I don’t have the musical education to explain why it sucks, it just does...half of its unsingable! It’s melodies are meandering and pointless and challenging to the layperson...everything’s wordy and ponderous! The lyrics are just- here’s a random song:
Now while the day in trailing splendor gives way to glories of the night,
thanksgiving to thy name we render, O God of darkness and of light.
Each day from thee we have our being, in all this wondrous order set;
thine omnipresence blinds our seeing, and in thy gifts we thee forget.
By the time you reach the end of a phrase you’ve forgotten the beginning of it! It means nothing! Every time I go in and people act like they sincerely want to sing 3 or 4 songs out of this wretched book over the course of a single hour I feel like I’m being gaslighted!
I will give a pass to anything simple, sweet, and clear of purpose- think Enter Rejoice and Come In, My Life Flows On, ‘Tis the Gift to be Simple, This Little Light of Mine, Spirit of Life, Come Sing a Song With Me...anything where the congregation gets to think to themselves “oh good, I know this” rather than “time to struggle through whatever the hell this is”. You can HEAR the energy change when they pick something people genuinely like, and it’s so rare! It should not be rare! Why are we sitting through interminable nonsense every week!!!
If it’s long and complex enough that you need a hymnal because people can’t memorize it after seeing the lyrics a few times, I honestly wouldn’t bother.











