Hi! I need some advice on how should I do this, I'll explain:
I used to be friends with this girl as kids (our moms kinda "made us" being friends cause we went to the same church) and we continued being friends as teenagers. She was a "theater kid" and that made me cringe a lot to the point that we had a fight about it and grew apart from each other. I remember she, back then, told me I was being a mean brat and that if I valued her and her friendship I should suck it up and go with her to her events/plays and stop making those faces and if I didn't then I never was her friend at all. I got mad too and told her that if she was my friend she wouldn't make me go with her to every single event/play that she was in, that I didn't meant to make those faces it's just that I couldn't stop it
Now we are both adults, we recently saw each other and chatted for a while. We both agreed that we were stupid teens, that all of our drama should stay behind
It was all good (I even got to met her husband and 3 kids and she met my fiance) until now that she invited me to a group event where they sing/act/do theater things. I tought she was joking at first but quickly realized she wasn't, I told her in the most polite way I could find that those events still make me cringe, that we should see each other outside those events and she (almost as exactly as the last time we had that fight) got all dramatic and defensive and told me that she thought that I had changed and matured but she realized I was the same as the last time we saw each other, that I was even making those faces again and, before I could say anything, she grabed her things and left, not before saying to me that she was gonna expect me to go at this event
I talked with my fiance about it and he laughed. Not in a mean way, it's just that we both think it's ridiculous, that we are both adults now, that she shouldn't be that hurt about something like that, that we can perfectly see each other outside those events. My fiance laughed even more about me doing "the faces". Again, not in a mean way, but in a "I know what faces she means". I mean, my fiance always says that I'm as expresive with my face as Emilia Clarke is, that I could tell a story by just making faces
Now, my fiance thinks that I should block this woman and move on but I don't know, isn't that too rude? Should I say something to her? I mean, I don't wanna go to this event but she's not gonna listen that. Should I just not go and that's it?
Yeah, the mom’s being friends and putting you two together expecting you two to get along is always wack. I feel like it never worked out for me. As a tangent, I remember my mom was friends with this girl in college (she went later in life) and she’d take my brother and I to her house and we’d “play” video games with her son. This kid was a total DICK and he never let us play so we’d just sit there watching. They had a dog that sucked too. They ended up not being friends anymore after she turned out to be an ass too. Anywho, I’ll continue on with your ask, but this just brought up some memories.
I will say, I do think it is kind of sweet that you two met after all this time. It sounds like you’ve got a good grasp on what the relationship was like for you and I do think it is so funny you think that the theater stuff is cringe. It kind of is so I get it, but yeah it sounds like she is really passionate about it. I would honestly laugh along with your husband just because I do agree it is ridiculous. You two are so much older and I feel like just because you grew up doesn’t mean you’re going to suddenly like theater stuff. I do think it is kind of wild that she expects you to go to her even after having what I feel like was a second minor falling out.
As far as blocking this woman, I mean, I don’t know her and I always want to give people a chance, but I feel like you and your fiancé sound like solid people so I feel like I should trust his judgement even though I’ve never met him. I think blocking should usually be reserved if you think the person is going to be a trouble maker later on. Regardless, even if they don’t make you trouble, she will be kind of annoying and it doesn’t sound like you two would end up spending much time together despite this rekindling. It just sounds like you two still might not have that much in common besides being older now.
My thought is, if you don’t think you’d actually want to spend time with this person going forward, then don’t go to the event. The earlier you do it the better because as an adult, I feel like our time is so precious so I wouldn’t want to spend it on something I don’t really like. Is it rude? Not really. I think it depends how someone takes it, but just because saying no is uncomfortable, doesn’t mean you need to do it. If you think there might be something a little salvageable from this relationship, then maybe go. Honestly, I think it would be a good experiment not to go just to see what her reaction would be. It would give a good bearing on what she is like as a person now. Ultimately, it is up to you. If I were you, I probably wouldn’t go and let things fizzle out, but that’s only because I’m not the type to be that excited about old friendships. I feel like sitting in an event is a commitment versus a relationship like this might be more of a “hey lets have coffee today” type thing.