YALL I HAVE IT I HAVE A THEORY THATS ACTUALLY PLAUSIBLE REGARDING DELTARUNE
theyre gonna try to silence me. the post is gonna get buried. i dont even know if this theory is unique, but its a showerthought so it came to me organically, but i present my theory:
kris has never been in control. at least, not fully.
lets start by establishing a timeline, starting with when kris is born and ending with when deltarune starts. when we enter the game, we see the scene of kris's room. namely: the existance of the birdcage. so the question presents: why would kris need the cage if this is the first time weve "possessed" kris?
the answer, most likely, is that kris has done the song and dance before. theyve needed to remove their soul before and keep it trapped. theyre used to needing to feel free from their soul.
and why is that?
this is where we need to establish that there are three forms of "control" that kris can be under: their own control, our control, and the control of... someone else.
lets look at kris's childhood. of course, we dont have control over kris here, so we'll ignore that for now. however, there are moments that kris seems to not react to despite being negative, such as kris pulling pranks on noelle as a kid. we also know there are moments that we know of that kris seems to be displeased by, even if they seem relatively positive, such as whatever moment the picture of noelle and kris represented in chapter 5.
so why is kris so opposed to the soul controlling them even if they do things that they should enjoy? well even outside of the utter loss of freedom (big theme there obvi), i think kris has done things they really didnt want to do while being controlled, possibly including whatever happened to dess.
and so, i think whoever is orchestrating this whole operation, who we'll just assume is gaster for now, offered them a deal: fulfill my plans, and ill free you of your soul (or, at least, the control it has over them).
thats why kris is helping with the dark fountains. they NEED to be free, even if it ruins their relationships or their reputation. that's why spamton hit them so hard. they both want freedom, but must be puppetted to receive it. thats why, when you choose that kris is "not ok" with what happened in the spamton fight, they scream "NO." not because they were scared (though that could be part of it), but because they realized how similar their situations are.
but again, we go back to the cage, and the question of "who was controlling kris?"
i mean... its gaster right? it has to be gaster!
gaster purposely sabotaged kris's perception of their soul so that he could manipulate them into doing what he wanted and keep us from interfering.
it would also explain why, despite being an "antagonist," kris isnt evil. they are, quite obviously, opposed to what's happening in the weird route, trying to grasp any control to get out of it and not wanting to "proceed." its also why they look away when we kill susie and ralsei in the SWORD route. they do genuinely care for susie and ralsei, and the more our control over them slips, i think we'll see that.
so there you have it! going back to the timeline, we have: kris (and their soul) are born; kris (at some point) gets controlled by gaster, gaster forces kris to watch themselves have fun and do bad things (possibly including dess's dissappearance), gaster makes a deal with kris to carry out his plans and make dark fountains in exchange for their freedom, and, finally, we gain control over kris, who is already tainted against us. though, given the weird route, maybe gaster was just preparing them for what was to come...
but hey, that's just a theory! A GAM- *shot by matpat's lawyers before i can finish the sentence*


















