#rescoring

[enby-axels]

i just saw your rescoring of olympic rondo, and it's funny because when i rescored it i found 48.75 in PCS😃 it really do be like that🤡

they need to abolish the PCS cap, i'm dead serious. it's selectively applied and punishes skaters with more complex, artistically demanding programs

[nameofjones]

Star Trek: Discovery is wowing me this season with some heartfelt story lines and tremendous special effects. I assembled some of the awesome visuals from the first five episodes of season 3 and added music by Martin Phipps (“The Diana Effect”).

[fs-rambling]

I rescored top 5 men at Worlds 2017!

Was this just an excuse to give H&L the score it deserved?  Maybe.

Here’s the results:

1. Yuzuru Hanyu, 331.63

2. Shoma Uno, 311.04

3. Boyang Jin, 303.98

4. Patrick Chan, 294.47

5. Javier Fernandez, 294.29

Notes: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wo5WeQ02CF00kCQ3h9YvbIGl-y6lIDqynsQ71FNHLsY/edit?usp=sharing

I love Javi, so it hurt very much to take his score down so much, but the TP was either being very nice or very negligent that day :(

But hey, I got to analyse Yuzuru’s legendary performance!  I gotta tell you, whenever I do this stuff for him, it blows my mind.  From the perspective of the audience, he’s incredible, but from a scoring perspective he’s mind-blowing.  He hits so many bullets with every element it’s amazing.  And especially today now that Patrick and Javi have both retired, his program components are so spectacular that he stands out like a giraffe in a field of cows.  Weird simile but you get the point.  

Anyway, this was fun.  Feel free to ask if you’ve got questions!

[enby-axels]

0 -> 0 GOE to 4Lz (very good height and very good length, steps before the jump/unexpected or creative entry -2 deduction for weak landing)

important note: ive heard there's some debate on whether or not the 4Lz is q/<, but, based on my footage, it's landed between the 45° and 60° mark, so it's cleanly rotated

+2 -> 1.6 GOE to 3A (very good height and very good length, steps before the jump/unexpected or creative entry, element matches the music, -1 deduction for weak landing)

+2 -> 0.52 to CSSp3 (good speed and/or acceleration during spin, effortless throughout, element matches the music, -1 deduction for traveling)

important note: the sit spin lost a level because the first position after the change of foot lacked revolutions in a valid position with the upper leg at least parallel to the ice

FCSp3 0 -> 0 to FCSp3 GOE (element matches the music, -1 deduction for slow or reduction of speed)

important note: the camel spin lost a level because the knee was not above the hip during the last spin position

0 -> 0 to 4F+3T GOE (very good height and very good length, eement matches the music, -1 deduction for weak landing, -1 deduction for long preparation)

+3 -> 1.17 to StSq4 (deep edges, clean steps and turns, element matches the music, good acceleration and deceleration)

+3 -> 1.05 to CCoSp4 (good speed and/or acceleration during spin, effortless throughout, element matches the music)

for a total GOE of 4.34 and a TES of 53.36

this basically just confirmed my suspicion that jason should be leading after the short program

if anyone has an informed reason to disagree (especially on the spin levels, because i admittedly had to consult the technical panel handbook several times to rescore those), please tell me lol.

[enby-axels]

rika's quad sal landing

from what i understand, there's some discourse on just how clean rika's 4S at nationals was... so let's look at the video!

(sorry for the blurs, this is as clear as i can get it, but for some reason it also ate up the quality 😔)

this is a still of where she lands. close to the quarter mark.

it's just shy enough of 90° that it doesnt deserve a q. it definitely doent deserve a <

personally, if i were on the technical panel, i'd call it rotated since it's somewhere between 85° and 90° (benefit of the doubt and all), and if i were on the judging panel, i'd deduct -1 in GOE for lacking rotation

(side note: this is partially why the q rule is so annoying. it requires an extremely precise measurement of where skaters land, and the sport as it is right now just doesnt have the technology to do such a thing, so it all falls on the technical panel's often questionable, inconsistent judgement)

of course, this is just the conclusion i arrived at with my own resources. if anyone has higher quality footage that contradicts this, i defer to them

[fs-rambling]

I rescored the rest of the men’s top 10 at Worlds 2019

A while ago, I decided to rescore (and subsequently rerank) the top 5 men at Worlds.  Now, as requested by @scifikimmi , I’ve done the rest of the top 10 (sorry it took so long!).  I also made a few small adjustments to the scores I gave previously.

Results:

1. Yuzuru Hanyu, 306.17

2. Nathan Chen, 291.88

3. Shoma Uno, 278.93

4. Mikhail Kolyada, 257.24

5. Matteo Rizzo, 255.54

6. Jason Brown, 253.96

7. Boyang Jin, 253.84

8. Vincent Zhou, 249.04

12. Michal Brezina, 239.71

16. Andrei Lazukin, 234.55

As always, here are my notes: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1miBuwqj4PhtPdQFntBl4-aACaB_mnHpeg9EKT0t0yBM/edit?usp=sharing - let me know if you think I made a mistake anywhere.

Tell me what I should do next!

[enby-axels]

Hello! I'm sorry to bring back these memories but I'm a new Fanyu and I trust you with scoring. Feel free not to answer, but I wanted to ask, how do you feel about the scoring of GPF 2019 Origin? I feel conflicted cause I think his PCS was quite high, but I also think it doesn't make sense how Nathan outscored him on every single component (even though it wasn't Yuzu's best in terms of PC I think Nathan was way too overscored). In terms of GOE I don't know. I think J3 was particularly harsh though, but tbf they were like that with everyone

imo his PCS were understandable, maybe even slightly generous. the program content was watered down and yuzuru himself didnt have his usual level of energy and precision. he still deserved higher PCS than NC though; mid 9s in any component, let alone all of them, are undeserved for NC.

and yes, judge 3 was very harsh, especially for the 4Lo and 4Lz; i would've given yuzu +5 and +4 respectively, not +2 and +1. but overall, i think his GOE totals were pretty accurate, if not a point or two too low. again, that was an atypically low energy skate from yuzu; for his jumps, it showed in his landings especially.

[dewimulyasarii-blog]

Rescoring for The Adventures of Tintin opening