What are questions that have yet to be answered by the trans community that if they answered you might be inclined to change your mind about gender critical theory?ďżź Iâm asking about questions that you ask and they respond with circular logic, or just avoid answering. ďżź
Why is the label âtransâ okay when it is followed by âgenderâ but not other things? Ex. trans racial.
What makes someone trans/nonbinary?
If a penis can be female, why are transwomen undergoing gender reassignment surgery to remove it?
What is a woman?
âIf a man can decide to be a transwoman because words change meaning/language evolves and genitals have nothing to do with gender, why canât a biological female identity as a transwoman?â
If sex is a spectrum then why do yâall just have AMAB/TMA and AFAB/TME lmfao
Why does âidentifying as somethingâ make you that thing?
Why is it the responsibility of womyn, the class of people with the least amount of power and wealth as well as the longest and most brutal worldwide history of oppression and slavery, to accommodate trans identified males and center them in our movement for liberation?
Why, with all of the money and strong public support (in "western" countries), do they not create their own third spaces?
Why do they not focus their ire on men, who are the perpetrators of discrimination and violence against them?
What is sexism? Why do womyn experience it?
The answers that I get to these questions are never satisfactory. They almost always end, at best, in appeals to emotion, and, at worst, threats of violence. Both of these tactics are very common and effective against womyn due to our socialization.
since they can only observe us from a biased, outside vantage point, how can someone born male know how it ~feels~ to be female?
If actual biological sex is a spectrum, what are the other gametes along with sperm and egg? Why has it taken so long for them to be observed?
Can your gender identity exist for a second without validation?
These are really good questions for peaking anyone who hasn't been sucked into gender ideology too deeply. I've used "what is a woman? What do all women share, and no men share, beyond our bodies?" and "How is this different from claiming to be a different race?" with some success.
if being trans is "being born in the wrong body," how do you know what the "right" body is? if it's not being born in the wrong body, why is someone owed medical care to change it?
imagine encountering a human society that has never interacted with our culture and has entirely opposite gender roles from us - what's the difference between a man from this culture and a trans woman from ours? if being trans depends on cultural context and external signifiers, how can someone "just know" they're trans?
why aren't straight people asked to "get over their genital preferences"? if it's wrong to ask that of anyone, why is it wrong to build personal boundaries around that?
If trans activism is truly only about getting trans people rights, safety, and respect. Why is so much of the online focus on policing words of strangers, in particular women? Why is there so much emphasis on whether one particular lesbian will date or sleep with a trans women or else she is a transphobe? Why is there emphasis on whether or not every women only space will include trans women or be deemed transphobic? Why isn't there as much focus on trans men as there is on trans women?
tbh the transgender/transracial debate peaked me
if sexual orientation is based on gender what about the hundreds of animal species with homosexual individuals we studied in the last few decades?
if sexual orientation is based on gender and pronouns don't mean gender. femininity/masculinity =/= gender. sex =/= gender then what *exactly* are we attracted to? labels?
if sex =/= gender why are female only spaces transphobic against trans women? on the same note why should we include trans men in discussions about abortion rights but we can't have female only spaces?
why are women oppressed based on gender? why aren't men the oppressed class and women the oppressors? just how and why did all this start?


























