There’s something wrong with Penelope
I realized I never explained my rewrite idea lol. It’s got the same plot/story structure as muffins/cupcakes with minor changes here and there. Pinkie pie and her sisters start killing at a young age, there’s a sister in the basement. Pinkie pie (aged like 25 ig) has been killing and eating people for 15 years when our story starts, she lives in ponyville where everyone knows everyone. She uses the town as a cover for her crimes, if she’s friendly with everyone, then no one will suspect her! But when a detective is been sent to investigate one random disappearance she starts pulling the threads of this cover up and discovers that almost half the town is missing at this point :D
Pinkie has naturally straight hair and sad/depressed personality, it’s only when she eats the “special ingredient” does pinkie pop up with positivity! Pinkie needs the gore in order to exist in public with a smile, she cant connect with anyone around her, even her “friends” aren’t safe! Honestly pinkie pie views the people around her as livestock that happens to speak the same language. If pinkie starts going thru withdrawals she’ll begin to hallucinate and Her mania manifests as a hungry, poofy hair-demon.
