Sorry if you already talked about it somewhere and I couldn't find it, but what are your favorite and least favorite Martian Martian designs? Like, not human disguise, not human just green, but full on alien guy (gender neutral)? What, to you, makes or breaks such design?
Oooh so I guess this means Martian True Forms! To the uninitiated; Martians usually transform into a humansona, an in-between Social Form that is part alien and part human (human but green, the form we mostly see J'onn in), and a True Form- which is their freak alien mode. Usually comic artists sleep on Martian designs from tight deadlines, but some of these stand out!
J'onn's stretchy lanky design by Mark Badger from Martian Manhunter 1988! I think his style lends to an abstract quality that makes this design so delightful. Even if the spikes on J'onn's back feel very "tacked on to a human form". There's something charming about this one.
Just the entirety of Riley Rossmo's Martian designs for Martian Manhunter 2018-19! Rossmo is a fantastic creature designer and he clearly let loose when it came to the martian designs. I don't love how some of these designs are overly gendered (M'yri'ah looking way too much like a Pixar Mom) and I'm neither here or there with the baby blob martians- but I overall really like the sheer amount of effort Rossmo put into these Martians. Yes I even like the freak sex Martian union. In this version, J'onn's True Form is more like a tiny skinny green alien man and while I don't agree with that direction, it's still a bold choice I can respect for wanting to change it up. I personally prefer the True Forms being monstrous and huge.
Young Justice Animated Martian designs! I like how monstrous their True Forms look- in that they're so far removed from human anatomy. My pet peeve with this design is the eternal gritting teeth face they have making these Martians very unexpressive characters. There's also a boring samey-ness to these designs where you can't help but feel like once you see one True Martian Form, you feel like you've seen them all. I imagine making entirely unique designs for each Martian would be taxing for the limited series budget. Still! It betrays this notion that they're a shapeshifter species that can look like anything they want. But we know how messy the racial allegory is on this show.
Man of Tomorrow Martian True Form!! I looove how freak J'onn's True Form is in this movie. Just horrifying. He levitates menacingly, he jumps around like a freak deer, it's great. This might be my favorite in terms of just how out there it is as a design. And it looks great in animation.
and lastly DCAU Martian True Forms <3 I know these are technically pretty close to human anatomy, but there's something so loveable and expressive about this design. I like the big head crest and the lack of nose. When I think about it, the ultimate struggle for making an out-there Martian design is the balance between unrecognizable and expressive. This DCAU design hits that sweet spot. Absolute Martian also hits that spot, but uh- since he's not technically a Martian I won't count him here.
I don't think I have a true least favorite since they all fulfill something different from what I'd like to see. But maybe the YJa ones just bore me the fastest. Favorite overall goes to Rossmo's designs.