I read the Obsession script and all of you are wrong. Bear's great sin wasn't making the wish. It's totally normal to wish your crush liked you back, and Bear didn't know the $7 toy he bought at the equivalent of a Hot Topic had actual magic powers. Bear's flaw comes in when he realizes something is deeply wrong with Nikki and does absolutely nothing to stop it or make things right until the very end. Bear is evil and cowardly, but not because he made a wish for Nikki to like him back. It is very important for you all to realize that wishing someone liked you back is not, in and of itself, a bad thing.
no, no, bear's wish was evil. you can see how awful it was in the way it manifested. yes, i agree, i don't think that he thought it would work. yes i agree, wanting someone to like you back is not inherently bad.
BUT:
he asked for her to love him more than anyone else in the world, including herself. he wanted to be at the top of the hierarchy above herself. he wanted to be the center of her universe, above taking care of herself, above her passions, hopes, dreams, friendships, familial relationships, and self-love. he wanted her to be at his beck and call, which is why nikki acts like that after the wish.
it's why she stands in her own piss for 9-10 hours while bear is at work. why she vomits on herself and stands there. why every time there's a conflict she resorts to sex. why she seems so hollow, why her dream of being a write suddenly vanishes overnight. because bear never wanted nikki. he didn't even know who nikki was! he wanted nikki's body and someone else inside of it who would adore him, pamper him, and love him without inconveniencing him.
if what he wanted was normal, the wish would have manifested that instead, like it did when ian wished for a billion dollars. it's not a true monkey's paw, because the one wish willow has no evil intentions.
bear is just that fucking evil.




















