I don't think Emilie, when she got herself pregnant with the Peacock Miraculous, was thinking about creating a perfect child. Some people just really want to have a biological child of their own. I mean, there are plenty of people in the real world who keep trying for a child when they have fertility issues. I think that that's more of a real world issue that every person has to grapple with on an individual basis. And adoption is not really as easy as you think it is. Sadly, health concerns that make conception harder can also make getting approval for adoption harder as well. Adoptions can run you nearly 50K with years of waiting and interviews and counselling. So, using the Peacock Miraculous to have a child was cheaper and faster than adoption. Do you know how many well intentioned parents would take this option if they could? Not adopting doesn’t make you evil. I don't think any of us are entitled to judge what anyone choose, real of fictional, child or no child.
Like, sorry to everyone reading this, but I’m gonna have to use the dreaded “slave” word for Sentipeople, because the people defending Emilie are defending the conscious choice of a rich white woman to create a slave to play house with (under the direction of the white middle class writers) while never taking said slave's remote control off.
THE PEACOCK MIRACULOUS IS ONLY CAPABLE OF CREATING SLAVE CHILDREN. This is a function hardwired into the Miraculous. It can only create children that are tied to the Peacock Miraculous, meaning they can be killed in an instant, and the Amok, meaning they can be controlled with a THOUGHT. “Well-intentioned” parent doesn’t BELONG in the same BALLPARK as USING THE FUCKING PEACOCK MIRACULOUS. And that’s BEFORE you take into account the fact that EMILIE NEVER TOOK THE RING OFF.
Also, Emilie and Gabriel are insanely rich. I’m gonna go out on a limb and say that money and RICH WHITE PEOPLE wait time isn’t going to be an issue. Never mind how this is the show where André is able to adopt Zoé by basically just going: “I fucked up my first child, I want to start over with this new, better-behaved one” and everyone was cool with it.
Frankly, because none of these characters are real human beings, I find the choice for them to decide to go with slave children over all other options FASCINATING. What might have gone on in the writers’ room when they were deciding that. I also find people defending Emilie’s decision to go with a slave child fascinating. What do you think about conservatorships? Or Elon Musk using sex-selective IVF and then abandoning his daughter when she came out as trans?