Close Call's 2013 offseason losers
8. Nick Johnson: Retired at age 34
So, this is more of a throughout-his-career type thing, but Johnson was never able to reach his full potential. Let's take a look at his 162-game averages for a few categories: he averaged 18 home runs/162. If he'd played full seasons in each of the 13 years since he started in '00, he'd have a career total of 234 (rather than the 95 he has). His 723 hits would go up to 1,833, and his 398 RBI would become 1,001. Plus, he probably wouldn't be retiring at 34. But due to tons of injuries, the closest Nick got to a full season was playing 147 games with the '06 Nationals.
7. Roy Oswalt: Remains a free agent
Oswalt was one of the most consistently dominant pitchers in baseball for a number of years with Houston, and had a 3.69 ERA as recently as 2011. While '12 was the worst statistical year of his career, it was his first year in the AL, and he was battling an injury all season. It was also the first season he'd ever appeared regularly out of the bullpen, which can be a tough transition for an 11-year veteran. In a pitching market that's been basically completely harvested, he's the best option left out there who isn't tied to draft pick compensation, and yet the only significant interest in him has been from the Mets, who want him to be their closer.
6. Dallas Braden and Armando Galarraga
Braden remains a free agent, and Galarraga signed a minor league deal with Cincinnati in January. They share some history, as Braden's Mother's Day perfect game in 2010 was less than a month before Galarraga's infamous blown call game, in which umpire Jim Joyce blew a call, saying the hitter who came up with 2 outs in the 9th while Galarraga had a perfect game going was safe at first, when really the first baseman had him out by a full step. Galarraga retired the next batter to complete the one-hitter.
Braden pitched just 3 games in '11 and none in '12 due to shoulder injuries, and was thus released by the A's in October. He's always shown promise and talent; he owns a career 4.16 ERA (which has gotten lower each season he's pitched) and a 1.325 WHIP.
Galarraga was somewhat of a random guy to throw a near-perfect game; aside from his rookie season in '08 when he had a 3.73 ERA, his numbers have never been particularly noteworthy, but his 3 full seasons in Detroit showed that he can be a solid back-of-the-rotation guy for a team that needs him. He's going to have a tough time breaking into a deep Reds rotation led by Johnny Cueto and Aroldis Chapman.
How the kind of mighty have somewhat fallen.
5. New York Yankees
Could this be the year the Yankees don't make the playoffs? Or even, maybe, just maybe, finish last--yes, last-in the AL East???
When you're the New York Yankees, an offseason in which your only significant moves are signing Travis Hafner and Kevin Youklis, whose ages add up to 68, is not just a loss, but it's downright baffling. The Bronx Bombers were tied to a number of free agents and potential trade targets, but never bade that big splash. That, plus injuries to Derek Jeter (though he's supposedly going to be ready for Opening Day), Alex Rodriguez, and Curtis Granderson, plus even more steroid allegations surrounding A-Rod--are worrisome for the team. Their superstars are aging, and they barely avoided being ousted as division champs by the resilient Orioles last year. All of the other teams in the AL East have made significant additions this offseason, and the Yanks will face some stiff competition.
4. Javier Vazquez: Remains "retired"
At 35, the 14-year veteran pitcher announced his retirement following the 4th-best season of his career in 2011. The former Expo drew significant interest from around the league, including form the Nationals, but a knee injury this offseason ended any hopes of him pitching in 2013. He'd likely have received either a well-paying last-minute contract by a team looking to round out its rotation before opening day, or an even better deal once the season starts when a team loses a pitcher to injury. However, the injury ended all of those talks, and it's looking more and more like he won't treat his retirement in a Favre/Jordan/Clemens-esque sense, but that he's really done for good.
3. Eli Whiteside
A backup catcher with 2 World Series rings, Whiteside has bounced around "faster than a beach ball at a Nickleback concert" (to quote Hot Rod) this offseason. The Giants placed him on waivers shortly following the season. Then, on November 5, the Yankees claimed him off of waivers, then put him back on waivers. On December 3, he was claimed by Toronto from the Yankees, and then by Texas from Toronto that same day. Hopefully he's in Texas to stay for the forseeable future, but he had a crazy couple of months there. He is a serviceable defensive backup, though he's coming off a couple of dreadful offensive years.
2. Kyle Lohse: Remains a free agent
A 12-year veteran, the righty had by far the best season of his career at 33 years young in '12. He's the lone remaining Type A free agent, and there are likely two reasons he's still on the market: He probably has a pretty high asking price, and, more importantly, signing him would cause the signing team to lose their first-round draft pick this year. Lohse is likely somewhat overrated, due to his age and his career tendencies (his 2.86 ERA last year and 3.39 ERA in '11 were his two lowest, and only the second and third sub-4 ERAs of his long career). However, he's always been a reliable innings eater (he's averaged 28 starts per season in his career), and thus would be a good addition to any team.
It's worth noting that, if he waits to sign with a team until after June's draft, he'll no longer be tied to compensation. We'll see if he's willing to sacrifice playing time to get a better deal with a better team. He can also be the guy out there available for contenders who lose a starter to injury.
1. Miami Marlins
Can you say fire sale? And no, I don't mean Die Hard 4. The Marlins, less than a year after their makeover--new stadium, new players, huge payroll--basically hit the self destruct button this offseason. Here's who they traded away: Jose Reyes, Mark Buehrle, Josh Johnson, John Buck, Emilio Bonifacio, and Heath Bell. Here's the "big names" they've added: Juan Pierre, Yunel Escobar, Placido Polanco, John Maine, Casey Kotchman, Chone Figgins, and Jon Rauch.
The guys they traded away, aside from Buck and Bonifacio, were all previously faces of franchises. Those seven new guys' ages average out to 33.14 years.While many of them were previously fantastic players, most of them are well over the hill; Maine hasn't pitched in the big leagues since '10, and most of the other guys are at least 3 years removed from their best seasons.
All of these trades has upset rising superstar Giancarlo Stanton, who's probably the one remaining guy the Marlins really need to have on their side to avoid full-on riots in the streets of Miami. Owner Jeffrey Loria is one of the most hated men in Florida right now.
~Close Call~








