Hello everyone!!! I have a post-Holy War Lavi theory in the works speaking on Lavi’s narrative, how his destiny within the Bookman clan will end up, dissecting Past!Lavi and his legacy, and finally how the ever-persistent “gray” morality theme fits into it all. I have not seen this take before, so I apologize if this had already been explored.
This will be Part I. It will contain spoilers up to chapter 254 of D.Gray-Man.
The theory I have is as follows:
Current Lavi, as we know him now, will not be physically following in Past!Lavi’s steps— as in, he will not deviate from his Bookman lineage. But I believe Lavi will follow in the footsteps of his predecessor in spirit.
Well, why not? What does that mean ‘in spirit’? What I believe will unfold in the story will be exactly as we’re told: Lavi will become the next Bookman. My theory takes it a step further— not only will Lavi become the leader of the Bookman clan as he has been destined to, but taking his destiny (in combination with the series “gray” morality theme and Past!Lavi’s legacy) will build towards him reforming the Bookman tenets on neutrality all together.
Let me go piece by piece.
On the first note of “not deviating from his Bookman lineage”: Lavi has expressed he doesn’t see himself as anything other than a Bookman in two (2) separate Discussion Rooms. While of course this is not definitive proof, Hoshino has noted she uses these in-betweens for foreshadowing. What is interesting is that she keeps this framing of “wanting to stay a Bookman” consistent for Lavi between the first time its brought up (first image, volume 7) and the second time it’s brought up (second image, volume 26.). He even mentions how he likes his job too.
"LAVI: (when asked if they weren't exorcists what would they be?) I'd be a Bookman. I have no interest in being anything else."
"LAVI: (When asked if they had jobs in the real world what would they be) Hmm... I don't feel like being anything but a Bookman."
That’s a 10 year difference between these two extras. A lot of things have changed, but certainly not this answer from Hoshino.
If these examples are still too indirect, I then offer the most recent piece of evidence coming from chapter 253. Here, we see Past!Lavi's soul merging with Past!Allen, and he speaks on the birth of the next Bookman Jr.
Past!Lavi's role in the story exists as the Mentor / Guide archetype. We see his words act as a source of reassurance and divine guidance. The narrative asks us to trust his words, his intentions, his knowledge. And we do. Given the panel below, I find no other stronger moment to imply Lavi's destiny.
To further discuss how Lavi will, in spirit, follow in his predecessor's footsteps, we must understand the choices Past!Lavi himself made and the legacy he leaves behind. We see in chapter 252 Past!Lavi explaining to Past!Allen about his crisis of philosophy. Past!Lavi asked himself these deep, introspective questions about his purpose.
"The duty of Bookman I must inherit— the wars that refuse to be gone from this world— what meaning is there, I wonder? In religiously remaining a bystander? Recording countless tragedies, on and on."
Past!Lavi abandoned the clan to follow Nea, who had a mission so strong it was enough to rival his indoctrination and destined rise to seniority. He admonished himself for doing nothing while knowing "the truth", and sought out to become Nea's host. Unfortunately, he did not make it to Nea in time before he died. He then swore to protect Past!Allen with his life— for which he fulfilled his promise. Arguably he also prevented Lavi from “crossing over” too early when he was shot as a child (Chapter 253.5) and saved him there too.
So, all in all, his actions show he had:
The will to change (questioning the Bookman mission)
A direction to heel-turn towards (Nea)
A mission greater than himself to fulfill (protecting Nea's host, Allen.)
What I also find equally important to note are the ways Past!Lavi didn't act that influences his legacy as well. We see just how his choices have profound impact on the story, but considering his background as a Bookman we learn there is narrative weight in the choice of inaction. (I will be discussing my thoughts on these two points in future posts as I have a lot more to say)
What Past!Lavi's inaction also says about his legacy:
While Past!Lavi questioned the Bookman clan and their mission, his crisis of philosophy centered around "what meaning is there in being a bystander?" and not "why do we continue to be bystanders?" While they may seem to be the same question, they are distinct. When he realized he was a cog, he left the machine— but didn't challenge the machine's mode of operation. He, in fact, believed in the operation enough he was confident the next Junior would succeed him and become the true heir.
There is one thread in Past!Lavi's story that's currently left unresolved: his relationship with his father, Bookman. We see Past!Allen plead with him as they're dying to live because there was someone he wants to have listen to him still. At this declaration Past!Lavi sheds tears at the memory of his father. A conversation left unfulfilled, a fractured relationship.
We now see the ripples from these two points slowly leak into the narrative the more we learn about the Bookman clan. I will say, the impact of the first point remains the most speculative. I would argue his choice to question the "what" instead of the "why" of his clan's mode of operation implies it's not something he wanted to challenge in the first place. I will later be comparing it against Lavi's own moment of crisis on the ark and his crisis centers on the "why" in my part II.
As for the second point, We most recently see how this "attachment" has impacted Bookman himself. In chapter 254, Bookman knows his son's energy resides within the helix of life. In a rather undisciplined train of thought, he is reminded of his son in this moment snow falls. Their fractured relationship persists in Bookman's mind even after all these years. That does beg the question: how often is he afflicted with these thoughts? Does he, too, struggle with the very same tenets he preaches? To this, I will be speaking more to the point about the "gray" morality theme in my part III.
"No, this won't do... My thoughts keep straying to the helix first... Simply from thinking you're there, as part of it..."
[He looks at the silvery snow... and instead sees his son.]
To conclude this first part, I've attempted to summarize the importance of Past!Lavi's legacy in hopes of laying the ground work and providing context to explain my theory: why I believe Lavi will transform the Bookman clan by the end of the series. In my next post I will be speaking on Lavi's position as the current heir and provide further reasoning as to why he won't be leaving the clan like his predecessor anytime soon.
If you read this far, thank you! Please let me know what you think and if I missed anything. If you have questions please bear with me as I'm still writing and editing the other parts, it was simply too long to include in a single post!