Teapot once again offering up balanced and fair commentary on the Xoyondo board, something of a rarity we know.
While we have already addressed the impact of Shadowlands on roleplay, it seems uniquely damaging to the PCU for some strange reason where it has not harmed others. Perhaps it is their culture of intense jingoism which no longer has a place within the current lore or the issue that the focus is on another plane/world, though this did not stop the Rotgarde back in Warlords of Draenor.
Teapot correctly picks up on the absence of Perroy as a driving factor. As Perroy directly controls over half of the PCU guilds, his delegated officers are likely now operating without oversight or direction which inevitably will lead to some confusion as to what should be done. Teapot speculates that Perroy may still be around, in a diminished capacity however. We reason that that would be even worse than an absence as what could be more demoralising for players than seeing their once active and “charismatic” leader reduced to a passive and apathetic shadow?
The next point on rapid expansion has been picked up on by us here at CoAD before a few times. The PCU’s obsession with filling niches has stretched them beyond breaking point now. This can be clearly seen by the decaying of Defias and Far Delvers this year alone. Teapot correctly states that the combination of overreach and lower numbers has likely caused tensions within other PCU guilds, such as the Ebon Onslaught. Recall Arindha was forcibly removed and their members are not satisfied with their membership inside the PCU now.
Expansionism has its limits and we are starting to see the elastic band spring back with surprising results.
Teapot goes on to make a very valid and interesting statement on the nature of the official forums. They have indeed become something of an issue there due to their many [PCU] threads clogging it up like some sort of attention starved e-celebrity. Combined with their “us vs them” mentality, something we here at CoAD only adopted purely because they would not engage meaningfully with us, it has driven a wedge in the community that will not soon be redressed simply on the grounds the PCU higher ups believe they are completely in the right 100% of the time and have nothing to atone or even apologise for to the many players they have infringed upon over the years.
Teapot goes onto offer more insight, the militaristic type guilds of the PCU are likely why the interest has fallen due to the irrelevance of such a guild in a post-BFA world.
Referring to the tactics done in the cesspit of PCU controlled AD discord, this is genuinely what happens, unsuspecting players are pulled in and directed to only PCU guilds, despite the claims it represents all of Argent Dawn.
Finally, we agree there needs to be more done to counteract the PCU presence, more guilds that are similar but not affiliated with them. While Teapot gives a moderate position on #NoPCU, we maintain that a firm division between PCU and Non-PCU guilds is necessary to prevent the former from infiltrating and sabotaging their competition as they have been shown to do very recently. Perroy and his higher ups do not see RP as anything more than a means to increase their own ego at the expense of others. “Winning” is all they care about in the end.
Non-PCU hubs such as the RP Announce channel ( https://www.argentarchives.org/node/113584 ) link to the server in here, and the Dalaran community would indeed be excellent counterbalances to the suffocating presence of the PCU.