A Grungler On Crossdressing
I think a lot about crossdressing, for a guy who doesn’t do it or go looking for it or interact with it at all.
Let me clarify: Kind of. Not really. I don’t think about it very often, it’s not a thought that occupies me a lot of the time, but it is a thought that when I do try and think about it involves thinking an awful lot, in a way that necessarily involves constructing not just ‘what I think’ but multiple related models about what it even means to do this thing we call ‘crossdressing.’ At a certain point the models break down.
If you’re not here to hear a cis guy talking about crossdressing as a practice with which he has nothing to do, then you might wanna go elsewhere today!
First of all, crossdressing is a term with a simple-sounding definition that I feel opens up a lot of weird doors. Crossdressing, ostensibly, is wearing the clothes of the opposite gender’s. Except, and this is the annoying thing, this doesn’t really mean anything, because there are no opposite genders. Also, people don’t really care about women wearing pants (unless they’re real freaks that I’m related to). As with many of these ‘queer’ discussions, what people really mean is ‘men doing something that isn’t men-appropriate.’
You can find this if you ask people about gay rights, inevitably you find the conversation gravitates towards gay men and then somehow, no matter what you start the topic onto, they want to bring up buttsex and poo and cocks. Now there’s a whole conversation around how that’s fundamentally because homophobia (and antiqueerness in general) is built around disgust responses and that’s why they try to bring up gross stuff.
When I talk about ‘crossdressing,’ bringing up like, Janelle Monae in a suit isn’t in the conversation. Nor should it be, really, because Janelle Monae isn’t a woman in a men’s suit, it’s a nonbinary person in their own suit, but the people who are mad about crossdressing include people who would absolutely see that as ‘probably fine’ because they’re parsing it as a woman wearing a men’s suit in a way that still nonetheless makes them look really hot.
Point is, step one: Crossdressing is, in one space, an impossible action and instead is just about patrolling the ways men shouldn’t dress.
Let’s assume, though, that crossdressing exists. Let’s assume then that it’s about some kind of simplified gender binary thingy that’s kinda silly, it’s a thing people can do when they wear the ‘wrong’ gender of clothes, or clothes that are ‘wrong’ for their gender. I’ll isolate it down to a specific example: Men wearing women’s clothing, and this is bad. From there I’ll discard the people who are mad about it for the obvious transmisogyny angle.
Instead, what about the trans people who don’t like crossdressing.
Now, for this in this context, I want to make it clear, I am neutral on what the opinions of these people should be and I do not think that anyone should have a particular opinion on this cultural practice. There are these two positions:
Men crossdressing is generally, bad or tasteless, because it enables transmisogynist people who are willing to play with gender enough to dress out of type, but are not actually engaged with the experience of being that gender.
Men crossdressing is generally, good or okay, because it enables people who might want to play with gender a place to do so that does not necessarily require deeper commitment and therefore, present those ideas to people, even those who are not necessarily the crossdresser.
This to me feels as much like an argument about drag specifically, and about drag culture in the specific, high-prominence American Excess. It feels like RuPaul. It feels like a conversation that isn’t about crossdressing, it’s a conversation around specifically some high-profile crossdressers who are probably also transphobes. It isn’t how it was phrased to me, though and I don’t want to speak over the conversation.
It is a challenging conversation to grapple with because I don’t want to act like it’s something anyone should have to put up with. I think that every community slice has bad actors in it, and I think that every single form that can take is going to feature shitheads that suck. I tend to think that any given practice that does enable those people should be addressed in a way that the community can, like, you know, by not tolerating them and kicking them out, and refusing to give them platforms and voice. I don’t think that means the practice of crossdressing is ‘bad’ in any way.
I do understand though that I’m not part of that conversation. I just don’t find myself compelled by the idea that guys wearing skirts creates some kind of greater structural problem that wasn’t already there, and would be there, even if the guy wasn’t wearing a skirt.
I kinda remember someone saying something like ‘femboy aesthetics are appropriating transfemininity’ which is just close enough to a joke silly opinion that I’m not sure it isn’t one. Like, if a guy wants to try transfeminine aesthetics, isn’t that a good thing? Shouldn’t transfeminine aesthetics be more present and more available and more seen as good and desireable things for people to engage with?
And the thing is, in with all this: I have no interest in it! Crossdressing isn’t something I’ve ever found interesting to do at all! I’ve worn a skirt a few times in the vein of ‘well, it’s what’s in this house and I can wear it,’ but I haven’t been left with any feeling of the experience afterwards like I’m delighted that Dress Goes Spinny. It’s just clothes, and I find people who get really mad about what other people are wearing tend to be silly. It’s one of the reasons I find hijab bans or the like a serious sign of someone being untrustworthy, because it’s so unserious to be a person mad about a hat. I know that hat is very significant to the person who wears it, but if I’m not invested in those reasons, it’s just a hat to me, and being mad about someone’s hat seems deeply unserious.
Honestly, this whole line of conversation, with my own complete antipathy towards the promise or threat of gender exploration is one of the reasons I’m nervous about watching I Saw The TV Glow. What if I watch it and I think it’s just fine and don’t have a full-blown gender crisis about it?
Check it out on PRESS.exe to see it with images and links!
















