the cp9 might be terrible at their jobs: a meta
so, water 7 + enies lobby is probably my favorite one piece arcs of all time: it introduces my favorite character, has that good character development, amazing villains, beautiful scenery. so ive frequently revisited it. and it always shocks me how much the cp9 don’t know. like, they don’t know jack shit. and i wanna talk about it.
so, let’s review shall we? so, cp9 had four undercover agents: two as shipwrights (lucci and kaku), one w iceburg as his secretary (kalifa) and one in the town (blueno). they were sent to find the blueprints of the secret weapon, and were undercover for five years. this means that they started their work about 3 years after tom’s arrest and franky’s “death”.
only eight years has passed since tom’s arrest. and tom was a well-known figure in water 7. he built the train that literally saved water 7 from poverty, and the people of water 7 know that. and even before then, he was known for being the guy that built the pirate king’s ship. and, on top that, he was the only (noticeable) fishman living on water 7, and given the sentiments on fishman, i doubt this went unnoticed.
and people most likely knew about his apprentices too. people probably didn’t take too much interest in them, but they had to know they existed. franky and iceburg were always with tom, and they were prominently featured in tom’s arrest, franky especially, which was a highly public event! he bashed a government official’s head in, that’s the type of thing people remember.
these guys barely knew iceburg was apprenticed to tom, and they only recently found out that franky even existed. and this baffles me because their boss was the one who got his face smashed. and spandam definitely holds a grudge over this, so he didn’t just forget about franky. spandam knew that there were two apprentices. and yet his underlings didn’t even know that for a majority of their time undercover.
and! what’s more!! cp9 had never heard the name cutty flam before going undercover. the only reason their whole thing works and they get the blueprint is because cutty flam is written on the fake blueprints and they heard the name once when franky used it when he first returned to water 7.
again, spandam knew who cutty flam was. he knew that cutty flam was apprenticed to tom, or, at the very least, somehow related. this was made very clear in franky’s backstory.
and he didn’t even think to mention that name to his underlings? cp9 knew that franky used the name cutty flam for four years, and they didn’t figure out anything until the very last second.
though, i don’t think this is necessarily a plot hole or anything. there’s a simple explanation for why this happened and why cp9 didn’t know anything-
and that’s because the government agencies are apparently really bad at communicating with each other. and spandam’s promotion to head of cp9 was more recent, so it’s possible that he didn’t deal with the agents that much. and his information was lost to the bureaucracy.
but, back to the title. this post is about how the cp9 are terrible at their jobs. im not saying they’re not strong, or that they’re not good assassins (tho i would say they’re not exactly quick and efficient), but they are terrible spies. like, their information gathering skills are the pits.
they were in water 7 for five years. they knew that franky used the name cutty flam, and then went by a different name. lucci, kaku and kalifa all remember that moment. kalifa, at the time, even noted that the man seemed suspicious and definitely saw iceburg’s visceral reaction to the name-
and they didn’t think to investigate that?? they didn’t keep tabs on iceburg and follow him to that secret meeting he had with franky? those two discussed some very incriminating stuff in a unsecured location that would have been so easy to spy on. but no.
and, they note that there are no records or anything on the apprentices. that makes sense, given that both of them were orphans or similar abandoned by their families. i doubt either of them lived in a orphanage or were ‘officially’ adopted by tom. paper-work wise, they were invisible.
but again, tom’s arrest was only eight years ago. that’s not very long. there has to be a public memory of those apprentices. again, one of them bashed an official’s head in. i wouldn’t be surprised if that was something people still talked about. at the very least, tom and his apprentices were common knowledge to the people of water 7. even tom’s trial and the details of it were public knowledge - that’s how spandam finds out about it.
cp9 lived there for 5 years. even if they didn’t specifically seek it out, surely they would have heard something. something about the fishman who built the sea train, or his violent apprentice that based someone’s head in and ran around in speedos. blueno was a bartender, for pete’s sake! people tell bartenders everything!
(and side note: someone had to make the connection between franky and cutty flam. yeah, franky changed a lot in his size and shape, but he was still a blue haired, speedo clad guy running around. and the speedo thing is definitely weird, people point it out all the time. so there can’t be that many guys like that around. someone in water 7 had to the make the connection. there had to be some sort of gossip mill running around about it).
and yet, cp9 were completely in the dark about everything! i don’t think they did any proper spy work. they just waited until robin showed up and then got lucky with that fake blueprints. like, if iceburg hadn’t used one of the tom’s workers blueprints, cp9 would have never figured out who cutty flam was and would have never gotten those blueprints.
those guys were just awful spies.