Discover Top Posts Tagged with #pll bethany

Popular Recent

~ATTENTION PLEASE~ How has everybody forgotten about this??! This is the scene in s5 where Ali has just come back and Hanna goes and gets black streaks in her hair and then it pans off to MONA watching behind glass with some mystery girl (it looks like Ali)! & this also reminds me of the scene where mona is 'killed', the blonde coming up the stairs everything about her looks like Ali to me and then when the person enters mona's room mona turns around and clearly see's who it is (yet she never mentioned anything). This really leads me to believe that mona knows/knew who A is!!! Somebody please tweet this pic to Marlene? I want this explained!😱 @bestplltheories @pllmysteries @pllsphere @plltherapysessions @plllogic @alisonredcoat @a-isfor-answers @a-teamofficial @wrenischarles @whothefckischarles @wrxnkingston @prettylittlesecrethints @prettylittlethe0ry @prettylittlesessions

So mAny lies

Let’s start with pretty much everything Charlotte said when she revealed herself as Charles (aka A?). First of all, she claimed she was transgender and born as Charles DiLaurentis. And then just happened to name herself CeCe Drake during her transformation. CeCe Drake. There’s no way I’m gonna believe she has the same last name as Mary Drake out of coincidence. Sure, Jessica and Mary being twins must mean that Drake was also Jessica’s maiden name. But CeCe was born when Jessica already was married (as she’s about the same age as Jason) so I bet she just was born with her mother Mary’s last name.. which happens to be Drake.

Now her not telling the truth about that to me basically means she probably made her whole story up. This includes this:

the relevant part begins at 01:58

It was always strange to me how CeCe talked about her mother and some really good lies.. making up a story and showing how good of a liar she really is. Right before Bethany pushes Marion off that roof and blames it on CeCe (which she does in a pretty convincing way imho. Just look at how shocked she is). And for what reason? To keep her from finding out the truth about CeCe? Is that a legit reason for Bethany to KILL Marion? I think what really happened is that CeCe took the real story.. her being on that roof with Bethany, making some crazy plans and Marion finding out these very plans - resulting in Cece pushing her off the roof.. and just twisted it. Twisted it in a way that left some pieces of the truth but made Bethany look guilty and crazy.

Talking about it..

Watch next on from 0:50 on:

So Bethany doesn’t know if she can trust anyone in the DiLaurentis / Drake family. And we find out Jessica was having an affair with Bethany’s father.. Well, can we be sure it was Jessica now that we know she has a twin? What if it was Mary who had an affair with Bethany’s father? And on top of that having children with him? Like Bethany and CeCe? Are we even sure Kenneth really is anybody’s father in this mess? I mean - Jason is Mr. Hasting’s son. If CeCe is really Mr. Young’s daughter - why shouldn’t this also be the case for Ali? Now before you start calling me crazy hear me out: In the halloween specials we learn that the twins fight over everything - even their dolls. To a level where one of them would be capable of stabbing the other (although for this to work she of course survived) and be sent into a mental institution. If you have a twin like that it not too unlikely she’d try to steal her sister’s man, too.. and if it’s just by being with him without him even knowing there is a twin sister and he’s not with the woman he thinks he is in some moments.

Here’s the twin story in case you forgot:

Now let’s say Mary was sent to Radley for stabbing her sister. She somehow met Mr. Young and had Bethany and CeCe with him (with Jessica pretending to be her and get pregnant with Alison somewhat in between the birth of the other two). This would mean the following things:

1) One twin being on the board of Radley meant she could be sure to have her twin under control any time she wanted. Plus somehow make it possible her children could stay with her although she was in a mental institution (this way she could keep away everything and everyone that belonged to her sister)

2) There’s an explanation how CeCe, Ali and Bethany could look that much alike to be mixed up constantly the night Ali disappeared

3) At least one of the twins has to be absolutely crazy and evil and taught at least CeCe and Ali how to lie. Plus there was some unknown place-switching between the twins going on here and unfortunately it was planned by the evil one.

You can see it here.. the evil twin was not the one to be locked away all the time. I think the innocent one somehow always ended up as the victim in the other one’s plans.

Anyway I think Bethany was the most pure-hearted out of the three blonde girls. The reason I think that is first of all the story Charlotte told (in the video above). You can clearly see how Bethany messes up her try in making up a good story. Plus, I think she was shocked about what happened to Marion.. and how Jessica/Mary covered it up and LIED about everything.

That’s what her paintings were all about.

Now Mary (let’s just say she’s the evil one so it stays a little less complex) did not like that about Bethany.. and wanted to get rid of her. Her original plan was to switch places whenever she wanted and have all three girls as her daughters (like the dolls she wanted from her sister as a child). But Bethany didn’t want to play her way. Therefore she started a huge scheme: Ali was supposed to fake her death, which she thought of as an awesome idea because..

yup, she planned it..

But there’s more. The reason Ali was supposed to do this was that Bethany could be found dead and mistaken for Alison (as all three girls looked a lot alike). It was no coincidence all three of them were wearing the same yellow top that night.

Don’t believe it? Look at that:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QK9waGOCQso (sorry, I couldn’ add more videos to this post) Jessica said the yellow top was waaay to revealing. (Plus, a sweet side note of Ali being able to hold her breath forever.. e.g. like in could be buried for some time before being pulled out again).. then all of the sudden she finds that yellow top on her bed with a note saying “great colour for you - Mom”. Sudden change of mind? Coincidence? I don’t buy it. One more interesting thing to watch: Jessica trying to keep Ali away from Charlotte because the friendship was “toxic” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S8LOLWD9f1M As Bethany said in the second recording she also was able to make plans though. I think it’s totally possible she somehow managed to turn the odds in her favour.. and be the one that’s pulled out of her grave in the end, leaving Ali behind (and looking like her a lot.. be aware we still have not seen her face, there’s gotta be some reason behind that!). This explains Ali’s extreme change.. it’s not really Ali. And it also gives us Mary’s motive.. First Ali is dead and it’s Bethany’s fault, now CeCe’s also gone. Now why would Bethany welcome Charlotte to her home like she did and love her as a sister like she did? The reason is she thinks Charlotte really changed and went through a lot.. plus after all she really was her sister. Exactly that’s also why Uber A thinks Bethany (a.k.a. the Ali we know right now) killed Charlotte. (Plus in this case it is possible that this is the real killer and motive here). Some more evidence:

One of the Mrs. D’s for some reason giving clothes to CeCe:

Aaand maybe Melissa buried Bethany (or Ali?) less accidently than she claims.. remember there was a little something found right at the stables one of the Mrs. D.’s used to take Bethany to?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5SjWqHyTtk

Sorry for the long post, hope you liked it ♥

Mrs. D, Ali and Sara Harvey

Imagine if Sara Harvey is Ali’s sister. Mrs. D was pregnant and lost her baby, she didn’t tell Ken and got Ali as a replacement from a family who couldn’t keep the babies or didn’t want to. She could have been “out of town” for a while, so that Ken wouldn’t know. Maybe Sara knows and wants revenge on Ali and Mrs. D for leaving her with a family she hated. Maybe she got into the Foster system and then got adopted by the Harveys. Throw Bethany in as a third sister and it is even more fun. I’m not saying the show is going there, but I think it could give some sense to the senseless Sara Harvey character.

#pll #pll sara #pll harvey #pll ali #pll bethany #pll mrs d #pll dilaurentis #pll thoughts #pll stories

So Bethany and Ali were mixed up that night..

.. but did you ever realize that doesn't even really matter? If CeCe had hit Bethany as she'd planned and Mona hit the actual Ali the only thing that would've been different would be.. practically nothing. Except Mrs. D wouldn't cover for Mona maybe. But without Mrs. D seeing it by coincidence .. the story would've been the exact same.

#pll #pll finale #pll Bethany #pll rant #pll ali #pretty little liars

3x01 Bethany’s Body Is Dug Up (Wilden Clue)

Interesting conversation between Veronica and Ashley. Veronica mentions that just before the body was dug up a ruling was about to come down to have to body exhumed. Information only lawyers, police, city officials maybe and medical examiners would have. The body as we know was dug up before this could happen.

Wo could have known in advance? Garret was in jail, he may have overheard the plans, but he was being set up by someone. Veronica knew and i am guessing the head detective on the case knew...Wilden. True he could have passed this information onto someone but this again ties him to something vital in the plot. A could had reasons for not having the body identified (and subsequently changing dental records etc, “playing with body parts”

#pll wilden is charles #pll wilden is a #pll wilden #pll bethany

Sara and Bethany

Many say that Sara isn’t Sara Harvey but Bethany young. Now, I don’t trust Sara either but, if she got home to her mother, wouldn’t her mother notice she’s someone else? The only way to get away with Sara being Bethany is that they’re identical twins (the parents might have changed Bethany’s surname for privacy or anything). That would work for the police identification too I guess, since it must be based on DNA (?).

Sara’s friends said she was horrible (just like Ali) and maybe she was horrible to her sister too, so that she ended up in Radley. The person to whom Bethany is referring in the tapes might be her.

We know Bethany’s father had an affair with Mrs.D, and we know Sara’s famly lives in a town near Rosewood, which could work.

Maybe Sara is the one who got killed that night and people who saw her the next day did in fact see Bethany. Maybe she wasn’t held hostage, but she’s A herself, and she’s just been hiding for all this time, planning for the girls’ escape hence dressing etc. as if she was a hostage.

I’m not saying that’s how it is, but I think it’s the only way it can work if the Sara being Bethany thing is real. Personally, I think that’s indeed Sara Harvey, and there’s a possibility she’s working with A.

#pll #pll Sara #pll Sara Harvey #pll Bethany #pll Theory #pll theories #pll hints #pll clues #pll thoughts #pll dollhouse #pll Radley

Dre Davis as Bethany?

Press releases stated she was to be playing a character called Kimberly Brown, so why is she wearing the famous yellow top covered in dirt.

Hmn.....I smell a ploy.

#pll kimberly brown #pll bethany #pll the yellow top #pll dre davis

Wren, Aria and Bethany related

Many people are saying that Wren and Bethany might be brother and sister, and I think that could make sense. What could also make sense to me is that Wren is related to Aria.

Byron mentioned his brother suffered from a mental illness and shortly after we got to know that Wren's father suffered from a mental illness. It could obviously mean nothing, but since we're supposed to believe everything is a clue, I found it interesting.

If Wren is A as many think, this might explain why Aria is less targeted than others. When he's seen colouring the brunette in the red coat, he might be drawing Aria, not Vivian as many supposed. Aria, after all, wore the red coat.

This wouldn't necessarily rule out Bethany: she might then be related to Wren AND Aria; maybe she's also the daughter of Byron's brother. This could also explain why Lamb seemed to recognise Aria, she might resemble her cousin.

#pll wren #pll aria #pll bethany #pll who is A #pll A #pll Wren is A #pll theories #pll clues #pll thoughts #pll byron