This is entirely on the basis that xenia is applied to a begger, which it is in the source material as well. This is so fucking stupid. It's made repeatedly clear throughout the movie that xenia applies to everyone and not just from the rich to the poor.
Do you hear that? It's the "Emily Wilson didn't watch the fucking movie" alarm! It is repeated several times that killing the suitors would violate xenia, and is part of why Odysseus exiles himself at the end.
Incorrect once again! They don't know the Cyclops is possibly Poseidon's son until after they already blind him, which the sailors who listened to his words don't bring up until they're already on the ocean again because they're not totally sure and are only reaching that conclusion now because they think they've been cursed, and Odysseus taking a Parthian shot getting out of the cave is nonetheless depicted as arrogance that makes the escape harder than it needed to be.
The translator of the ancient Greek epic is criticizing the adaption for "king good" because apparently it's hypocritical for Odysseus to be generous or do any of the work with his men instead of being a more tyrannical autocrat.
I'm not saying a communist take on Greek myth about wealth redistribution wouldn't fuck, but this seems like a somewhat ridiculous expectation.
Yeah, I agree Emily, The Odyssey would be a better film if only Chris had given a thumbs up to murdering your daughter. His strange choice to narrative condemn that can only be the result of stubborn insistence on a USAmerican viewpoint. If there was a Canadian film Agamemnon would have fought Clytemnestra off and convinced her to give him another five daughters to fuel his ship's sails.
Why is so much of her criticism literally just that the famous wife guy is an actual wife guy this time?
The spreading violence is depicted as destroying civilization, with Greeks pillaging and setting fire to villages while reacting in confusion to being mistaken for Sea People, and the ghost of the priestess Odysseus watched be executed tells him the gods are retreating from the mortal world in disgust, so no, I would say that is depicting it as bad and not simply something Odysseus feels guilt about.
Once again, that fighting the suitors means continuing to break xenia is a central conflict.
Goddamn, I fucking get it, you're real disappointed Odysseus didn't whip his dick out, can you stop whining about it for five fucking minutes.
This is true, but considering the main scenes in which characters eat are the villainous suitors greedily leeching off of Penelope, men being cursed to eat massive amounts of food against their will while a witch enacts body horror on them, and the crew breaking a divine law that will inevitably lead to their deaths, I can't help but wonder if that was the point. If Emily WIlson's PhD were in film criticism and not jackassery she might have asked herself the same before deciding to be weirdly petty.
What an utterly insane thing to write after "I would be ashamed to have written this."
Okay, there. We've established that I am approximately one million times smarter than Emily Wilson. My goal in writing this is to extend my light of knowledge to yall so that you'll also be smarter than Emily Wilson. It shouldn't be difficult.