Hi! I'm Ivy 🩷
THIS IS MY ONCE UPON A TIME SHIPS MASTER LIST with ratings (I write for a few of these find my ao3 link below)
SEND ME MORE SHIPS canon not canon we want them ALL
OUAT ships and my ratings : click for more!
The numbering is random at this point. (The ratings are subjective and also depend on how I'm feeling, don't take it personally 🩷 we can disagree, I promise it's fine 🩷🩷)
Canon:
1.OutlawQueen - 8/10 - I liked it, it was good, it had potential. It didn't fully realize its potential. And Robin's death killed me.
2.CaptainSwan - 1/10 - sorry it's just one of those I don't see, I just didn't see any chemistry between them, which is sad because I like Killian.
3.CharmingSnow - 10/10 - I do love them, they're so sweet and wholesome. Yes.
4.Rumbelle- 0/10 - Boring. Toxic, and not in the fun way.
5. Rumple/Cora (Goldenheart? Idk) -8/10 - THEY BROKE ME. Such a good storyline, Cora's decision to rip her heart out, Rumple's heartbreak, how that makes him harder and more ruthless. Then of course how that influences his behavior towards Zelena and later Regina. Ugh. Doomed love is so good. And they are doomed by their own characters!! God.
- SwanFire - 6/10-- I like them as like...a past ship? If that makes sense. I liked them as kids and I like them co-parenting but I don't think they should've gotten together. Also it was sad when Neal died.
--Leopold/Regina-- I'M OBSESSED WITH THEM IN THE WORST WAY POSSIBLE. They're horrible and super toxic and abusive and I hate it so much. 10/10.
RedSlippers (Dorothy/Ruby) - yeah ok. Fan service. I always skip this episode, sorry. Idc. 6/10
KnaveBeauty (Will/Belle) yeah this is cute. 8/10.
Graham/Regina UFFFFF THIS IS HARD. 9/10. You know I die for that toxic shit.
Graham/Emma they kissed so that counts. 8/10. I want to dislike them but I don't? They wouldn't have worked out though, even if he hadn't died.
Zelena/Robin Yeah this was not it. I love toxic relationships but this was such an obvious retcon...4/10
Charming/Kathryn (princess Abigail) I don't think their relationship was as bad as they tried to make it seem like? I know he cheated but up until then they seemed to be communicating pretty well. 7/10
Milah/Rumple they were not good for each other, frankly. She was awful to him. No wonder he killed her. 6/10 cause baby Neal was cute
Killian/Milah We didn't see much of them but from what we saw they were good together. They were both selfish af though. 8/10
Robin/Marian I want to give them a higher rating based on other adaptations of their story (not ouat) but I can't. 3/10. He CHEATED while she was in a COMA.
Kinda canon I guess? :
6.GoldenQueen - 11/10 - I like this ship in all its iterations, Rumple and young Regina, Mr.Gold and Regina, Rumple and the Evil Queen, Roni and Weaver. It's so good. The potential is *chef's kiss*
7.DragonQueen - 9/10 - this is kinda canon. Fight me. I like it as a past relationship for Regina. It's good.
8.CaptainQueen (Killian/Regina) - 8/10 - yes. Tell me they didn't give "we fucked" vibes?? Tell me that.
--SleepingWarrior (Mulan/Aurora)-- listen this is canon. And 10/10. I mean they didn't get the ending they deserved but they should have. THEY SHOULD HAVE.
---Star Swan-- (Lily/Emma) is it controversial here? Maybe but idc, those two had a baby situation ship. 9/10. Emma and dark brunettes is 👩🏻🍳😘
---GlassQueen (Sydney/Regina) -- WHY has no one written fics about them??? WHY??! it's such a crazy, insane ship!! I mean he's obsessed with her and she barely glances his way half the time!! 8/10. Potential for toxicity is 1000/10 though.
FairyCaptain (Tinkerbelle/Killian) -- I think they had a thing. I think Killian really hurt Tink, but somehow she was still in love with him 😭 8/10
GoldenWicked or GoldenGreen: so toxic. But who hasn't fallen in love with their mentor who used to fuck their mom? Universal experience 8/10
Not canon:
9. SwanQueen - 1000/10 - perfect. Amazing. Incredible. Meant to be. I could go on.
10.GoldenCaptain (Rumple/Killian) 6/10 - It's cool, it's not something I think about, but in theory it's not bad.
11. Killian/Belle (CaptainBeauty?)- 9/10 - YES. this would've been so much better than CaptainSwan 😭
12.GoldenSwan (Rumple/Emma) - ?/10 - I have never thought about this ship, it just literally never crossed my mind.
13. SnowQueen (Snow/Regina) - 4/10 - no. (I'm thinking about it) I CHANGE MY RATING -- 7/10. I'm gonna need some fics of these two. It's so toxic.
14. WickedQueen (Zelena/Regina)- 5/10 - Not for me, but I get it.
15. WickedSwan (Emma/Zelena)- 5/10 - I get it. I'm not into it. But I get it.
No number. CharmingQueen (David/Regina) - 8/10 - NEVER would I have thought of this ship if it weren't for some awesome writers out there. Now I like it hehe.
- CharmingHook (CharmingCaptain? David/Killian) - 7/10 - I love weird ships. I LOVE weird, fucked up ships.
- WickedBeauty(Zelena/Belle)- You know what?? This has potential. 7/10. They should HATE each other. That's why it has potential.
--RedBeauty (Ruby/Belle)--- 8/10. I SEE THIS. I mean anything is better than Rumbelle but this is actually good!
---RedSwan (Ruby/Emma) --- 5/10 - listen. If I'm going to ship Emma with someone it's not going to be Ruby, I do think their friendship is very wholesome though!!
---RedSnow-- 7/10-- I actually kinda love this ship lol. Snow needs to relax a bit and I can totally see Ruby helping her do that mm.
---Sea Devil (as pointed out by @italianbeatrice) (Ursula/Cruella)--- 7/10-- these guys would fuck so nasty. And also they'd be incredibly toxic.
MadQueen (Jefferson/Regina) -- I might be the only one who didn't particularly like Jefferson but yeah...6/10-- cause Regina is good with everyone
MadSwan (Emma/Jefferson)--- they must have had chemistry cause they were actually together, right? Wrong. 5/10.
GUYS! Cora/Eva??? It makes so much sense!! -- 10/10. (Also idk what it's called...heartmother? Someone tell me what it's called)
RedCaptain (Ruby/Killian)- I know I gave it a 10 before but I'm calmer now and I'm demoting them to a 9. Still love the idea! Very hot.
FairyQueen (Regina/Tink) -- as much as I love any F/F ships with Regina, they're just so great as friends+ betrayal. 7/10
FairySwan (Emma/Tink) --- actually this is wholesome and I like it 7/10
GreenFairy- They're actually kinda cute together not gonna lie. 7/10
IceSwan (Elsa/Emma)-- ngl I usually don't love ship with Emma without Regina, but this I love!! They're actually very compatible without having to force it. 9/10.
IceQueen (Regina/Elsa) How did I forget this?? I actually really like this ship. As my friend @dreadfulhint says, maybe Elsa could teach Regina to *let it go* 8.5/10
Eva/Regina-- SO apparently I'm the only person who's ever written them meeting??(Not romantically though) I'm sure that's not true but when I went to tag the tag had never been used 😭 romantically 8/10. Imagine Leopold and Snow's faces HAH!
CaptainFire: (Killian/Neal-Bae) : actually yes. 8.5/10
Granny/Rumple : Blame @dreadfulhint!!!!!!!! FOR THE NIGHTMARE. 10/10
Granny/Emma (blame whoever made this edit twelve years ago): fantastic crack ship 10/10
Threesomes +
1. I swear I've read a fic on this but Cruella/Ursula/Maleficent (seadevildragon?)--- 7/10-- threesome or atomic bomb? We shall never know
2.Emma/Regina/Hook (CaptainSwanQueen)---since we're doing threesomes...10/10. I love this ship, I'm sorry!! I think it's super hot and they had so much chemistry!!
3.Emma/Regina/Maleficent (swanqueendragon?) -- ALSO 10/10!! This is three women I can't get enough of all together. Also Emma would be the jealous one and Regina would be the bottom getting punished for it. I just know it.
4. Emma/Regina/Rumplestiltskin (Goldenswanqueen??)-- has anyone written this ship except me? Please send if you have because this is another 10/10. Sorry. I know it's controversial.
5.MadSwanQueen --- POTENTIAL 7.5/10 (we're doing decimals now) it would be really cool in a s1 setting!
6. GoldenDragonQueen (Rumple/Mal/Regina) -- I have actually read a fic with these three. It was hot. 7.5/10.
7. CaptainRedBeauty: this would be Killian and Red tag teaming Belle and it would be sexy. 8/10
8. CaptainRedSwan: As I've said before, Emma and Killian...meh. I'm sorry 😭😭 6/10.
I FORGOT SEASON 7
16. StepQueen (Ivy,drizella/Regina) - 10/10 - Give me all the master-pupil dynamics, and all the Evil to Good teaching Evil trying to make her good 😭 I want more fics of these two tbh.
17. Alice/Robin - 10/10 - I love them. No notes.
18. Ivy/Henry (StepBeliever??idk)- 9/10 - they had so much chemistry!!! And it would've been so fun to see Henry fall for a villain 😭
19. Facilier/ Regina (WitchQueen?? Idk this either)- 8/10 - you know I love any ship with Regina (if that wasn't obvious) I just wish we'd known a little bit more!!
20. GlassBeliever (Henry/ Cinderella V.2) I'm so sorry to all shippers of them. I hate this ship. They had so little chemistry and it's not particularly interesting. 0/10
Controversial and/or triggering (DNDR)
Rumple/Neal- honestly he's so fucked up (you know who I mean) I could almost see this 8/10
Snow/Emma- ACTUALLY!! Yeah this is good, the fact that they didn't know they were related...and finding out....AHHHHH 8.5/10
Henry/Regina - I might get absolutely cancelled for this but I thought the show writers were going in this direction in s7, like a revival of Greek myths or something, a modern Oedipus moment...and I was here for it. Imagine the horribleness of it?? I live for that shit. 9.5/10
Henry/Emma - eh, this could be interesting but somehow I don't see it being AS horrible as Regina/Henry so it gets fewer points from me 6/10
RoseQueen or BlackQueen (Regina/Cora) I've said this before but this is so fucked up and Cora was so abusive I can just see this as like...more abuse. 8/10
RoseGreen (not sure about the name, Zelena/Cora) - I'm not a huge fan of Zelena but Cora would be cruel enough for this. IS THIS THE ONLY WAY YOU'LL LOVE ME, MOTHER?? 7.5/10
I'll be updating this!!
Send me your weird ships in asks or dms and I'll rate and add them🩷🩷
~~~~~
You can find me on AO3:
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works


















