nancynextdoor·:
Nancy was still robbed of words. Yes, it was good to see him, it was so good that it hurt not being able to close the distance between them. Her gaze met the ground as she felt his burning on her frame and she wished she didn’t hold this stack of books so she could bury her hands deep in her pockets.
“Too late?” She finally stammered quietly. Too late for what? To rekindle his love for her - because hers certainly didn’t have to be revived the way it banged against her ribcage, so much so that she had to fight the urge to look down at her necklace to see if it was bouncing around on her dress.
Was it too late for anything? Was their relationship over because either of them got too wrapped up in their own shit to make a little call? She couldn’t believe Jonathan had spent the past year by the phone too scared to dial her number like she had, her hand always hovering above the tab to end the call. Anxiety turned into embarrassment, embarrassment turned into anger.
They were both cowards, the way they stood in front of each other right now. She’d blamed him for not calling, for moving out of town, for moving on, for leaving her behind, and now all that was tumbling around in the back of her mind while the desire to just fall into his arms was overwhelming her.
A memory popped into Jonathan’s head as he stared at the Wheeler girl, one that makes him cringe as he thinks about it. There had been one time the call he was always too afraid to make had gone through; he remembered standing in the doorway, back against the wall next to the phone as the dial tone rung through his ear. He waited and waited for someone to pick up, thinking that it was sheer dumb luck that he finally had the courage to call the Wheeler household and no one picked up. Then, just as he was about to put the phone back onto the receiver, he heard a voice.
“Hello?”
It wasn’t Nancy-- it was Mike, but he was still close. His heart beat against his rib cage painfully at being so close to talking to her, but he couldn’t find his voice now that someone had answered. He heard Mike’s voice again, “Hello? El, is that you?” It was so nauseating to hear someone sound so hopeful for someone else that he just hung up the phone abrupty instead of asking for Nancy, something that should have been easy.
It made him sick to his stomach now, looking right at Nancy and knowing that he was too much of a coward to even talk to the girl he loved. Now that he was right here in front of her, running his mouth, he had no idea what to do or say without making anything worse.
“Yeah, too late-- y’know,” He mumbled quietly, shoving his hands down into his coat pockets. “Before you... heard that I was in town. Unless you already knew.”
Jonathan looks back at her, almost expecting Steve or some other handsome guy to come around the corner and sweep her off of her feet. “I”m sorry, Nancy. I-I shouldn’t have bothered you-- I should’ve just left you alone.”













