i'm not in love
in which angus always preferred being alone. at least, he used to.
pairing is angus tully x fem!reader
word count is 3.4k
author says don't look at me <3 not proofread bc it's me
you should watch out for college-aged angus, mostly just two besties who are so in love it makes them stupid
title song is i'm not in love // 10cc
angus tully answers his motherâs biweekly calls diligently. not because either of them truly want to speak to each otherâitâs more perfunctory than anything. she calls and asks about school, and he tells her itâs good. then he asks about stanley, and she tells him about stanleyâs job, and then sheâll ask angus about his job. he tells her itâs fine, and she offers him money that heâll accept only if heâs in a particularly foul mood. after three years, they almost have it down to a perfect script.Â
at least, he thought they did.Â
âhowâs y/n?â
the question catches him so off-guard that his sharp intake of breath makes him choke, but judy waits patiently for an answer. he mentioned you every once in a while. mostly, he likes that youâre an entirely separate part of his life from his mother and stanley. heâll bring you up if she asks why he isnât coming home on a holiday, or on the off-chance she asks about his weekend plans. yours is one of the only names heâs ever given her when he talks about school, and one of the only ones that seems to stick around longer than a few months at a time. âsheâsâŠgood,â he responds tentatively.
âwhat are you guys doing tonight?â
he stares at his phone in bemusement. âwhat is this?â
she sighs, and he can almost see that displeased look on her face. he had it memorized. âwhen are we going to meet her?â
âwhy do you want to meet her?â he asks. if he really thinks about it, it makes sense. you two had lived across from one another for three years, and you had fallen together in a way that almost felt predetermined. you are the longest standing person in his life post-high school, and his mother knows this.
he had always preferred being alone. even as a child, he had no interest in playing with the neighborhood kids in the middle of the street. he liked doing things by himself. he liked doing what he wanted without having to inform anyone else. when he had gone to college and found a semi-affordable apartment that he wouldnât have to share, he had been elated. the cute girl across the hall had just been a plus.Â
you two had always just worked. he holds everyone at arm's length, but it had never even occurred to him to shut you out. you two end up together most nights, watching movies or doing homework. it happens so easily that he hardly recognizes how strange it is. perpetual wallflower angus tully is attached.
âwell, you two have been together for a while. if things are serious, i think itâs best that we meet her.â
angus blinks, shocked, before a nervous laugh bubbles up in his chest. it starts low, but the longer she waits in her own confused silence, the louder and more unruly his laughter becomes. heâs laughingânot because the idea is ridiculous, but because itâs so plausible that it takes him by surprise. he had spent the last two years trying to bury his feelings for you, and he had been so unsuccessful that even his mother had picked up on it.
âangus,â she snaps, and he giggles, even though it isnât funny, even though his stomach twists and rolls in a way that makes him feel sick.
âiâm sorry,â he gasps, covering his eyes. âjustâŠweây/n and i arenât together.â
thereâs a long moment of silence where he catches his breath before his mom says, âangus, thatâs not funny.â
âwell, it is, if you think about it really hard,â he offers. she sighs, exasperated, and angus rubs his eyes. he canât possibly explain to his mother what about this situation is truly amusing, because really, it isnât funny. itâs not funny that heâs desperately in love with his best friend, and itâs not funny that she oscillates between entirely oblivious and seemingly aware.Â
âyouâre telling me youâve been missing family holidays for a girl you arenât dating?âÂ
he can tell she doesnât believe him, and he doesnât bother reminding her that they havenât had a real family holiday in years. long before he started university, and long before he met you. besides, answering that question honestly is dangerous, and should he not handle this delicately, heâll find himself on the wrong side of his motherâs wrath.
âuhâŠâ
heâs fumbling, panicking, and it only gets worse when he hears his front door open. âangus?â you call, and his whole body cringes, his head falling to rest on the wall.
âangus,â judy warns.
âyeah,â he blurts, watching you round the corner. you smile, offering only a small wave as you drop your bag onto his kitchen table. âno, mom, obviously not. that would be ridiculous.â
as he feels her anxiety cease, his own skyrockets. heâs focused entirely on you; your back is turned toward him as you open his fridge, searching through the shelves for something to eat. if it were anyone else, heâd be irritated, but he almost loves it when you do it. loves that you feel comfortable enough in his home to make yourself feel at home, that he can take care of you in the smallest way. most nights, when he lies in bed and thinks of you, he finds himself thinking of the ways he could take care of you. the ways he could give you what he never had, the things that had been ripped from him. security. unconditional affection. peace. heâs barely listening when his mother sighs again. âyou know, i donât understand your humor sometimes.â
âi know,â he says. you kick the fridge closed, enough food in your hands to feed both of you. âhey, she actually just got here. can i let you go?â
ânot until you answer my question.â her voice is clipped now, and angus winces. some nights sheâs a little more forgiving with his distraction, a little more responsive to the things he says that she doesnât necessarily understand. tonight, heâs more distracted than usual and less decipherable than ever. âwhen can we meet her?â
angus groans, and you smile over your shoulder. you know better than anyone how much he struggles with his mother. youâve listened in on many of their phone calls, and patiently listened to him complain about them later. âi donât know, mom.â
âhow about easter?â she asks. angus turns to lean against the wall and watch you, and you lean against the counter, waiting for him to be done. he rolls his eyes, a silent cue that things are taking longer than heâd like. âstanley and i can drive up that saturday and take you guys out for a nice dinner. on us.â
reluctantly, only because he knows that sheâll blow a gasket if they donât nail down plans on this phone call, and because he wants this to be over, he huffs. he pulls the receiver away slightly and asks, âyou want to have dinner with my mom and stanley easter weekend?â
you blink owlishly. âwhat? why?â
âthey want to meet you.â
âwhy?â you insist. he glares at you impatiently; knowing angusâmore, knowing what you know about his motherâan answer is needed now, and explanation must come later. the idea of meeting his mom makes your stomach turn uncomfortably, but there he stands. even with a hard glare, you feel safe with him. you feel the need to do what he asks of you, and you know him well enough to know that he wouldnât ask if he thought it would be something you couldnât handle. âuhâŠi guess, yeah.â
he offers a grateful smile. âeaster weekend sounds great, mom.â
they quickly finalize plans before hanging up, and the second the receiver is back on hook, he groans loudly, rubbing his eyes. you wait for him to speak, but he stands with his hands over his eyes, hiding from you. âangus.â
âshe thinks youâre my girlfriend,â he blurts.
you really donât mean to start laughing. âwhat?â
his lips turn up in a sheepish smile. âi guess theyâve thought we were together this entire time,â he chuckles. âand i panicked! she accused me missing holidays to spend time with you and i didnât want to get in troubleââ
you clutch your stomach, doubled over in laughter. he doesnât want to laughâfrankly, heâs a little hurt that you find the idea so laughable, but he had laughed, too. âyou caved,â you gasp. âyou caved and told a lie because you didnât want to get in trouble with your mommy.â
âokay.â he rolls his eyes. âwhatever. youâre part of this now, too.â
your giggles die down and you turn to take the food out of the microwave. âhey, i could back out. i could break up with you at any time.â
he scoffs, but doesnât respond. often enough, when youâre doing exactly what youâre doing now, angusâ feelings become overwhelming. watching you move around his kitchen with the kind of natural domesticity makes him feel choked, buried under his overflowing affection.
the harder he fights his feelings, the worse they get. youâre his best friendâitâs not on purpose, either; you arenât at all the kind of person he ever thought he would fall for. you were bitingly funny, of course, but you fought him constantly. he wouldnât even say you were particularly nice for the first few months you two knew one another. youâre entirely out of left field, and he canât even get a read on you half the timeânot that he even really wants to. part of him thinks that knowing exactly what you think about him would be truly crushing.
âi guess a free meal could be nice,â you tease, stirring your dinner with a knowing smile.
âyeah, youâre so unused to those,â he bites, pushing himself off the wall. you beam.
itâs surprising, in a way, that you hadnât met angusâ mom and stepfather already. heâs met your family a thousand times over; they take you both out to dinner every single time they visit you. they had sent him a birthday gift this year, for christâs sake. but you could probably count the amount of time angus had seen his mother in the last three years on both hands. you were surprised enough that she even remembered your name.
you had spent your entire friendship with angus thinking about his mother. being angry with her. your best friend is caring, in his own stilted, modest way. heâs witty and so smart that it intimidates you, and heâs loyal. it tells you all you need to know that his relationship with his mother isnât strong.Â
he bumps you out of the way, and you let him. you watch him open the cupboard for plates to evenly split the leftover pasta, and your chest nearly heaves with confused affection. you see the way he looks at you when heâs not careful. with an unrestrained reverence, with a tenderness that canât be forced. it had made you uncomfortable, at first. made you feel like you couldnât be around him anymore. you had tried to pull awayâfor a day or two.Â
the reality of the entire situation is that angus tully belongs in your life. you adore him too much to cut him out, and even if you didnât, it kills you to think of him alone. heâs a lone wolf; itâs amazing enough that you two have connected the way that you have. if angus didnât have you, he had a few friends from class. maybe two or three guys from work. but nothing as deep, nothing as serendipitous as your friendship.Â
discomfort with his feelings had grown into a tentative acceptance once you realized he had no plans on acting on them, and after a few months, tentative acceptance had grown intoâŠsomething else entirely. you arenât sure exactly what it is. it isnât like those juvenile, giddy crushes you had harbored in high school. angus doesnât keep you up at night, nor does he make you lovesick. he puts you at ease. he makes you feel safe. he makes you feel like yourself.
you donât want to confront the strange sense of peace that angus has offered you without even knowing. without even trying. you donât want to change your friendship, or misattribute your feelings, so you ignore them. and you ignore the way he looks at you, and how he insists on making your favorite dinners, even though he complains about you eating his leftovers, and how he uses your spare key to lock your door every single time he leaves your apartment without fail.Â
your knees bump together under the tiny table in his kitchen as you two eat dinner. you listen to him talk about his coworkers, lulled into relaxation by his deep voice; you always loved your dinnertime conversations. mostly, one of you just talked. you would talk about school and work and your classmates and your days; they arenât even really conversations. itâs just an excuse to talk and an opportunity to listen. he doesnât mind when you donât respond, and neither of you care if the other person talks the entire time. itâs time spent together more than anything else. you think about how effortless it feels. how you could do this every night with intention, not under the guise of getting out of your apartment. you think about the dinner with his mom, and how youâll both put on nice outfits to go out, and how youâll come home together, and how youâll dissect every detail of the dinner and the conversations for the entire night, if not for days afterwards.
you notice only a moment too late that youâve zoned out, and angus kicks your shin gently. âyou good?â
with a reassuring smile, you nod. âyeah. iâm just thinking about dinner with your mom.â
heâs bashful when he laughs quietly. âyeahâŠsorry. i know i kind of screwed you over.â you can tell that he truly does feel bad, but the longer you think about it, the less you dread it. you think you might actually like an excuse to acknowledge the way angus looks at you, for him to not have to hide it.Â
âi donât knowâŠiâm kind of excited,â you admit, pushing food around your plate. angus looks at you from under his lashes, taking pause at your tone. you refuse to look at him, and it sends his heart into overdrive; heâs panicked, certainly, and so in love with you that it makes him nauseous. he isnât entirely sure that heâll survive a night of you pretending. of it all feeling so real.
he can feel a confession coming, bubbling up in his chest, and he swallows in panic. âsheâsâsheâll like you, i think.â
with a slight smile, you push your plate away from you. âiâm not sure iâll like her.â
which he loves about you, naturally.Â
he clears his throat to bury the confession and stands; angus grabs both plates and turns his back to you to hide his flushed cheeks. shamelessly, since he canât see you, you watch him, soothed simply by the way he moves. by how familiar he is. by how you can almost predict every move he makes. the words fall out before youâre even cognizant of them
âjust so you know, i donât mind your mom thinking iâm your girlfriend.â
the way he freezes makes your shoulders tense. you hadnât meant to say that. it was true, but he didnât need to know that. angusâ mind screeches to a full stop before it starts running ten times faster than before. what did that mean?
slowlyâso slowly that you almost donât noticeâhe sets the plates in the sink. you wonât get out of this. you know you wonât, because you know angus. once the door is open, heâll take the opportunity to push it every single time. âwhy?â he asks, his voice a carefully constructed tone of ease. he plays it well; his nonchalance is almost perfectly natural. it nearly tricks you.
still kicking yourself, you shrug even though he canât see you. instead, you start emptying your bag to distract yourself. textbooks and notebooks and pencils clatter against the table. âjustâŠwe could sell it, donât you think?â itâs not even close to what he wants to hear, and you buckle down even though you know you wonât win this one. âwe know everything about each other.â
he snorts, and it puts you at ease. not because youâre going to get out of this. you know something dangerous is going to come out of this conversation, but because itâs angus. itâs your best friend. and you know him, and you know the way he treats you is symptomatic of something much larger. it used to scare you, but it doesnât now. not now that he washes your dishes, the sleeves of his sweater pushed up to his elbows. you trust him. you know that any vulnerability you share will be returned to you tenfold.
âyeah, right. that just makes it convenient,â he says knowingly, head tilting. he watches you sort through your textbooks, hiding your anxiety while you busy yourself.
part of you hopes that heâll just drop it. not because you donât think things will work out, but because you love how things are between the two of you. the almosts, the what-ifs, the wondering is something you so love to savor. itâs still so easy between you two; all of those what-ifs still exist only in your minds, only in the silent space between you that neither of you are willing to acknowledge. thereâs plausible deniability. thereâs safety.
you smile shakily, glancing up at him. âi guess i meanâŠthat weâŠwork?â
he smiles back, comforting but still audacious. âand by that, you meanâŠâ
with a groan, you fold your arms and bury your face in them. you know this leap can only be beneficial, but youâre struggling to let yourself admit anything. itâs more frustrating than the denial.Â
angus stares at you, suddenly the emotionally constipated one, and his heart is pounding in his ears. he can feel it beating against his chest; heâs not brave enough to hope. itâs too scary for him to wonder if this is finally it, if you had been as keenly aware as he had assumed you to be.Â
âjustâŠi think thereâs a reason my mom thinks weâre together. just so you know.â you groan louder, unmoved by his words, and he continues, âbeyond the fact that weâre constantly together.â
you peek up at him, your chin still pressed against your forearms. he watches you, big brown eyes wide open with vulnerability. heâs waiting. you figure itâs as good of a segue as heâs going to give you. with a deep breath, ignoring the turning and rolling of your stomach, you say, âi feel likeâŠthings could be like that between us.â
he breaks into a smile so wide that you have to look away from him. âoh, is that what this is about?â he asks facetiously.Â
you grunt, irritated. âdonât tease me.â
he laughs, uncrossing his arms. you donât even want to look at him, humiliated. he hasnât rejected youâin fact, you know heâs just keeping you on the line to tease you. it irritates you, but he seems giddy, even if he tries to act like heâs unaffected. he canât keep that goofy smile off his face. it entirely gives him away. âhey,â he says, voice bright. âcâmere.â
âno,â you spit, annoyed. you know that the second you give in, everything will change. for the better, you think, but it will change. you hold on to the wondering for just a moment longer, but you canât help yourself. he waits patiently at the counter, holding on to the ledge. you like the wondering, but you think youâre ready to find out if itâs as good as it seems it would be.
self-conscious, you cross the room to him. you stand only centimeters apart, and he grins at you, fingers gently stroking the hem of your collar. âyou know, right?â
you donât have to ask what he means. you know. maybe not the depths, but you know. the way he looks at you is enough to let you know. the way he takes care of you tells you what his words havenât yet. they will. âyou canât hide from me, angus tully.â
he loves that about you, too. heâll tell you all the specifics later. for now, he kisses you, a long arm around your waist, and you think that this is much better than the what-ifs.













