Billy and Stu X Reader Headcanons (SFW and NSFW)
Content warning: 18+ content, BDSM, rough sex, handcuffs, knife kink, blood kink
Breaks into your room unannounced (usually to give himself an alibi).
He'll break in even if you're not there, you'll find him on your couch or in your bedroom watching horror movies like he owns the place.
"You should get some more tapes, I've already watched all of these 10 times over."
"Well maybe if you didn't break in every damn night-"
Loves to rile you up so you can play fight.
Will sometimes lead to some more NSFW scenarios but we'll get to that a bit later.
He always ends up on top of you, and will usually end up leaving a bunch of hickeys on you once you've "lost."
Not too big into cuddling but definitely won't complain about having you close.
This man doesn't sleep for shit but he wants you to get your rest.
Will complain if you try to stay up with him, especially if he can tell you're struggling to stay awake.
Will literally pull the-shushing and putting a hand over your eyes-method if you try to force yourself awake.
He isn't too crazy with PDA, he'll hold your hand, wrap an arm around you, but he's not too affectionate in public.
He likes to hang off you though, he does not care about height at all.
Once you're behind closed doors you're more affectionate, he'll kiss you, tease you, hell he'll fucking cook if you ask him (he's damn good with a knife).
I have a feeling he loves candles, especially more Halloween-y autumn-y scents, he'll light them to set a mood.
He (and Stu probably) definitely chased you as Ghostface, not to kill you but to spook you and give himself an alibi.
If you figured it out and didn't care he wouldn't pull it again.
WILL NOT let you in on the fun though, he already has issues controlling Stu, he doesn't need a third to worry about.
He'll literally kill for you though.
He'll still continue to break in after kills, probably uses your shower with extra care to clean it afterwards.
Spends more time at your place than his own house because of ✨parental issues✨.
He'll even sleep in your bed.
He loves taking you on dates because he loves you and he loves having alibis...
Loves to tease you, will rial you up and play fight you just to have and excuse to get on top of you so he can leave a fuck ton of hickeys and grind on you.
If he finds out you have a mask kink it is truly game over.
He will 100% wear the mask and outfit to take you.
He will use the base of his knife to penetrate you, make sure you have a fuck ton of lube.
He'll cut you a bit if you're into that, nothing vital but just enough.
Will also restrain you if you're into that, handcuffs are his go to.
This man will only be gentle if you ask, he is rough and you will be sore for days at the end.
He puts movies on when you fuck.
And light candles of course.
He loves to mark you up, everywhere, no area is off limits.
He definitely prefers to be the dominant one but he's willing to switch it up if you request.
Don't expect him to be an easy sub though, he's still going to be an asshole.
He'll go absolute ape shit if you put on lingerie or fishnets for him.
He likes your bed, but he's up for some experimention like the shower, table, couch, maybe the floor if it's carpeted and in front of a mirror.
He loves watching your expressions.
This man is too good with his hands, it's actually crazy.
He's not a fan of giving oral, he likes receiving more (he leaves giving up to Stu).
He loves to choke you, he knows just how to do it perfectly to get you riled up (he definitely practiced on Stu first).
He will relate the weirdest shit back to you, like unrelated slasher films somehow remind him of fucking or wanting to fuck you.
Stu definitely joins in but we'll get to that later.
Every move this man makes is slow, calculated, and deliberate. He knows just how to make you tick and if he doesn't know now he will find out eventually.
This man is NOT quick, he does not want quickies, he wants the whole night dedicated to fucking you.
He likes to make it a challenge to see how quiet you can be while your parents are around late at night.
If they're not there, he'll make you scream your brains out.
He loves all the little noises you make, he's not too vocal besides talking dirty.
He'll groan and grunt a little but you'd be hard pressed to get a moan or whimper out of him unless you really go at it as a dom.
In fact, he actually encourages you to be vocal, he loves getting instant feedback on how well he's doing and how good he makes you feel.
Very gentle with aftercare for someone who's so rough.
He'll clean you up, either run a bath or shower for you, taking it upon himself to scrub everything off you.
He'll cuddle with you afterwards, only time he'll do that voluntarily really.
If you comment on him being soft he'll either roll his eyes and push your face away or start to fuck you all over again if he knows you have the stamina.
Also breaks into your house, usually through a door though.
He's not as invasive as Billy, he will actually ask you if he can come over and allow you too invite him but, breaking in just has its fun.
Unlike Billy he loves to be all over you, cuddling, kissing you, just getting his hands all over you.
He will pick you up anywhere and everywhere, he'll just grab your legs in such a fluid and unpredictable motion, you never see it coming.
He will passionately make out with you.
He doesn't stay over as much as Billy does, but when he does stay the night they will be chaos twins, but once again, we'll get to that later.
Loves to cuddle and watch horror movies.
He'll bring in little baked goods for you.
Sometimes he sneaks in alcohol.
Or the baked goods happen to have weed.
Don't worry, he asks your permission first.
He just loves to party, even if he's just hanging out at your house.
Will steal your stuff, doesn't matter what, it's his now.
Loves when you mark up his neck and shoulder with lipstick or hickeys
Don't expect him to do nothing back though.
Similarly to Billy, he'll play fight you.
Easier to "win" against him since he's a lot less calculated and more clumsy than Billy.
He is still 6'4 and fairly buff though so that may be a problem.
Chased you as Ghostface once and never again because you found him out.
Upon Billy's request you will not be helping him out.
Unlike Billy he also LOVES PDA in public, his hands will always be on you.
Also unlike Billy this man passes OUT. He'll use you as a pillow even if he's like 3x your height, weight or whatever.
He'll cuddle you up to his chest.
Always sleeps in that damn red robe, it drives you crazy how good he looks.
Like Billy, he'll force you to sleep, this man wants to you have a good nights rest.
He's less of a dick but still has his moments.
He'll actually bring you videotapes instead of begging you to buy more.
Invites you over to his parents big ass house all the time.
Once again, COOKED if he finds out you like masks.
Knifes less so, surprisingly doesn't want to hurt you too much.
Still a restraints guy though.
Finding out you like the robe also means you're cooked, he will not take it off for sex unless it gets really hot.
He's cooked once you find out he loves you dressing up, lingerie, fishnets, anything sexy and he's losing it.
Also, willing to experiment in the area where you do the deed, but your bed will do just fine.
He's less willing to hurt and degrade you unlike Billy.
He's still crazy though, this man is a fucking monster in bed, you will never know his next move.
Loves watching you give oral but absolutely LOVES watching your face as he eats you out to the point you're overstimulated.
He'll use his fingers too, he really good with those.
Also, he marks you up. Between him and Billy, you'd better have good makeup skills or a wardrobe full of long-sleeve shirts.
He's cool with high or drunk sex, it makes him goofier and he likes that.
Unlike Billy, he won't risk your parents being around, he won't even touch you if they're there.
When they're not though, he loves all of the sounds you make.
He is just as vocal, he makes comments the whole time.
He's the type to start laughing and shit while actively cumming because he's having that good of a time.
He's also fine with switching things up, doesn't care if he's a dom or sub, prefers to be the dominant one though.
He's not a background noise person, he wants to focus on you.
He's a crazy freak in the sheets but he can tune it down if you need him too.
Worships your body, kisses all over.
After you two are done, he'll run a bath for the both of you.
Will complain if you only have a shower.
After you two are cleaned up, he cuddles and kisses you.
Whispers sweet nothings and puts on some movie he won't pay attention to.
If you tease him for it he'll find it amusing.
Billy Loomis and Stu Macher
Mfs will not shut up when they're around you. Constant playful bickering and arguing, it's like being trapped with a married couple.
You'd better have a shit ton of movies lined up, these two will go through them so quickly.
"You seriously have the third Halloween? You spent money on this crap?" - B
"Shut up, it's fun, I needed to complete my collection."
"I'm with Billy, you don't need beyond two, all the rest suck." - S
"Wow, didn't realize I had certified movie critics in my house."
"We're just saying you wasted your money." - S
You cuddle and watch movies, Stu falls asleep across the laps of both of you guys.
You had to ban note-taking devices to encourage them not to be homicidal maniacs in your house.
90% of the time they're not invited, they just show up.
They at least bring snacks though... Or at least Stu does.
Lord have mercy if you choose to play fight.
Both of them tag teaming you only ends in disaster.
One of them will end up holding you down while the other marks you, nothing too hard, just enough to make you giggle.
If you try to "escape" there is no sfw direction that situation is heading in.
If Stu is the one who invited both of you over, you guys will cuddle on his couch.
Back to the "Stu falling asleep" thing, if he falls asleep on both of you, he is out, you in Billy will have to attempt to carry him if either of you want to move.
If you fall asleep first, Lord have mercy.
Type of mfs to draw shit on you when you're asleep (mainly Stu).
Will tease you once you wake up.
"Oh hi sleeping beauty, someone's woken up from their beauty sleep." - S
"That an invitation?" - B
This is the only time you might find Billy actually sleeping, being between you guys and all the warmth brings out his body's more relaxed side.
Once he's out, he's out though.
You all pile onto yours or Stu's bed eventually.
Stu will be in the middle unless you request.
You will NOT CATCH Billy ever being in the middle, poor little psycho gets too hot.
Threesomes with these guys go INSANE
You will not be walking the rest of the night if you sub.
Both are rough and crazy.
Unless you request them to be gentle because you've had a rough day or something, they will go crazy with you.
Bruises, kisses, and bite marks EVERYWHERE.
If you try to "escape" while play-fighting, they will take off anything below the belt and start teasing
Having them both chase you as Ghostface goes crazy.
If you don't want to sub, Stu will.
You will NEVER catch Billy subbing.
Billy likes to do the dirty work, he'll get all up inside you or Stu and have one of you do oral beforehand.
Someone is ending up restrained.
Billy is more serious than Stu, there's kind of a good cop/bad cop situation happening.
They'll teach you some techniques ;)
Both are insane with their fingers.
Stu has some insane tongue work and Billy loves to watch.
Stu is louder than you and Billy combined, doesn't matter what he's doing.
Both of them love when you dress sexy for them, lingerie, fishnets, thigh-highs, they will eat you ALIVE.
Sometimes Billy will just invite Stu on the phone while actively doing the deed and he'll rush over to join in.
Stu loves it when you two give him attention, it makes him feel special.
Aftercare usually involves you three in the shower cause let's face it, the bath and barely hold you three.
You'll be in a big cuddle pile, probably some horror movie on the TV.
You guys go until you're done, even if you choose to tease, no one is going in for another round.
Stu is all giggly because he's probably still cock and or pussy drunk (or just regular drunk).
Billy probably teases the shit out of him for it. Sometimes you guys don't even need a blanket, you're that warm.
You all eventually fall asleep on each other.
No AI was used in the creation of this fic nor any others on this page. The creator of this blog is opposed to any use of generative AI and opposed to this fic being used to train AI or copied without consent.