Splash
Part 6
Pairing: JJ Maybank x Mermaid
Warnings: Nudity
Word Count: 6.8k
A/N: It's giving Aquamarine 🤭🌺
Masterlist
The next day, JJ probably looked at the clock at work a thousand times.
After yesterday's scare, he'd tried not to let his mind go there, but he couldn't help but worry about Angel. He tried to focus on work, on cars, on fucking around with his coworkers– on literally anything other than the fear that somebody was out there trying to snatch up his mermaid-girlfriend-who-wasn't-actually-officially-his-girlfriend.
But every time his thoughts wandered, they went right back to her.
What if that guy comes back and she doesn't react quick enough this time?
What if somebody else sees her?
What if she doesn't come back?
A little after four, he got a notification that Kiara had sent a picture to the group chat. He grabbed his phone and opened the chat expecting to see some dumb meme, but instead he felt relief fill his entire body.
His shoulders finally relaxed against the garage wall as he looked down at a picture of Angel. She was sitting on Sarah's bedroom floor in his clothes, trying not to laugh while Sarah leaned in and attempted to put lip gloss on her lips, very much laughing.
She was okay.
She was safe with Kiara and Sarah doing some silly girly stuff.
JJ just stared at it for a second. He zoomed in on the picture, to the tiny bit of shimmer on Angel's lips, then smiled the biggest dopiest smile that his coworker, who happened to glance over at him, had ever seen.
JJ: She looks cute
"A girl?" his coworker asked.
JJ jumped, snapping back into reality. "Yeah. Yeah, kinda."
"Kinda?"
"Yes. Yeah." He shook his head and huffed out a laugh. "A girl."
"Well that explains why you've been smilin' all the damn time." His coworker snorted and went back to work.
A new text popped up as he was saving the picture to his phone.
Kiara: She just SQUEALED. She misses you.
JJ smiled harder.
JJ: Oh yeah? Tell her I miss her too
A minute passed. JJ's lips twitched, figuring the girls were having to explain how texting works.
Kiara: She says she needs you to taste her lip gloss when you get home.
JJ actually had to turn away so nobody could see his face now.
JJ: Can't wait
He glanced at the clock and sighed when he saw that he still had an hour and a half until he got off. "Fuck me."
After work, JJ zoomed down the dirt road to the Chateau, tired, sweaty, and more than ready to see her.
And then he did and he almost crashed right then and there.
Angel was sitting in the grass between Sarah and Kie, looking completely different than any other time he'd seen her, and JJ nearly forgot how to breathe.
She was wearing a pair of Sarah's shorts and a little tank top, a puka shell necklace sitting around her neck. Her hair was down as usual, but with tiny braids woven in random places. There were probably ten different bracelets stacked around both her wrists. And her fingernails were pink.
JJ just stared. He absolutely loved seeing her in his clothes but this... this was different.
"JJ!" She started getting to her feet.
"Wait!" Sarah grabbed her wrist and Angel froze mid stand. "One more nail!"
JJ laughed under his breath, shaking his head.
Sarah carefully finished painting the last fingernail while Angel stared impatiently at JJ like she was gonna explode if she couldn't be close to him in the next two seconds.
"Okay," Sarah smiled. "Done."
Angel practically launched herself up and took off running across the grass.
"Angel, don't hug him!" Kiara shouted. "Your nails aren't dry!"
Angel stopped herself at the last second, then carefully placed both hands flat against JJ's shoulders instead, absolutely beaming.
JJ's hands settled around her waist. "Hey, pretty girl."
"Pretty?" She immediately glanced down at herself.
His eyes traveled over her outfit again, smiling so wide his eyes crinkled. "Yeah. You look... really beautiful."
"Thank you," she said softly and he could see the way heat crept to her cheeks. Then she looked down at herself. "I'm a girl."
JJ's eyebrows lifted and he looked toward Sarah and Kiara. "Well, thank God. I was worried there for a second."
Angel's eyes widened.
Kiara scoffed. "Don't confuse her!"
"I'm kidding," JJ laughed, fiddling with one of the little braids Kiara had woven into her hair. "You are definitely a girl."
She giggled. "I look like them. Instead of you."
He nodded. "You do."
Her eyes narrowed slightly like she was remembering something, then she smiled. "Sooo..."
JJ tilted his head. "So?"
Angel's gaze flicked toward his mouth before returning to his eyes. "You said you wanna taste my lip gloss? ....On the text?"
JJ's eyebrows lifted. "Oh, yeah..." His eyes immediately dropped to her lips now. "Yeah, I'd love to."
She reached into the pocket of her shorts and pulled out the little tube. "Sarah gave me it."
He smiled. "That was nice of her."
Instead of handing it to him, she twisted the cap off and carefully put on another layer.
JJ watched, his grin slowly growing.
Angel pressed her lips together once then released them with a pop like the girls had showed her, then she looked up at him.
JJ didn't even have time to say anything before she leaned up and kissed him. He smiled immediately and she couldn't help but giggle, which made him smile harder. The kiss was soft and sweet, and JJ hummed when he tasted the fruity flavor.
She pulled back after a moment and JJ licked his lips.
He nodded. "That's good. Tastes good."
Angel giggled again.
He rubbed his own lips together as he tried to figure out the flavor. "What is it?"
The word was on the tip of her tongue as she thought about it, but she gave up after a few seconds. "I forgot..."
JJ laughed softly. "You forgot?"
She nodded. "Yeah."
He looked at her lips again. "Well... Let me try it again. We'll figure this out."
"Okay," She reached up, slipping both hands around the back of his neck.
The girls laughed quietly from across the yard as they watched her pull him back down.
This kiss lasted a little longer. JJ leaned into it, one hand staying at her waist while the other settled lightly against her back, pulling her closer and Angel melted into him immediately. When JJ's tongue briefly brushed against hers, Angel made the tiniest surprised sound.
For another few seconds they stayed there, completely caught up in the kiss, until they finally separated.
They both looked at each other, equally dazed, faces still inches apart.
He swallowed, then glanced at her lips. "Cherry?"
She nodded softly. "Yeah... cherry."
Sarah and Kiara stood and walked over.
"Okay, lovebirds, we have a proposition," Sarah announced.
JJ snapped out of his daze and let go of her, then narrowed his eyes. "What would that be?"
"We're taking Angel shopping."
His smile faded slightly. "Uh..."
Angel nodded. "They say I need my own clothes. Not just yours. And I wanna see more people things."
The girls both looked at him, immediately realizing why he was nervous after hearing what had happened yesterday.
He glanced toward the marsh, the fact that someone had tried to catch her still heavy on his mind. His protective instinct still kicked into overdrive.
But then Angel gently grabbed his wrist. "Shopping?"
She said she didn't think the man saw her face. He thought.
And she looked so excited that JJ couldn't bring himself to say no.
He sighed. "Fine."
Angel squealed.
"But," JJ added, pointing at her feet, "you have to wear shoes."
She looked down at her bare feet suspiciously. "Why?"
"Because humans wear shoes at stores."
"Why?"
"Because apparently our feet are too delicate for the ground."
Kiara snorted. "And our ground gets a little gross sometimes. From people littering."
Angel made a face, having had a long conversation with Kie about littering earlier that day. She told her about things she'd seen in the ocean that almost made her cry.
Sarah disappeared inside and came back out with the Twinkie keys and a pair of white sneakers.
Angel sat in the grass and slid her feet into them before JJ bent down to tie the laces.
She stood, took an experimental step and immediately made a face. "These are weird."
Everybody couldn't help but laugh.
Angel was completely fascinated the entire ride in the Twinkie. She sat in the passenger seat beside JJ, staring out the window with those wide curious eyes like she'd been dropped into another universe.
She recognized things she'd seen in the movies they'd watched like grocery stores and drive thru restaurants, but she still had questions.
SO many questions.
And they all honestly loved answering them, as well as arguing about the best way to explain whatever she was asking about.
JJ smiled the whole way there, because seeing her discover everything made even the most mundane things feel new again.
By the time they pulled into the shopping center, Angel had learned about signs, traffic lights, parking lots, beach stores, advertising techniques, and that cars ate very expensive gas in order to move.
Also that it apparently costed money to do just about everything, which was kind of a bummer.
They walked into the clothing store and Angel's jaw dropped. "This is a lot of clothes."
"Yeah," Kiara nodded, smiling. "It is."
Angel walked forward, pulling JJ with her.
Once she got to the first rack, she let go of his hand to touch a shirt. Then another. Then a dress. Then another. Then held up a pair of shorts.
JJ followed behind her, hands in his pockets, watching her inspect everything with the seriousness of someone exploring the ocean floor. He noticed how she, of course, paid extra attention to anything pink or sparkly.
He picked up a short, flowy pink dress and held it out. "You like pink, don't you?"
Angel looked over. "Yes. I am pink."
JJ grinned. "True." He held up the dress. "I'm not exactly a fashion expert, but..."
Kiara scoffed. "That's an understatement."
"Shut up, Kie." JJ looked back at Angel. "But this?" He held the dress against her. "You?"
Angel stared, smoothing it down the front of her body
"Me." She nodded slowly. "Yeah. Me."
He immediately smiled at the idea of her all dressed up. "Definitely you."
She hugged the dress to her chest. "I love it."
JJ's smile widened. "Okay, yeah, we're getting that."
Sarah handed Angel a shopping basket. That was their first mistake. Because Angel apparently interpreted shopping basket as collect as many beautiful things as humanly possible.
Five minutes later, she slipped on an enormous pair of pink sunglasses and giggled at herself in a mirror before turning to JJ. "These?"
He snorted. "Oh god. No."
Angel put a matching pair on him and couldn't contain her laughter.
"Why do people even wear these?" she managed through her giggles.
JJ tried to catch his breath. "Because the sun's bright."
Angel looked at him like he'd said the silliest thing she'd ever heard. "But that is the sun's job?"
JJ sighed dramatically, shaking his head. "Humans are weak."
Sarah quickly snapped a little candid picture with her phone. "For their wedding," she whispered to Sarah.
"Oh, for sure," Sarah agreed. "That's adorable."
JJ squinted at them over the glasses, but couldn't wipe the smile off his face.
Sarah grabbed a floppy sun hat and plopped it on her head. "There. That completes the look."
She looked back over at the mirror and slowly turned her head to the left. Then to the right. Then started laughing again, even harder.
JJ leaned against a rack, just watching her, unable to stop laughing himself. She was actually the most adorable thing he had ever seen.
Kiara elbowed Sarah in the arm. "He's gone."
"Yup."
He had never seen anybody so excited about life. And every second he spent with her, it rubbed off on him a little more. With her around, JJ was truly starting to feel more like himself again.
Which made him even more upset that anyone would want to try to take her life away from her.
Try to make money off of her.
Experiment on her.
Whatever the hell they wanted to do to her, the thought made him sick to his stomach. But he tried not to think about it.
In the next ten minutes, the basket Sarah had given her quickly became stuffed.
JJ eventually looked at it, laughing nervously. "Jesus, Angel."
She looked up at him innocently from where she was crouched, looking through everything she picked. "What?"
"That's a lot."
She glanced down. "Too much?"
His expression immediately softened. "No, no. Not what I meant." He crouched beside her. "You can have stuff. I'm just saying... clothes cost money."
She frowned. "Them too?"
"Yeahh."
"All human things cost money?"
JJ grimaced. "Unfortunately."
She sighed. "I want so many things."
"I know." JJ laughed. "Look, you can pick six things." He held up six fingers. "Six."
Angel stared at his hand and did the same. "Six?"
"Six."
They both stood and she immediately smiled and stood on her tip toes to give him a quick kiss on the cheek. "Thank you."
He couldn't help smiling back. "Maybe seven."
She smiled harder.
"And a bikini."
Sarah immediately stepped in. "I'll get her the bikini."
Angel turned toward her. "Really?"
"Yeah."
"Thank you!"
Kiara grabbed her hand. "And I'm getting you a purse."
"A purse?"
JJ watched them lead her toward the bags.
Eventually, Angel finally emerged from the dressing room, her basket a little less full and with Sarah and Kiara, who were holding everything she reluctantly decided not to get.
She had chosen two pairs of shorts, a mini skirt, blue dress, the pink dress, a tank top with a hibiscus flower, another tank with little sequins, a crochet bag and a pink bikini that was almost the exact color of her tail.
She looked at herself in the mirror one last time, still wearing the blue dress.
JJ stood behind her
The way he was looking at her was probably similar to how she looked at pancakes, before absolutely devouring them.
She looked at him through the mirror. "Pretty?"
JJ's smile was immediate and not only because of how fucking gorgeous she looked in a dress, but because he really liked how they looked together. "Very."
She turned around. "Very?"
"Very."
She walked straight into him and wrapped her arms around his waist. "Thank you."
JJ hugged her back. "You're welcome."
He wished he could buy her the entire store in that moment.
Sarah gasped. "Wait." She pointed down the street. "Ice cream. Angel needs to try ice cream."
Angel's head snapped toward her. "What is ice cream?"
A group of younger girls shopping nearby looked over, then at each other, wondering if they all heard her right.
Sarah grinned. "Something you need to try."
Angel immediately grabbed JJ's hand. "Let's go."
JJ laughed. "Okay, damn, wait. We haven't even paid."
"Oh yeah..." Her face scrunched up in annoyance. "Money."
"Yeah, I know right."
She thought for a second then leaned in close to JJ's ear. "What if we just walked out with the stuff? What would happen?"
The girls snorted, looking around to make sure that nobody had heard.
"You'd get arrested," Kiara mumbled.
"Arrested?"
Sarah nodded. "Yeah, by the police. The people that make sure people don't break laws."
"Laws?"
"Which would be a huge problem, because you technically don't even have an identity," Kiara added.
"I...den-tity?"
Sarah laughed. "We'll explain later."
JJ wrapped his arm around Angel's shoulder, smiling proudly. "I knew there was a reason I liked you."
The four of them put the shopping bags in the Twinkie and headed down the street to the colorful, slightly kitschy little ice cream shop on the corner, Desserted Island Ice Cream.
Angel suddenly stopped dead in her tracks as she noticed something.
JJ walked straight into her. “Shit, sorry," he laughed. "What is it?”
Angel pointed upward. “Look!”
Everybody followed her finger to a giant, blue ceramic dolphin sculpture sticking out of the roof of the little pink building.
“Dolphin!”
JJ grinned. “Yeah, that's a dolphin. Not a real one though.”
She nodded, still smiling. "I know. It's just art." She giggled and grabbed JJ's hand, dragging him toward the entrance. "I love this place."
“Alright, alright,” he laughed. “Jesus. Don't leave everyone behind.”
Inside, Angel immediately looked around at all the different color walls and furniture and pictures of ice cream.
Sarah leaned toward Kiara, watching as Angel laughed at a fake shark head on the wall. “What do we even get her?”
“Something pink,” Kiara decided.
Angel's head snapped toward them.
Sarah smiled. “Wanna try strawberry flavor?”
“Straw...berry… Yeah, sure!”
“Okay. And if you don't like it, you can have mine. I'm getting coconut.”
Angel nodded seriously. “Trade.”
“Trade.”
They ordered their ice cream and found a table outside beneath an umbrella. Angel sat beside JJ, and stared at her cone.
He nudged her. “You gonna eat it?”
“I'm looking.”
“I see that.”
She took her first lick.
Sarah smiled. “Good?”
“Very good.” Angel nodded quickly. "Holy shit."
Everyone laughed, still finding it way too funny whenever she cussed.
She took another lick. Then another. And then the sun did what the sun did and it began melting down the cone onto her hand.
“No.” She quickly licked it away.
But it kept happening. And JJ couldn't stop laughing
She whined pitifully and looked over at him for help. "JJ. Why?"
"It's hot outside," he shrugged, handing her a napkin. "Frozen things just do that."
Angel sighed and began eating as fast as possible... which, of course, led to a brain freeze. She froze halfway through a huge bite, and her eyes squeezed shut. “...Ow.”
JJ looked over. “Brain freeze?”
She nodded miserably. "I think."
“Yeah. That happens if you eat it too fast.”
Angel groaned and dropped her forehead onto the table, still clutching her rapidly melting cone,
“I don't like ice cream.” She sighed and lifted her head to take another lick, before dropping it back down. "But I do."
They all burst out laughing.
"It is not funny."
JJ laughed harder, reaching over to pat her back while she stayed face down on the table, giggling despite herself.
She lifted her head a few seconds later and went back to eating and JJ couldn't stop watching her. Or smiling.
After a few minutes she leaned against his shoulder, happily eating her cone, relieved that the hard part was over.
The girls noticed how his smile softened.
His hand slid to her lower back, fingers threading through the ends of her hair and she automatically scooted closer to him.
He realized then that he was getting way too used to this. Whatever this was.
He honestly didn't know what the hell they were doing yet, but whatever it was, he really, really liked it.
Which was really, really terrifying.
Sarah suddenly held up her phone. “Okay, look at me and smile.”
Angel smiled the biggest goofiest smile they'd ever seen from her.
JJ didn't have to do anything. He was already smiling.
Sarah snapped a picture and turned the phone around.
Angel's mouth fell open when she saw it. She obviously knew what pictures were, but she had never seen one of herself.
“Look it's us,” she laughed.
JJ glanced over at her instead of the phone. "It is."
"We look pretty."
He nodded. "We do."
"You wanna take another one?" Sarah asked.
Angel nodded and wrapped her arms around his shoulders. "Yes!"
Sarah lifted her camera and Angel pressed her lips to JJ's cheek.
She showed it to them afterwards and JJ nodded in approval. "Yeah. Send me that."
Angel smiled. "Me too."
"You don't have a phone."
"Oh."
The girls started asking her what she thought about being out in the human world.
Angel nodded. “Good.”
“Just good?” Kiara asked.
Angel nodded again. “Very good. Lots of things.”
“Yeah,” Sarah said. “There's a lot to see.”
She sighed dramatically. “But...”
JJ looked at her. “But?”
“Human things cost money.”
Everybody groaned and nodded in agreement.
Angel frowned. “I want lots of money.”
Kiara laughed. “Don't we all?”
They eventually got up and started walking back toward the Twinkie.
Angel was in the middle of telling Sarah something when she suddenly slowed, staring at someone over JJ's shoulder.
JJ noticed. “What?”
Angel raised her hand and waved.
He turned to see an older man standing across the street, looking wildly out of place among the beach town crowd in a gray suit. And he was staring directly at Angel like he couldn't take his eyes off her.
After a moment, the man lifted his hand and waved back, lips curling up in a strange smile that didn't reach his eyes underneath his mustache.
JJ's smile disappeared.
Sarah noticed too. “Who is that?”
Angel shrugged. “Don't know.”
The man gave them all one last look before turning and walking toward a black Bentley parked along the curb. Then he glanced back one last time before opening the door.
JJ looked down at her. “Hey.”
"Hm?" she asked, still watching as he began to drive off.
“You probably shouldn't wave at strangers.”
Her brows furrowed. “Why?”
“Because you don't know them.” JJ sighed.
She tilted her head as she tried to understand.
“Especially weird creepy old men,” Kiara added.
Angel's eyebrows pulled together. “Oh.”
JJ immediately softened. “I'm not trying to be a dick. Just–don't wave at random people, okay?”
She nodded. “Okay.”
"Not everybody is good or nice or has good intentions. Especially when it comes to pretty girls like you, unfortunately."
She smiled a little at the last part.
He looked back down the street as the Bentley disappeared and took Angel's hand in his. His stomach felt strangely tight, because yesterday, somebody had tried to catch her. Somebody who was probably still around. And now a strange man had been staring at her.
Maybe he'd just noticed the gorgeous girl walking down the street... That was entirely possible. Hell, JJ would've just about broke his neck to look at a girl like her if he'd never seen her before.
But suddenly he couldn't stop wondering whether there was another reason. Like if somebody had seen her face or word had gotten around about a Kildaire Island mermaid with long waist length hair like hers.
Whether that man knew exactly what Angel was.
JJ glanced down at her to see examining one of the bracelets the girls had given her earlier and smiling to herself as they walked, completely oblivious to his thoughts. He gently squeezed her hand without thinking.
Angel looked up at him. “JJ?”
“Yeah?”
“You're thinking.”
He stared at her. “How the hell do you always know that?”
She giggled. “Your face.”
He snorted and squeezed again. “Yeah, well. Don't worry about it.”
She leaned against his arm as they walked. "Okay."
But JJ kept looking back toward the road, more high alert than ever. Because the fact that there was a chance that somebody could take her away from him– could take her freedom away from her– scared the absolute hell out of him.
It was finally Friday.
Another day at work, another day where JJ couldn't stop thinking about Angel. It was actually becoming a problem.
He'd always been pretty good at getting distracted when he needed to be. Work used to be one of the places where he was able to quiet his brain just a little when he was really going through it. But lately, every spare second belonged to her.
And today, especially, he kept thinking about the way she'd looked at him yesterday. How excited every new thing made her. How she looked in girly clothes. How adorable he thought she was when she was frustrated that her ice cream wouldn't stop melting.
He couldn't stop pulling his phone out and looking at the pictures Sarah and Kiara had taken of the two of them.
And then there was still the fact that someone had tried to catch her, of course. It made him ill every time he thought about it.
He hadn't lied when he told her he'd do everything he could to keep her safe. He felt a strange protectiveness for her that he'd never felt for anybody before.
But it wasn't only that.
He was falling for her. Hard. And he was finally coming to terms with that.
It had been one week, and she had already become the person he looked forward to seeing every morning and every afternoon when he got home.
It wasn't exactly love at first sight. Even though he was obviously immediately very attracted to her.
At first, he'd been confused as hell. Then he'd been fascinated. Then she'd started making him laugh. A lot. She'd looked at him like there was nothing wrong with him, nothing broken or disappointing or worth judging.
And she'd brought a kind of happiness and excitement into his life that he hadn't realized he'd been missing.
And he wanted her to know that. Needed her to. So he decided he'd tell her when he got home, which only made the day go by even slower.
Angel wasn't having a much easier time thinking about anything but him.
She was with the girls by the Chateau dock and usually she'd be listening intently to everything they said, absorbing every drop of information she could, but she definitely was not right now.
She held onto the side of Kiara's paddleboard with one arm while she let her body drift through the water. Every once in a while, the board wandered too far from everyone and Angel would flick her tail beneath, effortlessly guiding it back toward the dock.
Cleo was on her back on a towel. Sarah was sprawled across a pink floatie wearing sunglasses and sipping on a Whiteclaw.
Kiara was sitting on the board, talking about something Angel had completely stopped hearing about five minutes ago.
Everyone was keeping their eyes and ears open for boats, just in case.
So was Angel, but she was also deep in thought. Her cheek was resting against her forearm on the paddleboard, eyes fixed somewhere far beyond the marsh and a little smile on her face as she thought nonstop about JJ.
Kiara stopped talking mid sentence and smiled too. "You're thinking about him, aren't you?"
Angel blinked and looked up at her. "Who?"
Kiara gave her a look. "You know who."
Angel's smile immediately gave her away. "JJ," she said softly, smiling even harder just how his name felt on her tongue.
"Yeah."
"Yeah." Angel sighed dreamily, completely unashamed. "I really like him."
The girls exchanged a quick look.
"Yeah," Sarah said laughing softly. "We've noticed."
Angel smiled down at the water. "You're lucky."
Kiara tilted her head down at her. "Why's that?"
"You've known him a long time."
"Yeah." Kiara smiled. "I have."
"He's very special."
Kiara's smile grew. "Yeah. That's one way you could describe him."
Cleo stretched her arms above her head. "JJ actually said the same thing about you."
Angel's head popped up. "He did?"
"Yep."
Her smile returned immediately... until it suddenly disappeared.
"What's wrong?" Kie asked.
Angel looked down at her hands. "JJ never kisses me."
All three girls stared.
Sarah slowly lowered her sunglasses, the corner of her mouth curving up. "Uh..."
Angel frowned. "I mean... he kisses me back all the time."
Cleo snorted. "Yeah, I was about to say..."
"But he never does it first."
That made them all quiet for a second.
Angel looked genuinely confused. And a little sad. "Why?"
Kiara glanced at Sarah and Cleo before answering gently. "Okay. So... humans... usually, when two people meet, they don't immediately start kissing."
Angel's eyebrows pinched together. "Why?"
Sarah smiled. "Because usually you don't know if the other person wants to kiss you."
"But I wanted to."
"We know," Kiara said gently. "And JJ knows now."
Angel picked nervously at one of her bracelets. "But he didn't know me."
"Exactly." Kiara nodded. "You'd been watching him for years. You already knew who he was. But when JJ met you, he didn't know anything about you."
Angel's face slowly fell.
"And usually," Sarah added, "people talk about how they feel first. After they both get to know each other. Or they kiss because they're attracted to someone and they're pretty sure the other person wants it too."
Angel went still. "Oh."
It was the first time they'd seen her look genuinely embarrassed.
Her eyes dropped back toward the water, throat tight. "I did the wrong thing."
"No!" Kiara immediately said.
Angel looked back up.
"You didn't do anything wrong," Kiara assured her, reaching down to squeeze her shoulder. "You just didn't know. And he figured that."
"And JJ definitely doesn't mind," Sarah added. "Trust me."
Angel still looked uncertain.
Cleo sat up on her towel. "The guy literally described you as a gorgeous girl."
Angel's smile returned again. "He did?"
"Yeah. Remember when he went to get you clothes the day he met you?"
Sarah laughed. "He smiled when he told us you kissed him."
Angel's cheeks went pink.
"He said he'd never seen anybody so pretty."
Kiara smiled too. "And honestly? I think part of why he lets you decide when you want to kiss him is because he wants you to have the choice. He doesn't want you thinking you have to."
Angel looked down at the water again, something inside her settling at that. "Do you think he feels the same?"
The girls exchanged another look.
"About you?" Sarah asked.
Angel nodded.
"We don't know what JJ's feeling," Kiara said. "He doesn't exactly sit around talking about his emotions. But, I've never seen him act like this with a girl."
"Ever," Sarah added.
Angel listened carefully.
"He was really sad before you came along," Kiara said. "Like... really sad. He wasn't himself at all."
Angel frowned. "I knew."
"You knew?"
"He was sad when I watched him. I saw him cry."
The girls' bottom lips poked out at each other. They immediately felt terrible that they hadn't been there for him as much during that time. They just hadn't been sure how to be.
"Then yeah," Sarah said softly. "I think you made him happier. And I think he really loves having you around."
"Definitely," Kiara agreed.
Cleo nodded. "I've never seen him smile this much. And he used to smile a lot."
"And," Sarah added, "we're pretty sure he's going to kiss you first soon."
Angel's eyes went huge. "Really?"
Sarah grinned, shrugging once. "Probably."
Angel's head snapped toward the driveway as she heard JJ's bike. She practically launched herself away from the paddleboard, nearly toppling Kiara into the water. "JJ."
The girls burst out into quiet laughter.
She held onto the edge smiling, watching as JJ's bike rolled into the yard a minute later.
He hopped off, grabbed a small cardboard box from his backpack, and headed inside without even noticing the girls staring at him.
Angel waited impatiently in the water.
JJ came back outside and walked quickly down toward the dock, eyes already searching for her. "Hey, guys."
"Hey," they called back.
His entire face lit up when he saw her looking up at him, chin resting on the wood, and he smiled that stupid, immediate smile that the girls had just been talking about.
He crouched in front of her. "Hey, cutie."
Angel's smile practically split her face. "Hi."
"How was your day?"
"Long."
He laughed. "Yeah? Mine too. What'd you do?"
"Think about you."
JJ's eyebrows shot up. "That right?
Angel nodded.
He shook his head. "Me too, honestly."
She giggled and reached up both arms. He grabbed her hands and pulled.
He tried to help her up onto the dock, except she was wet and he was very sore from the week.
"Shit–"
Angel squealed as JJ stumbled backward and they landed on the dock with Angel directly on top of him, her tail flinging water all over Cleo and Sarah as they shielded herself.
For a second, the two just stared at each other while the girls all couldn't stop laughing.
Then Angel started laughing too.
JJ groaned. "Ow."
"I'm sorry!" she managed through giggles.
"You just body slammed me."
"You pulled me!"
"Yeah, and then you–"
Angel laughed harder and now JJ couldn't help but join in, as usual.
"Shit," he muttered, shifting beneath her. "I'm really sore. Sorry."
"Sore?"
"My muscles hurt."
Her laughter softened as she looked down at him.
JJ looked up at her, at that smile he'd been dreaming about seeing all day. Then the long strand of wet hair that had fallen across her face and stuck there. He reached up and gently brushed it away, his fingers lingering briefly against her warm cheek.
Her laughter disappeared completely now as she just stared down at him like he was the only thing that existed. And she noticed that he was looking at her the same way.
"Okay," Sarah whispered to Kiara, before crunching up her can, rolling off the floatie and swimming to the ladder.
Kiara nodded. "Yeah."
Cleo climbed to her feet. "Let's go."
Angel looked over her shoulder. "Where are you going?"
"Inside."
"Why?"
Kiara gave JJ a look. "It's getting a little hot out here."
JJ laughed. "Shut up, Kie."
Angel looked between them, confused, and watched as the girls grabbed their things and headed back to the house.
And suddenly, it was just the two of them.
"Well..."
She tilted her head. "Well?"
"I think we got ditched."
"Ditched? That means they left us alone?"
"Yup."
She smiled a little bigger. "I like alone with you."
JJ laughed. "Yeah, I don't mind it." He looked down at her tail. "We should probably get you dried off."
She nodded, in no rush not to be on top of him, but rolled off anyway. "Okay."
He stood to grab the same old beach towel he'd been using all week then sat beside her, crosslegged as he began rubbing the scales dry.
"I like when you do this," she said softly.
"Do what?"
"When you take care of me."
His heart squeezed at that. "Yeah? I like taking care of you."
"You do?"
"'Of course. And I kinda got to, 'cause if I don't..." He nodded toward her tail. "...you're gonna stay fish."
She giggled. "I am a fish."
"Half fish."
Finally her legs began to appear, which still blew his mind every damn time.
"That's so cool," he whispered, shaking his head as her pink scales melted into skin.
Angel laughed. "You always say that."
"'Cause it always is." He smiled, squeezing her calf.
She stretched her newly human legs out in front of her, in nothing but her new bikini top. "Done."
JJ grabbed clothes from where she'd shedded them onto the dock before she had turned earlier. He held out her tanktop and shorts. "Your new threads."
Angel took the clothes. "Threads?" She giggled. "What are threads?"
"I mean… threads are the tiny little strings woven together to make clothes. I guess that is kind of a weird way to describe them."
She shook her head. "Humans have so many words that means two things."
"Yeah," JJ agreed. "We really do."
He sat back down and looked away while she changed, as if he didn't hold her while she was completely naked every single night. Which was becoming harder and harder honestly. God, he wanted her.
She still didn't understand why he did this. And she didn't understand why she kind of liked it when she'd catch him looking at her body. Like when she'd get up from bed to grab something across the room or when she'd be sitting across from him flipping through a book with pictures and asking a million questions.
She liked the way he'd get this dazed look every single time and how his eyes flicked up to her face like he was caught doing something he wasn't supposed to.
"Okay," she said as she finished dressing.
He turned back toward her and gave her a quick up down before laughing softly.
Angel looked down at her outfit. "What?"
"You look really good."
She smiled shyly. "My threads?"
JJ grinned. "Yeah."
"Thank you." She spun around once. "I like being a girl."
"I like you being a girl too."
She walked over and plopped down beside him, shoulder pressed against his. They sat there quietly, just smiling at nothing. Every few seconds they'd glance over at one another and laugh for no reason just because of how tight their chests got every time they made eye contact.
"So..." JJ said finally.
She looked over.
"I gotta tell you somethin'."
Her smile faded into curiosity. "What?"
He fiddled nervously with his shoelace, feeling kind of silly for being so nervous. Angel was never nervous when she talked about how she felt.
"I should probably warn you... I'm really bad at talking about... feelings."
Angel waited patiently.
JJ took a breath. "I know I've only known you for..." he laughed once. "...what? A week?"
She nodded. "One week."
"Yeah." He looked out across the marsh before finally looking back at her. "But... I'm… uh… I'm honestly really falling for you."
Angel looked around. "Falling?"
JJ's mouth opened. "Uh...I mean--"
She scooted closer. "You are going to fall?" She grabbed his arm. "Be careful."
He stared at her for a second before laughing. "No–"
She looked even more confused. "Funny?"
He wiped at his eye. "I'm sorry."
"What?"
He smiled. "'Falling for someone' doesn't mean... actually falling."
"Oh."
"It means..." He searched for the right words. "It means somebody stops just being somebody you like being around. They become the person you think about all the time."
She blinked up at him and swallowed. "JJ..."
"The person you're excited to see." He smiled. "Someone that makes your day better just by existing."
Angel couldn't stop smiling now.
"And every day..." JJ admitted quietly, "...you somehow make me like you even more. Like holding you even more. How it feels to kiss you."
She stared at him.
"So..." He shrugged. "I guess I'm saying I really, really like you. And I've never liked anybody like this. It feels crazy."
Angel's eyes became glassy. "You are... falling?"
He nodded. "Yeah. And not off a dock this time."
She laughed at that and smiled so hard her cheeks hurt. "I am falling too. I have been a long time."
JJ laughed softly. "I'm glad."
"You make me happy."
"You make me happy too." He shook his head. "Like... you really made everything better for me. Thank you. I'm really happy I met you."
"Me too," she breathed. She placed a hand on his knee and slowly leaned toward him instinctively, then stopped, remembering what the girls had told her.
JJ noticed and his smile grew. He reached up and gently tucked a strand of hair behind her ear before resting his hand against her cheek and she leaned into it.
Angel didn't move, her heart beginning to beat a little faster in her chest as she realized that it might actually be finally happening.
And it did. He leaned forward, very slowly and pressed his lips to hers.
Angel's eyes fluttered closed, suddenly a little dizzy, butterflies going crazy in her stomach. It felt different than when she'd be the one to lean in, because this time he was choosing her.
He wanted to kiss her.
A warm little feeling bloomed in her chest so suddenly it almost made her laugh. And when he pulled back after a few seconds, Angel just stared at him.
"What?" he asked quietly.
"That felt different."
"It did?"
She nodded. "You kissed me."
"I did."
"I like when you kiss me."
His grin somehow got even bigger. He kissed her again and she hummed. "Good. Get used to it."
She leaned her head against his and hugged his arm. "Okay."
After a few quiet moments, JJ cleared his throat.
"So... I was wondering..."
She looked up at him.
"...If maybe… I could take you on a date? Just the two of us. Maybe to a restaurant or–"
Angel gasped. "A date?"
He nodded. "Yeah."
"Like… like in the movie last night?"
JJ smiled wide. "Yeah. Like the movie."
She practically bounced where she sat before throwing both arms around him. "Yes!"
He laughed as she nearly knocked him sideways.
She nodded rapidly. "I want a date with you."
"Alright, yeah. Let's do it. I wanna see you in a dress. Maybe the pink one?"
She giggled. "Yeah? The pink one?"
"Oh yeah." He smiled. "I think you'd look really pretty in it."
She chewed her lip for a moment. "You think I will?"
"I know you will."
Angel's face turned pink once again. She slowly crawled into his lap, wrapping her arms around his neck. "I am excited."
"So am I."
She rested her forehead against his. "When?"
He pretended to think. "Maybe tomorrow?"
She let out another little gasp. "Yes, tomorrow!"
"Alright." He slipped an arm around her waist, pulled her a little closer, and then pressed his lips back to hers.
She melted again, hands going up to cup his face, certain that she was the happiest mermaid in the entire planet. Had to be.
"It's a date."
✮ ⋆ ˚。𖦹 ⋆。°✩⋆✮ ⋆ ˚。𖦹 ⋆。°✩𖦹⋆ ˚。𖦹 ⋆。°✩
Part 7 Coming Soon
Taglist: @blues-main @outerbanksgirly @shayyaps @andrealux21 @wolfwar @obxobsessedbitch1 @maybanksbambi @holyfujjj @moonlitpogue @mmayii @bithewayellie @redhead1180 @gemmjuice @lotusinlove-blog @destinylovesobx @causeimyoung1 @podiumackles @rrosiitas @pomegranateher @uselessnewt @fenixwinchestersblog @celestemera @winterr-night @dreaming-softly-in-the-night @littlemisscobrakai @stars4birdie @kksturns @dulcorated @ifilwtmfc @lacecam @ellabou18 @lowmillions-lvr @zoeiscoolio @bailsmbnk @baylorloves @moneyflowsworld @chronically-jess














