Book Review - All the Bright Places by Jennifer Niven
Release Date - Jan 6th 2015
Genre - Young Adult Fiction
Publisher - Knopf Publishing Group
Theodore Finch is fascinated by death, and he constantly thinks of ways he might kill himself. But each time, something good, no matter how small, stops him.
Violet Markey lives for the future, counting the days until graduation, when she can escape her Indiana town and her aching grief in the wake of her sister’s recent death.
When Finch and Violet meet on the ledge of the bell tower at school, it’s unclear who saves whom. And when they pair up on a project to discover the “natural wonders” of their state, both Finch and Violet make more important discoveries: It’s only with Violet that Finch can be himself—a weird, funny, live-out-loud guy who’s not such a freak after all. And it’s only with Finch that Violet can forget to count away the days and start living them. But as Violet’s world grows, Finch’s begins to shrink.
Okay. I can write this review without thinking about the trauma this book put me through. Okay.
When it said on the back of the book ‘for fans of The Fault in Our Stars’, I never expected this level of trauma. You thought Augustus Waters was bad? You still can’t get over that? Think again. If you were even in the slightest touched by the death of Augustus Waters, this book will send you on a downward spiral that will end with intensive therapy.
When I picked up this book, for the first few chapters, it really wasn’t living up to the hype from what I could see. Violet’s character seemed stereotypical - the popular girl that’s been through some kind of trauma and has decided to get over it by not getting over it. Your basic YA female character, rejecting the world and everything. Theodore Finch’s character was also reminiscent of something. He was basically Augustus Waters without half the virtues of the actual Augustus Waters. So for the people preparing to read this book, you will either look at Finch’s character and roll your eyes or you will fall madly in love with him instantly because of the entire ‘I play guitar I’m a bad boy’ thing he has happening, which is mildly attractive.
These characters somehow end up in the same position; at the top of the Bell Tower, talking each other off it in their own way. When they are grouped together (to Finch’s insistence) on an assignment for U.S. Geography, the entire readership managed to predict what was going to happen and here comes the love story, which while well-written, was pretty much expected.
A little more into the book, we see the two taking a trip to a never-ending body of water, where Finch dives in a little too deep and gives Violet the scare of her life. At this point, anyone who knows the meaning of the word ‘foreshadowing’ is going ‘uh-oh’. It was at this point when the words on the page began to burn into my corneas and I became glued to the book.
Another suicide attempt later, the reader already has a pretty good idea of where the story is headed for Theodore Finch. But, because we are stupid young things in love with this boy now, we dare to hope for the best. Then the thing happens. The thing that will fucking tear your heart out and had me waking up at 6AM and questioning the meaning of life. I’ll tell you this - I never cry at books. Except for Fault in Our Stars. And now this. This book was even worse, because it left me with this empty feeling in my stomach like there was a hole there.
You wanna know what we saw in Augustus Waters? He didn’t die voluntarily. Augustus Waters had no choice and it was tragic and it was horrible and we couldn’t stop it and I still can’t forgive John Green, but I understood. Here, the theme of suicide is actually dealt with in a much more hands-on graphic way than I have ever seen it dealt with before, and it’s even more painful to the reader because we feel as if the character had a choice!
While this book is extremely valuable and close to my heart as it has changed the way I see things entirely (and because of some personal issues), to me it sends the wrong message. Niven aims to help people feeling suicidal, show that there is hope, and having one of her main characters commit suicide and describing it so graphically isn’t exactly blazing with a hopeful message. But this book definitely has shock value and it will raise awareness. Even if it does make you completely depressed and absolutely HURT YOU LIKE NO WORDS EVER HAVE BEFORE, I applaud any literature that can make me howl with tears.
Congratulations, Jennifer Niven. Now all you guys, if you have a strong stomach and are 100% sane and equipped to handle this book, go pick it up!