I must admit I have a hard time differentiating pessimism from realism, but some of these opinions on The Healer and A colt is my passport seems soo negative to me.
The whole context of these films are not the best, but at least we can expect great acting from Ewan, and maybe these films won't be bad at all, they could be at least okay? It's not like Ewan has never been in a bad movie before (I really dislike High Life, for example).
No actor has been in only absolute masterpieces, and I'm glad Ewan is experiencing different things and hopefully these roles will open doors for him.
I totally get what you're saying and I think there's a useful distinction buried in here between pessimism and realism.
Taking High Life as your example. To me that film was an actual piece of shit, bless it. I didn't even make it to the end, gave it about five more minutes after Ettore died and switched off, no shame. I don't think anyone's holding the standard that every single thing he touches has to be a masterpiece. I thought Grantchester was pretty crap too, if we're honest, and life went on, the sun still rose.
I don't think anyone here believes he's actually going to be shit in The Healer or Colt. The concern isn't his acting, it's the projects themselves sounding a bit shaky on the little we know and that's a completely fair thing to say out loud. We're allowed to look at a premise or a director's track record and go "hmm, not sure that's my cup of tea" or "that could go wrong for this reason." That's not being neggy for no reason, that's just having a working brain. We're a fan blog, not a PR department.
And I also don't want to be a stan sat in a vacuum where we just blindly love everything he does. The whole point of this space is to discuss things properly, break them down, and disagree with each other sometimes. Not mean. There's a real difference between the two and I think it's worth something.
To me the fairest position is the one you're basically already living by: it isn't out yet. Watch it, then decide. Maybe it comes out and we all eat our words with a nice bit of humble pie. Maybe it doesn't and we say so, kindly. Both outcomes are completely fine, and neither makes us bad fans.
I think the reason the balance has felt a bit off this week is just timing. We've caught a wind of talking about these two projects loads in a short space of time, purely because there's nothing to actually watch yet, so there's nothing warm and lovely to weigh it against. I've been trying to slot in lots of silly, daft stuff between the more serious posts to balance it out, hopefully that's helping a bit? Right now we're just speculating on a synopsis and distribution rumours as that's genuinely all we've got to go on. Once there's real footage, a trailer, actual reviews, something to properly sink our teeth into, I think the tone rights itself. Give it time. It'll balance out, and so will we. 💚