on my bullshit again about the watering-down of Ilya as a person that some (SOME I SAID) fans do in order to kinda valorise (?) Shane (NOT AN INSULT TO MY BELOVED SHANE HE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS!!!!!)
But this time in relation to the Centaurs.
It's a thing I've seen frequently that upon Shane moving to the Centaurs, Ilya immediately starts deferring to him or the Centaurs immediately switch like "friendship allegiance" to Shane and kind of mock Ilya or Shane is portrayed as generally being In Charge of Ilya with the Centaurs supporting that narrative.
Similarly to my issues with the Shane Walks Ilya Like A Dog genre, it erases Ilya's agency as a character by making him something that Shane has to handle rather than Ilya being a multifaceted character in his own right and additionally diminishes him as someone with his own drive, talent and ambition to become a kind of "pet" to Shane. It also reduces Shane's character to Ilya's "parent" or "minder" and portrays him as being exasperated or annoyed with the man he loves and willingly and enthusiastically got married to.
Now. A bit of friendly joking or mocking is a common thing! Sometimes we make fun of our friends! In a loving manner!
However there's a lot of stuff out there that's just consistent mocking of Ilya by the Centaurs, a lot of it the kind of "idk how he puts up with you!" type of boomer humour. Again insults both Ilya and Shane imo and their relationship.
(Why are you making Shane the mature calm collected one and Ilya the hyperactive dumb sexual idiot he has to control? I think people forget that Shane is a Jock, even more so than Ilya and his silk shirts, and he is not a blushing maiden! It is the biases people have against autistic men, men who bottom and East Asian men let's be so fr. Shane is not scandalised by Ilya like a Victorian maid. Yeah he didn't want Ilya calling them lovers in front of Yuna and David, but they're his parents! As far as MY parents are concerned, my boyfriend and I chastely hold hands five metres apart on the couch, my friends know we fuck!)
Also makes the Centaurs kind of one dimensional characters? Kinda gives them a henchman vibe.
I support them chirping Ilya, that's so understandable and common. But at the same time, a lot of the stuff I see is not consistent with a team that have been captained by Ilya for nearly three years, that have been supported by him and supported him! Like the Cens were truly in the trenches for a while and Ilya was there with them, hauling them up out of it! That speech post plane incident was such a motivation for their team, to the point they actually won multiple games in a row and made it to the second round of playoffs, after a playoff drought of literal YEARSSSS. Like they beat freaking Montreal! In a series!
Textually, the Cens have a lot of loyalty and respect for Ilya as their captain and friend. He may have missed a lot of off-ice bonding due to the fact loverboy 3000 was spending every spare second he could have with yearnerboy 3000 but he still supported them! Especially Troy, his Cens best friend!
Immediately pivoting their characters to be on "Shane's Side" (which again, there are no sides to be taken in this relationship, it is Hollanov vs the problems (institutional homophobia, racism, the Russia of it all) not Shane vs Ilya!) does a disservice to that loyalty and friendship. They love Ilya, they don't see him as something to be managed or put up with.
On the point of Ilya deferring to Shane as captain, I think that's bullshit. Shane probably gets the A at some point, that's understandable, but Ilya is captain for a reason. We see in both books that he's a good captain as well, to both Boston and Ottawa! I think part of that is a general lack of knowledge (not meant in a bad way) about the actual duties of an NHL captain, but at the same time, Ilya is canonically one of the two best players in the MLH and an experienced captain. He knows what he's doing! He understands his players (again looking at everything he did for Troy) and as much as I love Shane and know he supports Ilya (bc he's a good partner), Shane also knows that Ilya's got this.
(Quick sidebar to pivot to the general hc about the Cens being annoyed with Hollanov doing PDA in the locker room. Hollanov are not doing that. Ik Shane thinks at some point that he doesn't understand how Ilya's teammates are capable of being normal about his hotness in the showers etc but that's because he's in love with Ilya and they are not currently on the same team. In an actual professional setting, they're not making out in the locker room. lowkey undertones of unconscious homophobia on that one but whatever. Hollanov are probably told to get a room when the Cens are at a club or at a gathering, but they're not going to be unprofessional at the rink. Moving on)
My final point. Shane does not save the Centaurs. God knows I adore him, and he is OF COURSE a generational player. He's insanely good. He is a hockey beast and everyone should fear to be on the ice against him.
That being said! Ilya canonically makes the Centaurs better. Bood is canonically one of their best players. Getting Wyatt, Luca and Troy is canonically a large part of the Centaurs rebuild. Ilya is 110% their star player who helps drag them up, and the other Cens are also locking tf in. Wiebe is a massive part of their rebuild!
obviously getting THE Shane Hollander gives them massive centre depth, and I wouldn't be surprised if Unrivalled gives us Troy-Ilya-Bood as a first line and then Luca and Shane on second line (I don't care to remember if Troy Bood and Luca are left or right wingers) bc when you have two generational centres, you're gonna have basically two first lines and then slap them together for the power play. (Sorry turned my IRL hockey brain on)
But it's important to note that the Centaurs get to the second round of playoffs in TLG without Shane. I'd imagine they win the Stanley Cup in Unrivalled or they'll have won it in the gap between TLG and Unrivalled, but they were on track to become serious Cup contenders without Shane. He undoubtedly will be a massive help bc again he's Shane fucking Hollander, but place some respect on my OG Centaurs' names! They've put in a lot of work, Ilya especially, and they are a good team.
all of this to say. Ilya's team loves him. Shane loves him. Ilya is in fact also a generational talent and an extraordinarily good hockey player and captain. Diminishing his character to Shane's lap dog does him a disservice by erasing his character and also insults and mischaracterises Shane, who is not Ilya's parent he is his husband.
(lowkey a lot of people are wife-coding Shane and wife guy- coding Ilya, bc of racist stereotypes and thinking towards East Asian men, autistic infantilisation of Shane and misogynistic and homophobic stereotyping and assumptions towards Shane as a bottom. They also masculinise Ilya bc he's a top, when this man is much more likely than Shane to explore the gender spectrum and be more "stereotypically" gay by engaging in typically feminine hobbies. Only one of these idiots had to hire a stylist to get him out of athletic gear and it wasn't Ilya and his leopard print shirt. Shane ily never change) (this will be another post in itself)
This got ridiculously long but I'm not putting it under a cut, you are going to read it <3 (lh)