What I enjoy about c!Tommy and c!Wilburâs relationship a lot is discussing how their characters tend to mirror each other, and itâs interesting how they depict parallels or contrasts depending upon how they're examined. At their core they seem similar, but there are certain aspects of their ideals, worldviews, and mindsets that set them apart from one another in a way which provides good material for analysis and gives them a well-rounded dynamic within the story that communicates a compelling and cohesive narrative, both individually and together.
With their ideals, c!Tommy and c!Wilburâs shared values built the foundations of Lâmanburg and a legacy which prevails even now despite its destruction, and still affects their characters and others today. The spirit of resistance in the face of an unjust authority and the willingness to stand up for what they cared about no matter the circumstances lived on in its members, and no one was more true to this than c!Tommy and c!Wilbur. Though they kept this ideology with them, they both had different approaches and applications in how they expressed and upheld them, which fall in contrast to each other in this case.
c!Tommy has always been more direct with his feelings; through his words, through his actions, he wears his heart on his sleeve and is generally an easier character to read because of this. This nature of his tends to show in how he approaches conflicts and applies his ideals. During conflicts, his first instinct is to stay and to fight, for what or for who he cares about, regardless of the odds against him. This is shown before the events of November 16th when he and c!Tubbo discuss leaving the server behind and he says he needs to stay behind for L'manburg and for c!Wilbur, and even later on during the community house confrontation when he sides with c!Tubbo and New L'manburg for the sake of his friends and c!Wilbur's legacy. He'll stay true to this trait even despite it not being in his best interests, even if it risks his well-being and his life, or jeopardizes his personal objectives. Sometimes this is his downfall when combined with his impulsiveness and his aggression, as is the case when he incites conflicts rather than solving them. Overall though, one of c!Tommy's core characteristics is his heart, and I don't think he should be faulted for it.
c!Wilbur, by comparison, has the tendency to be more subtle in his own approach, and truly does value using his words over his actions since that is where his strengths lie. He prefers to weave narratives and debate his point to an opponent or strategize and think through his approach. Though he will occasionally engage physically, it isn't usually his first plan of action. This doesn't mean he lacks the heart c!Tommy does, in fact he matches him in that respect, though he makes more of an effort to conceal that part of himself to remain stoic and keep a level head. Unfortunately, he'll fall into a pattern of avoiding an issue or a conflict, whether that be by retreating into himself, doing so in a more physical sense by bodily removing himself from the situation, occupying/involving himself elsewhere, or by using misdirection in a conversation. He does genuinely want to change or to resolve the current issue, but he has trouble directly confronting situations and people for fear or failure or rejection. He hasn't yet had this trait addressed in its entirety, and as of now he seems to be in the midst of confronting that part of himself for his conclusion.
There will be exceptions to the rule, of course. c!Tommy and c!Wilbur both subvert their usual fight or flight defaults in some instances. For c!Tommy, he foregoes his instinct to fight when he escapes exile and during almost all encounters where he's alone with c!Dream thereafter by choosing to flee, and Wilbur becomes much more physically confrontational when his emotions run high and the people he cares about are directly at stake, as he did when c!Niki was being persecuted and treated unfairly by c!Schlatt and when he confronted c!Dream after learning about the abuse c!Tommy suffered in exile.Â
c!Tommy and c!Wilbur also have similar mindsets regarding how they perceive themselves and others within the server, which fundamentally influences how their characters interact with people and react to events, as well as how their characters develop. The aspect of roles, both self-imposed and assumed by others, play a major part in their characterization and development even now. Combined with their originally black and white view of the world, which diverge from each other as c!Tommy and c!Wilbur develop separately, it leads to an interesting dichotomy between them.
For c!Tommy, this mindset is a central point of conflict in his character's development throughout the story. He has a complicated relationship with the roles assigned to him and internalized within himself. A core part of his character's development throughout his story is reconciling with others expectations and perceptions of him by either accepting or denying them in a brutal cycle he still struggles with even now. In his mind, it was black and white in that whoever was "with them" was "good" and whoever was "against them" was "bad", and the roles he assumed of himself and others reflected this. The events of November 16th forced him to consider thinking outside of the "us versus them" mindset and adapt it into something more nuanced, but this was still just the start of that shift. Moving forward into the beginning of the exile conflict and following arc, c!Tommy still holds onto those roles, but this is where it begins to change from something almost positive into something negative. c!Tommy's roles in his story were, up until this point, a combination of expectations/perceptions given to him by others as well as expectations/perceptions he gave himself. When c!Wilbur assigned him the duty of being his right hand man, he shouldered that role and all that came with it with pride. When c!Wilbur challenged his status later on, he challenged him right back. Even despite his position as "lower" in the hierarchy, c!Tommy was still an individual with his own will and was outspoken in his opinions. In exile, that fire and that opposition was dimmed and smothered until his sense of self and his worth as an individual was more dependent on outside perspectives rather than his own. This was evident in the bunker during the Disc Finale when he asked c!Tubbo, "What am I without you?" In his conversation with c!Foolish all of his development, both negative and positive, were displayed so well. His words about c!Wilbur in particular highlight this especially when he says that, in spite of all the bad he's committed in the past, he's still capable of good. As is anyone else. They weren't mutually exclusive to him anymore. Though, when he was questioned about his role on the server he concluded that it was up to interpretation based on the person, which still showcases his inner conflict with himself as an individual as well as the burden that comes with it.
In regards to how c!Wilbur perceives himself within this narrative, it's equally complicated in that he both thrived and spiraled within the confines of these roles. c!Wilbur is a showman, he revels in his theatrics with bouts of melodrama and making grand gestures. The world was a stage and he stepped into the center to perform. c!Wilbur views the server through the lens of storytelling, assigning and shouldering roles as he understands them. This, compounded with his black and white view of the world which was much like c!Tommyâs before his worldview gained a bit more nuance, prevented him from thinking outside the portrayals he envisioned in his mind. In the early days, anyone who was with them was âgoodâ and anyone who was against them was âbadâ, a simple division of them versus their opposition. Over time he buckled under the weight of these expectations, both from himself and others, and in the end succumbed to the combined stress of both this and his struggle with his declining mental health. As a result of his death and time in limbo, his own character development was suspended as the server left him behind. When he was revived, he was unchanged and lacking the knowledge of what had happened during his absence, thus leaving his adrift in its midst. He thought that he was center-stage in server's story and once again internalized these thoughts, attributing all its conflicts and changes to his own influence and portraying himself as the simultaneous sole solution and crux of the issue. At a surface level this seems to be due to his self-centered nature, and in some respects it is. However, this is also a means for him to conceal himself behind a facade. By continuing to play the roles he knows and by assuming everyone else falls in line as they always did before, he prevents himself from seeing what has changed and ignores it in favor of using it as a means to excuse his coming departure and all that it entails.
All of this to say, I'm interested in how they'll end their character's arcs and resolve the conflicts and issues they have with each other when they seem to have such fundamentally different ends in mind. c!Tommy wants a place and person he can feel safe and cared about with as an individual and as himself, while c!Wilbur seems to want to move forward and beyond everything completely once he's made his amends, leaving behind a legacy more favorable than his last. With the contrast inherent in c!Tommy's plea to stay warring with c!Wilbur's desire to leave, I am curious to see how these two will reconcile with all that in mind. It's my wish that they reach that conclusion together, despite it all.