I want to be a little bit of an unserious/light-hearted hater for a moment and confess that I don’t like Redtail because the amount of attention he gets annoys me.
Imo Redtail’s character is actually on caliber with the likes of Mistmouse, Leafshade, or Cloudpelt. Characters that when you hear their name, it makes you pause for a moment like, “Wait. Who?” But the reason that it doesn’t annoy me when Mistmouse, Leafshade, or Cloudpelt or the like gets attention is because Mistmouse, Leafshade, and Cloudpelt fans know that their blorbo is obscure and not that important. So when I see those characters getting love I just think: “Good for them. That person must have developed those characters in some cool way in order to latch onto them like that.”
But when Redtail gets attention, I feel like it’s usually presented like: “this guy was actually so important!!!” But the truth is, Redtail just isn’t all that important. His death is important, but his character is not. He doesn’t even really have much of a character at all. Redtail was simply blessed in that fact that he happened to die within the first 5 pages of the first book of the first arc, so everyone who picked up a Warriors book happens to remember him. And I think we as a fandom should acknowledge that lol
















