rethinking the anime "magic girl site" and lowkey it'd have been really good if it wasn't trying so fucking hard to be madoka magica, except edgier.
madoka magica was so good because even amidst all the horror and despair, there was still hope to be found in the form of godoka, and also the fact that any girl can wish for basically anything from kyuubey.
magic girl site doesn't offer such relief. if any of the girls use too much magic, they just die. there's no relief system in place. the site admins are all just evil, and aya's brother is just evil.
i know the manga ends with the timeline being reset or smthn so that the site no longer exists or whatever and aya's brother isn't evil anymore but that to me feels like a cop-out. all it tells me is that nothing that happened mattered.
when the universe was reset in madoka magica, there were still consequences. the first time it was reset, it came at the cost of madoka existing in living memory. the second time it was reset, it came at the cost of homura taking her place.
as far as i am aware, there is no such consequence in magic girl site.
it's a shame too because magic girl site offers so many good and interesting ideas but it gets sent to the wayside for the sake of angst and fanservice (the latter specifically with nijimi and shioi bc wtf)
idk this is mostly a rant














