So, here’s my own hot take on bi women using butch/femme terms. I researched the history of the terms butch/femme and lesbians experiences with them, and this is my understanding of these terms and identities. The terms butch and femme are complicated lesbian identities that have been in use for a long time. If you don’t already know, butch and femme don’t just mean that one dresses more masculine or feminine. These identities also coincide with gender expression, social presentation, sexual and relationship roles, subverting gender roles, and gender identity. Femmes are not lesbians trying to act straight, and butches are not lesbians trying to be straight men, and these identities should never be mistaken as such. The experience of loving and being sexually attracted to women only often shapes how women view themselves and their world. Some lesbians feel a disconnect from their womanhood, because of their lesbianism, and go by alternative pronouns. Other lesbians identify as non-binary, and their gender identity and sexuality do not discredit the other. The terms butch and femme often help lesbians who have no other language to describe their lesbianism and gender identity express their feelings and identities. Butch and femme are very reliant of the lesbian experience, and how being a women who solely loves other women affects them. Bi women, obviously, do not share lesbian experiences that shape these identities, because, in short, bi women are not lesbians. This isn’t to say bi women cannot love women as well as lesbians or that bi women cannot have complicated relationships with their gender. However, I am saying that bi women do not share the same relationship with womenhood, identity, and gender expression that lesbians do, because they do not share the experience of loving and having relationships with only women. Butch and femme identities are often built off of these experiences, and because bi women do not share in these experiences, they also cannot share in these identities. Also, the terms butch and femme were often created and used in the context of women seeking other women and wanting a relationship with only women. Butches often seek out femmes, and vice-versa. While butch-butch relationships and femme-femme relationships obviously exist (and are completely valid) the birth of these terms, while also based on lesbians’ complicated relationship with gender, are also based on women seeking relationships with other women. Femme/butch identities are synonymous with having relationships with other women and were created to have relationships with other women, so it wouldn’t truly make sense for butch or femme women to seek out relationships with men or non-binary partners. Idenifieng as a term created in the context of a specific action and relationship, while seeking something different just wouldn’t make sense. But, what about bi women? Are they not allowed to have terms to express their identities and feelings? First of all, I do not believe bi women using butch and femme terms is a completely malicious attack on lesbians and their terminology. Many bi women, me included, were not or are not aware of terminology for bi women, and have used butch or femme to describe themselves. But, now there are many terms to describe bi women, such as doe, stag, and tomcat. While not much has been explored in these identities and they are fairly new, bi women do have terms to describe ourselves when it comes to gender expression, and experiences as bi women. (I might make another post about my experiences with femme/doe identities, and what they mean to me.) More bi women coining identities such as tomcat or doe can help more people become aware of these identities and bring more nuance and exploration of these identities.
TLDR; The term butch and femme were built on the lesbian experiences and the context of wanting relationships with only women. Because bi women cannot share in those experience and do not solely want relationships with men, they cannot also share in the identities that do not revolve around their experiences. I hope with made sense! Also, please be civil in the notes! XOXO