the polo shirt incident₊˚⊹ ᰔ
using these pics of finn as a reference for college!mike, see the vision ⊹₊⟡⋆
ʚ:content: college au, established relationship, smut, fingering, first times, clumsy!mike, mdni
the mattress creaked when mike shifted, his long legs tangling with yours under the sheets. the room was quiet, just the sound of his heavy breathing and the faint hum of traffic outside his campus apartment. he was hovering over you, his dark hair falling forward into his eyes, looking down with an intense, slightly panicked expression he got whenever he was overthinking.
he was wearing that navy polo shirt you’d been staring at all afternoon, but the buttons were undone, showing the flushed, nervous pink of his chest. his big hands were resting on your hips, his thumbs pressing into your skin.
"my hands are freezing," he muttered, his voice cracking a little. "are you sure?"
you rolled your eyes, a little grumpy from how long he was taking. "mike. just do it."
"okay. okay, hold on," he whispered.
he slid his hand down, past the waistband of your underwear. you shivered when his fingertips first brushed against your inner thigh. they were cold, but the heat between your legs was already building. mike swallowed hard, his jaw tight as his fingers moved higher, finally pressing against your center. you were already slick, the front of his boxers rubbing against your thigh as he leaned closer.
he parted you slowly with his thumb, his gaze locked on your face to check your reaction. when he slid his middle finger inside you, you let out a sharp gasp, your fingers instantly digging into the fabric of his shirt.
"did that hurt?" he asked quickly, freezing completely. "was that too much?"
"no," you breathed, pulling his shirt to tug him back down. "no, it’s fine. just don't stop."
he let out a shaky breath against your neck, his body relaxing just a fraction as he pushed his finger a little deeper. the tight, wet heat of you swallowed his finger completely. he started to move, slowly at first, curling his finger inside you to find the right angle. he wasn't perfectly smooth at it, his knuckle rubbed against you awkwardly for a second and he mumbled a quick apology into your skin, but he was paying attention to every twitch of your hips.
he added a second finger, stretching you open a little more. you let out a choked sound, arching your back off the mattress as his thumb started rubbing circles against your clit. mike’s breathing hitched. he got a steady hyperfocused rhythm down, his fingers sliding in and out of you quickly, slick with your wetness. the wet sound of it in the quiet room made your face burn, but mike was completely locked in now, his long body heavy against yours, his chest dragging against your nipples through your shirt.
"you're so wet," he whispered into your ear, his voice scratchy and rough. "do you like that? right there?"
you couldn't even answer, just nodding against his shoulder as his fingers pushed deep and hit the exact spot that made your toes curl. his pace picked up, his hand getting clumsy but excited, wet between your thighs until you suddenly tightened around him, a hard wave of heat rolling through your stomach. you buried your face in his neck, muffled cries hitting his skin as you came, your walls squeezing his fingers tightly.
mike let out a low, breathless grunt, keeping his fingers inside you for a few more shallow strokes until your breathing slowed down.
when he finally slid his hand out, he was panting, his face bright red and dripping with sweat. he stayed hovering over you for a second, looking down at his fingers, slick and glistening with your wetness. his eyes were completely focused as he slowly brought his hand up to his mouth. he wrapped his lips around his fingers, sucking them clean with a slow intensity, his tongue tasting you while his gaze stayed locked onto yours. he swallowed hard, his throat moving as he pulled his fingers out with a soft click of his tongue.
he collapsed right next to you, rolling onto his back and dragging his arm over his eyes, his chest heaving under his shirt. the front of his boxers was visibly soaked.
you turned your head on the pillow, still trembling a little, looking at him grumpily. "you're a mess, wheeler."
mike let out a breathless, exhausted laugh, keeping his eyes covered but reaching out with his clean hand to blindly find yours, squeezing your fingers tight. "shut up," he mumbled, his mouth curling into a tired, proud smile. "you told me to do it."












