- Inlove With Another You?
Batboys × Civilian reader!
SYPNOSIS: Rejection and confession at the same time after they tried to confess to you as their hero persona.
* Generic Fluff. * Short scenario. * during Robin era.
- Dick Grayson.
"No"
You told him, pushing him back like you were disgusted at his presence alone. Dick was beyond shocked.
He's been trying relentless at courting you both hero and as Grayson at school.
Does he care that Bruce is not happy about this? Yes, absolutely. But he's a big boy who just fell too hard for another. You can't blame the victim.
Bruce just doesn't understand the feelings racing through his veins whenever he saw you. He's too old to understand young love or puppy love.
The possibility of someone else slipping between you and him during his time as Robin was a high possibility.
That is why he took the oath of loving you as WonderBoy and Grayson, you deserve both of him.
Bruce could never understand the overthinking and bad feelings when his lovers ( not yet ) is out there by themselves... And not because he watched too much drama with someone.
To be honest, barbara loves torturing him by forcing him to watch them and the plot is about the girl falling for another because the boy is too busy- scary as hell.
Tonight he tried to kiss you, thinking you would too without hesitation... He was Robin afterall and every girl in Gotham drools over Robin.
Or he thought...
After saving you from a vicious dog, he took you to the rooftop where the star's were shining brightly, the moon visible.
His hand's on your waist, although he was nervous and his hands trembles abit he tried to be tough. That is what girls like.
Yet you pushed him when he was leaning near you, ready to kiss you under the shimmering moonlight stars decorating the sky.
"oh... sorry, i didn't mean to make you uncomfortable"
He apologized immediately to save himself. This was embarassing, he have been reading your signal wrong this whole time.
"I like someone else"
That hurt even more... This is exactly why he needs to be glued onto you, but it's too late to do that now...
"Who...?"
He was curious, who exactly is the guy that got you before he could?
"Dick Grayson"
Oh boy, he's ready to give any offering to your parents for your hands... They want his soul, money, body, sell his organs? yeah... sure as long as he gets to hear your dumb confession again.
His face flush and his smile almost reaching his face, you... like him. Guess being near you as much as possible is indeed the correct method of courting.
You didn't even kiss the WonderBoy because you love the actual him and not because of the mask... It's taking everything in him to not just reveal himself and kiss you.
You better bet he kissed you the moment he saw you as Grayson, doesn't matter who is present at the moment, your parents or even Bruce... No one is stopping him from taking your lips.
- Jason Todd.
"Im sorry"
The moment he heard your word his world crumble, he knew he couldn't have everything he wanted or need in life but you? You weren't a want you were a need and he couldn't see why the universe hated him so much for you to reject him so bluntly.
He thought you liked him, that was literally why he went through all the trouble of impressing you tonight.
Stealing Bruce wallet since he already spent plenty using his allowance. He booked a special show for you, fireworks and food and even a bouquet since girl's love them!
He was too naive and he rushed the whole process since he had a gut feeling that you might fall for another if he act too slow.
Suddenly the world was gloomy again, the cold air hitting his uncovered legs, the lingering smell of garbage, the one sided love story he was starring at hitting him all at once
He felt like he was back on the street with nothing, but now he had everything but you which was the same as nothing.
He wanted to cry but he couldn't not infront of you. He thought you liked him, you and him were friends from school and whenever he turned his head to admire you, you already beat him at it.
Hell, you kissed his cheek! Was it all platonic? Was the holding hands, telling secrets, the jealousy and all those supposed teenage love all just a stupid misinterpretation?
"I like Jason Todd, he's the one I want"
Inorder to make it less awkward you mentioned the guy you liked, him. Unbeknownst to you.
Jason's heart was suddenly pumping at an abnormal beat. He completely forgot that he was ROBIN and not JASON at the moment...
All the depressing thoughts exit his mind as he just stared at your lips... He had- He has a real chance... You actually liked him. Hearing you say it makes everything more difficult to process.
Yes, he was somewhat confident that you like him but... Hearing you confirm it wasn't the same as him telling himself that it's the truth.
The fireworks went off which forced his attention to shift from you to the colours adoring the night sky. Atleast you weren't aware that he was the one who booked it, it would have been more awkward and he wouldn't be able to forget it even if he get to marry you at the end.
Yet the light of colours couldn't captivate him as much as you did. He looked at you as the colours highlight your entire self, absorbed in the sudden burst of Colors in the sky.
"I understand..."
He didn't say much, he doesn't want or need to. Everything was failing successfully. Although his heart ache knowing he stole money for no reason, you didn't enjoy it that much. It's hard to when the hero you rejected is literally by your side.
He didn't even wait for the moon to vanish, sneak out of the manor and went to your house. Breaking in was something he was good with and lucky him your window was opened.
He kissed you that night, not as Robin but as himself, under the dimly lit room holding onto you like life itself.
- Tim Drake.
"I don't like you"
Tim couldn't focus on anything, not even how you were refusing to look at him. He could only feel his heart breaking inside his rib and embarrassment flooded it's way into his system.
He stood there as his hand went to his hair to push it back from blocking his view. Pressing his lips together, as he took a big breath.
You sounded so sure. Well you were but how could he be so stupid...? It took him two years to come to this conclusion of confessing.
With the help of Stephanie he planned this moment. He made sure it was perfect and just how you'd wanted it.
Yet, the problem was that you didn't even reciprocate his feelings back from the start.
He had taken you to the highest building in the city that had this extremely detailed carved gargoyles on it. Which might nor be romantic for most but it was the details that matter.
He met you because of a gargoyle, one carved resently and was bought by Bruce. Fortunately you broke it and the craftsman dragged you to Bruce to apologise and pay for it.
The moment he saw you something felt odd. Yes, you were in tears because you broke a billionaire statue... But you looked so- He can't explain what he felt then it was too complicated.
That was the begging of your friendship with Tim. Ever since the feeling of love grew into something bigger than he anticipated.
"Why?"
He asked, he was afraid of the answer yet he desperately needs to know what he did wrong. Why wouldn't you want him as much as he did?
He was so sure of himself that you loved him dearly maybe not as much as he did but it was there! He spent every hour making sure it was! What did he calculate so wrong? Was he so bewitched by you that his rational mind left and vapourised into delusion?
But, he couldn't think of any other big misinterpretation in his life to connect to this. He was smart, found out batman true identity and claim the title of Robin without anyone help...
Yet he couldn't understand what love was like? This wasn't your fault, it's his for viewing every detail with so much attention in hopes of you reciprocating his feelings that he convinced himself you did as well.
" I like someone else... "
He stood there as his blood drain from his brain, surely dying was better than seeing you smile at another guy just as he did with you.
God... If he can't have you what's the point. Yes he knew teenage love rarely ends well but he was sure that he wouldn't be able to fall in love with another anymore.
" I like Tim Drake "
The moment you told him suddenly all the blood rush back to his brain and as well as his face. So, he wasn't wrong... He knew it! Afterall he took 2 years to make sure that you like him back. Never doubted himself.
Next time the two of you met it was at the same place as where he tried his luck as Robin. But this time he finally got to call you his as an end result.
He kinda blame himself for confessing as Robin and not as the Tim you knew... Atleast he get's to kiss you against the gargoyle.
- Damian Wayne.
"I can't accept"
Damian stood there as he stared straight into your eyes sending chills down your spine. You wanted to look away but you were to scared to even act upon it.
He had accidentally said the word after he thought you died, but turns out the world just wanted to see him being humiliated as he saw you standing beside him shock.
He scoff not at you, he wasn't mad at you for having a basic opinion towards someone... He was mad at himself for being vulnerable enough to even utter it out loud.
You were from school and the only person who managed to be his 'friend' tho he usually refers to you as something else.
He hated you deeply for planting his mind with yourself and taunting him relentlessly as time past. Yet he wasn't very willing to let you go, he rather have you at arm's reach. He just wanted it gone without hurting you.
He's read enough manga to realise the feeling and he absolutely despite himself for falling for a plain girl like you. Although you being friends meant you weren't exactly normal...
Ignoring it only made it worse. He would sometimes end up sketching you without realising it, staring deeply at your face which from your point looks like he's judging you severely and the fact that he always saved you first amongst other.
Which he always ended up being teased for. Afterall he was the one who picked you up and took you to the safety zone while completely ignoring the mayor... In his defence there can always be another mayor but you on the other hand can never be replaced.
" I like someone else "
You utter out, not knowing what to even say to him. He was Robin afterall and the most intimidating one... And you rejected him straight to his face, you got some guts to even continue your speech.
Damian on the other hand felt a pang in his heart. Right, another person always intervene and stop the second lead from ever having their chance... He hates love traingle even more now...
Whomever you fell for better be some kind of deity or he'll absolutely- He needs to control his mind. Although he appears to be unaffected outside he was having a whole monologue enough to create a romantic manga.
He just wish he's never met you at all and yet at the same time he was happy with the presence you have provided in his life, even if it meant breaking his own rules and the method he was taught at a young age.
" I like Damian Wayne! "
It seems his stare alone could make you completely loose control of your mouth, you're just making it worse...
Damian eyes widen abit, not enough to be noticed by you. Stupid you, why didn't you say so... Why did you have to be so stupid and make him feel like he actually got a chance to be happy?
Yet he did everything to make sure he didn't suddenly remove his domino and grab your face and kiss you, later he would cuss you out for speaking too much and little at the same time.
His demeanor change to something more comfortable, maybe falling for an idiot wasn't so bad when they can't even control themselves.
He thought he'd end up with someone as smart as him but guess that wouldn't be the greatest balance... His intelligence can compensate for all that you lack.
" I see "
He left without another word, you were obviously scared of him and that wasn't the best feeling. He understood tho, he wouldn't be comfortable around someone he rejected especially when they dress like a night freak.
The next day he saw you at school set your favourite drink on your table while still with that face of his.
" Learn to adapt under pressure, you'll go nowhere if not "
He didn't confess outright, there was plenty of time and his mind is set at being with you now. He just want to express his feelings more before he gets to call you his.

















