My official controversial take:
I never liked how much Cutie was hated. It stung tbh.
I have this... problem of sorts, or clinging onto people too heavily. Neurodivergent doesn't begin to describe me but until there's an official diagnosis, I will never know to what extent is wrong/not sound with me.
And honestly? I'm a Cutie defender because I feel like they were the same way at first.
I personally would love to know what people think of me just to make sure they still want to be around me, instead of wondering if they hate me behind my back. Cutie having telepathy is no different. It makes it so much easier to overhear (quite literally overhear) what people think of them, especially unempowered ones.
Were their actions justified? Absolutely the fuck not. They crossed the line after being told repeatedly that Geordi wanted them to not listen in and respect his boundaries.
I have done the exact fucking thing and have lost too many people because of it. It still hurts to this day that I lost friends over my own stupid actions.
And now them being hesitant or possibly refusing to use their abilities? Yeah. That's what fucking happens when people mess up and learn from their mistakes. They're afraid that they're going to mess up again. I am afraid to mess up again, so in turn, I never fucking talk unless I'm spoken to.
No one will ever know the true extent of what happened to Cutie before they even met Geordi — only Erik will ever know that, if he even wants to make that a thing, and it should be understood and respected if he doesn't want to.
But to literally hate a realistically written, possibly neurodivergent character just because they messed up, even though they got help and is now better?
That's just fucked up, in my opinion.
People can change for the better, therapy can do wonders to make a person behave better. And that applies here.
Cutie did wrong, yes, they fucked up. They got help. They went to therapy. They're working on controlling their telepathy better, getting a better handle on things. And the relationship is still going strong. They refuse to use their magic unless Geordi asks them to.
That's what healing looks like, and to hate that is just... messed up.
Maybe I feel too strongly attached to Cutie but I've gone through the same things before. I dunno. Take this controversial opinion, I guess.