Y’know I actually wanted to post this first before making the post about the beasts not being dead but when I was writing this I thought it be best to acknowledge and just speak in my opinion about the beast’s fate. But yeah it’s time I talk more about Shadow Milk Cookie. Specifically how the tarot cards back in Beacon of Hope foreshadow how he is now at the end of BY Ep. 15 and my crackshit theories on what could happened on Act 2 with the first episode, Arcana of Deceit and Truth. Of course keep in mind, this is all just speculation and ramblings from me
Ever since the reveal of the animatic trailer showing Act 2, there’s been a lot of excitement and guessing for what could happened in the story. But what I want to point out is how this update made me look back at BY Ep. 8 Beacon of Hope at the tarot card scene before Shadow Milk change them. So I’ll be breaking down what they mean and after the change
Devil — SM's unhealthy obsession mixed with loathing towards PV. As well as creating unlimited chaos to get the witches attention etc. His insecurities, pride
Death — Shadow Milk had a huge play in Pure Vanilla's Awakening and let himself get tricked by his ancient counterpart. However it could also mean that considering he was the Fount of Knowledge, he went through a drastic change but still hold back by the past and unchecked trauma, loneliness, self hatred, fully unable to moved on
Judgement - After learning of Silent Salt's "betrayal" and literally get stabbed by him in the front, SM absorbed the essence of the Ultimate Cookie along with MF, BS, and ES transforming into something even more chaotic that he now plans to create more diverge timelines in order to create his perfect timeline where deceit and chaos reign, as well as playing the Game of Truth and Deceit again with Pure Vanilla.
Wheel of Fortune - Upward: Luck, karmic cycles, turning points, new opportunities, fated encounters, and understanding the nature of life. Reverse: Loss of control, disruption, unpleasant change, setbacks
The Emperor (Black Sapphire) - Upward: representing structure, stability, and authority, symbolizes the need for control and logical, disciplined action in life. Reverse: Suggests abuse of power, lack of control, or excessive rigidity. It may indicate a need to stop avoiding responsibilities and instead take charge of your life to create order
The High Priestess (Candy Apple) - Upward: intuition, mystery, subconscious wisdom, and the divine feminine. Reverse: Repressed intuition, ignoring inner guidance, secrets, superficiality, and disconnection from oneself
In the animatic trailer, we’re shown three specific tarot cards. Wheel of Fortune both upright for Timekeeper and downwards for Shadow Milk but also the Hermit card which shows Pure Vanilla, basically the card means introspection, solitude, and the search for inner wisdom. Upright: Soul searching, spiritual journey, solitude and self reflection. Reverse: isolation, loneliness, being antisocial, refusing to accept truths.
However if you look very closely at SM’s card, I heard many people say it has the ouroboros, a snake eating its own tail which represents the eternal cycle of life, death and rebirth but could symbolized the fact Shadow Milk’s self destructive behavior in this endless cycle that he can never moved on from his painful past, trauma, the witches or get over the fact that Silent Salt “betrayed him”. Instead of moving on and accept what has happened, he holds a deep bitter grudge to not only to the Witches and cookies but everyone
Theory Time: No Turning Back and the Future of the Cookie-verse
For those who don’t know who Timekeeper Cookie is or completely new to Cookie Run in general, she’s a legendary cookie originated from Ovenbreak who made her debut in 2020. She’s the director of the Time Balance Department or TBD for short, she also happens to be the future self of Croissant Cookie (A cookie who also made her debut in Ovenbreak and first show up in Kingdom as an NPC in the Inter-dimensional Super Mayhem story) from another timeline. What the TBD does is that they check and maintain balance within the timestream of the cookie universe. Think of them as sorta like Marvel’s MCU TVA from Loki. If you want to watch stories about the TBD to learn more, then I highly recommend checking out “Operation Timeguard”, “Save the Future” and the current story that was just released back in January, “Operation: Now Hiring!”
In the trailer of OvenBreak’s previous update, they explain how timelines work. An important detail to note is that when an unexpected event from a core timeline occurs, splitting to create diverge timelines, but when these grow, it can become so overwhelming and chaotic. If these aren’t trimmed away, the sheer volume of energy from the core timeline can cause it to lapse out of existence. This is where the TBD steps in which they have END (Emergency Neutralization Division) deal with potential temporal emergencies
Even things can happened without the caused of divergent timelines, which as catastrophic events when a core timeline’s shards can break off and drift into temporal space and if these aren’t repair, you can kiss that timeline goodbye. And this isn’t the first time, if you’re an longtime Ovenbreak player like you me then you know that in one of Ovenbreak’s previous updates of 2025 was the final showdown (Draconic Immortalis) against Longan Dragon Cookie in which they in a desperate attempt tried to break the veiled border to rule all however doing so would have caused OB’s timeline to collapse, it gotten so bad that Millennial Tree Cookie had to step in and asked Timekeeper Cookie to help which she ordered the TBD to repair the time barrier.
And what happens if divergent timelines become so powerful that not even the END or Timekeeper could stop it? Uhh…well I can’t imagine what but we all know it has something to do with that clown and fate of the entire cookie world and beyond ._.
Now this leaves in with these guys…the dragons, corrupted legendaries and finally the last group of new cookies we’re not familiar with. In CRK’s 5th anniversary fan festival, they briefly talked about how these group of cookies are part of a secret organization connected to the TBD.
Here’s my take on how this could go:
The four main dragons (Ananas, Lotus, Lychee and Longan Dragon) will be involved and are from the Kingdom timeline. Some of them will help our heroes while those like Longan Dragon will take advantage of the situation. But the dark purple dragon (Either from the Jewel or Coral Dragons. The stone dragon is out of the picture since the Ebony Dragon in Ovenbreak has a black and red color scheme) is from another timeline in which they survived and escape to Kingdom’s due to Shadow Milk’s messing with the timelines. And let’s remember the fact that Pitaya Dragon got absolutely beaten in BY EP. 14, and it looks like they’ll be under SM’s control which sucks
The corrupted legendaries (Alluring Crescent/Moonlight), Deep Sea Trident/Sea Fairy), and Night Archer/Wind Archer) are from another timeline, possibly from SM’s attempt in spreading his chaos and deceit or not. However the odd ones standing out are Millennial Tree and Fire Spirit Cookie since they’re in their Primal Mercy and Immortal Cataclysm ovenbreak costumes respectively. Then there’s also Stormbringer Cookie if you look closely and she doesn’t seem to be corrupted either but we most likely see other corrupt versions of the legendaries in the future
The last group of new cookies are either a group of supporting characters that will help our heroes or new antagonists that are a foiled to the TBD. Or maybe they’re actually work with the TBD but part of a special secret task force under direct orders from Timekeeper Cookie. I heard some people say they look liked scientists or could potentially used to be human but like the First Cookies, they somehow got turned into cookies
The Bug Beasts are a direct result of Shadow Milk using temporal energy from CRK’s timeline to create divergent timelines on a massive scale in his attempt to create the perfect timeline he desire which widely attracts the attention of Timekeeper Cookie and the TBD
(EDIT: Speaking of which, considering Timekeeper is morally grey she’ll be watching how this goes but will step in when necessary since SM is a huge threat. We’ll definitely see them have their fight again. Remember she’s the director of the TBD, she may be a little chaotic but she’s sane enough to not let the timelines or the entire multiverse rip itself apart. She’s literally one of the most important characters in the franchise and every cookie run timeline would have collapse due to catastrophic events if the TBD wasn’t formed or if there was no one else to prevent them.)
Now let’s talk about Pure Vanilla…because good grief this guy needs therapy (Everyone needs therapy at this point) and a cup of hot cocoa. White Lily’s death really hit him the hardest and with the possibility of Truthless Recluse returning, albeit not fully. I think it’s most like Pure Vanilla will be more firm and tell harsh cruel truths while still having his compassion to get through with Shadow Milk as an last attempt out of reason and to break him since he failed to reason with Dark Enchantress which we all know how that end up unfortunately. So the Pure Vanilla we’ll see in Act 2 will be mix of his Crispia and BY/Truthless Recluse, using his past experiences to beat his beast counterpart again, while Shadow Milk will try to torment and break PV again like he did before but this time for round 2 in another game of Game of Truth and Deceit. ._.
As for the hermit card I mentioned early, I guess PV would had to isolate himself, go on a journey to cope and maybe slowly heal with his grief over White Lily to find his inner truth (EDIT: Considering that the hermit card is facing upright and not reversed like SM’s, I think PV might be alright in this). It could be something like the Sugar Free Road trial he did in his youth before founding the Vanilla Kingdom, this time he might find deep understanding and the freedom White Lily left to him. And considering the fusion thing of WL and SS’s soul jam merging into one whole being to which PV calls them the “Beacon of Hope”, they’ll definitely have a huge play in the story and maybe help him, act some sort of guide but learn to find their place in the cookie world. Then there’s Candy Apple and Black Sapphire (Unless if it’s their Witch’s Castle versions but idk), who are still alive (Although this leaves me wondering about the fate of the other Beast’s minions, which I hope they’re okay after the war. Who knows where they went since Ep. 14) if you look at the title screen at the end of the trailer so obviously they’re gonna continue working for him. SM does still care about them but…For how long?
It sounds crazy but I feel like at some point seeing SM spiraling down even further would make the duo doubt, right?. Like sure spreading deceit and chaos worldwide? Sure. Slandering and ruining cookies lives (Ex: Latte Cookie, Princess Cookie and Parfait Cookie). Deceiving thousands of cookies to turn against those who sworn to the protect them? No problem!
But interfering with time to the point at the slight chance that the ENTIRE multiverse along with you, everyone you know and love could possibly be destroyed from the instability of temporal energy and among other things who knows what. You know there has to be a breaking point moment and no turning back at this rate. I know they’re very loyal to their master but even B.Sapphire is sensible and the sane out of the deceit trio to noticed something would be off. Even in Beacon of Hope, he noticed how off his master was feeling and going easy on Truthless Recluse (Pure Vanilla). If anything, Black Sapphire is more moderate and restraint compared to Candy Apple. And let’s not forget he is very self aware that CRK is a mobile game (His kingdom quotes and even his end of the year story event is high proof of that) but I’m sure he doesn’t know what exactly happens next in the story
If Devsis are really going to redeem Shadow Milk, then maybe…just maybe they could do the same to Black Sapphire and Candy Apple. Let them have their fun run at first until they slowly had their moment where they see that their actions have extremely direct consequences and learn things the very hard way, see the true destructive nature of deceit and notice that their master has gone too far, spiraling down even more further. Have them team up with our heroes since they want their master back. Maybe SM will pushed away the only two cookies who deeply cared about him, burned the last bridges out of paranoid or something given his current mental state. IF possible by the end of act 2 he's finally defeated once and for all, he will most likely received more harsh judgement, like I said in my previous post, he can’t get away scott free for the amount of crimes and shit he pulled (Honestly he’s really such a good effective villain imo. It’s fitting how he’s the most leaning towards pure evil out of the Beasts. It’s layers of tragedy and complexity the more you understand his character). Even though he absorb the powers of the three beasts and has his loyal followers by his side, he’ll still be truly alone. The first step for him in order to actually accept PV’s friend request is for him to swallow his pride and genuinely open up his vulnerabilities as well as learning to trust cookies again, it will be a slow process for sure but it might take time to heal. The same could apply to the other three beasts which might take some time for them too and a lot to think about.
But yeah those are my thoughts on this so far. I know it’s early to make assumptions but hey that’s theorizing when it comes to cookie run for ya, you just think too deep. My only hope is that they don’t rushed Act 2 and take time to get us to know other cookie worlds, more stuff on the TBD and where the journey continues for our heroes and the rest of the cast. Stay unlikely guys, I will be posting more once we get more info and closer to the story’s release