned Jesse to feel that way and to let it paralyze him.    Â