Is __ your fave cookie!!?

This is a little experiment of mine! I believe that every character in the game is someone's favorite and that they all deserve love <3

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Intro post!!

Hello everyone, I am your host Coral and I will be posting polls a few times a day asking if a certain cookie is your favorite! (Basically what the user suggests)

I accept requests for other cookie related games and side characters, I love receiving asks!

Polls on new characters will be released at 1pm est and after their release update ends to have less recency bias

Also it doesn’t have to be your ultimate favorite, tbh it’s more like if you REALLY like them. I’m indecisive as hell and I’m just here for a good time

[isblankyourfavecookie]

…well, everyone. How are we doing.?

[isblankyourfavecookie]

could you do spinach cookie please ?

Is spinach cookie your favorite npc?

Yes! 🥬

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 15

[isblankyourfavecookie]

will you do npcs next? and if you do you should do royalberry first

Is royalberry your favorite npc cookie?

Yes! 👑

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 14

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Which gem mermaid sister is your favorite?

Crimson coral 🪸

Aquamarine 🐬

Gold citrine 🔱

Mystic opal 🪻

White pearl 🌸

Voting ended onMar 9

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Is millennial tree your favorite cookie?

Yes!

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 8

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Are the chess Choco twins your favorite cookies?

Yes!

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 7

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Is Salt Cellar your favorite cookie?

Yes

No

Voting ended onMar 6

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Charcoal cookie repoll! (Is charcoal your favorite cookie?)

Yes

No

Voting ended onMar 4

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Which virtue cookie is your favorite?

Flour of Volition 🕸️

Herald of Change 🔥

Fount of Knowledge 🫐

Bringer of Happiness 🌈

Salt of Solidarity 🗡️

Voting ended onMar 3

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Which beast cookie is your favorite? (Repoll!)

Mystic flour 🌾

Burning spice 🌶️

Shadow milk 🥛

Eternal sugar 🍭

Silent salt 🧂

Voting ended onMar 2

[isblankyourfavecookie]

healer cookie? NOT pure vanilla . healer cookie specifically

Is Healer cookie your favorite?

Yes! 🩹

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 1

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Doughael repoll! (Is Doughael your favorite “cookie”?)

Yes!

Nope!

Voting ended onMar 1

[isblankyourfavecookie]

oops I haven’t posted in almost half a year……. Sorry guys I’ll get back to it

Here have some awakened white lily art I made a while back as apology (ᵕ—ᗜ—)

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Which beast minion is your favorite?

Cloud haete ☁️

Candy apple cookie 🍎

Nutmeg tiger cookie 🐅

Pavlova cookie 💘

Black sapphire cookie 🍇

Voting ended onOct 3, 2025

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Btw I’m going to do a re-poll a few updates from now with the beasts so it’s more accurate 😭

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Is nox black salt your favorite?

Yes of course

No

Voting ended onOct 1, 2025

[isblankyourfavecookie]

Devastating that we didn’t see him this update 😞