He was right, of course. She never returned the question, never asked him what he wanted â because she didnât need to.Â
âYou want the same thing as the rest of us.â Her voice was soft, as if she was afraid the world would hear, as if she was afraid of hearing it, herself. âTo be loved.âÂ
It was a rare moment of truth, to admit that maybe, she had known him all long. That in all their fights and goodbyes that followed, she knew that what he was really asking for was affirmation, some small admittance that he was wanted, that he meant something. Yet when he continued with his questions, all Verity could do was clench her fists at her sides, nails digging into the skin of her palms until they broke skin, as if the pain would bring clarity when all she wanted was to answer, to tell him that in their endless fights, there was no real winner.Â
She stood motionless, allowing his touch but not reacting. âYou want me to lie to you so you feel better,â she scoffed, âjust like the whiskey you drank tonight. But itâs a momentary distraction, and in the morning youâll have a headache to show for it. Iâm not doing that.â Because I hate you. Because I love you. She stood in the middle of the two extremes, an endless tightrope walk throughout the years in which she often swayed from one side to the next. But the rope that she walked on stayed the same. Because I care about you.Â
âYou want the same thing as the rest of us â to be loved,â she repeated, âbut the love youâre looking isnât from me. Not really.âÂ
Verity sighed and took the hand that was against her face in hers, pulling him into her bedroom with a quiet resignation. âYou can sleep here tonight. I should still have some of your clothes in the closet.â She paused, suddenly feeling tired, as if the weight of the last few years had finally settled on her shoulders. âI should go catch up on work.â
He wasn't sure what he had been expecting. Verity had never been one to bend to his will and he was sure she wouldn't pick that moment to start.Â
When she spoke, it was so quiet that he cocked his head to listen, feeling each word as if it were an iron-gripped hand tightening like a fist around his insides. To be loved. The sentence stole the remaining shreds of his breath, a yearning that ran so deep it mingled with the depths of his soul. Avery's words rattled around in his brain, buzzing like flies he couldn't swat away. No matter how desperately he flailed. In his drunken state, he almost asked if that was what she wanted. If that was what she'd meant when she told him he couldn't give her what she wanted.
Because that was the one thing he wanted to give her. He was just too scared to be left standing alone with his heart in his hands.Â
His soft edges hardened again when she told him no. He wasn't sure why he was surprised, the word piercing his skin like a dagger. He wanted to argue-- he wanted her to lie so he could tell her the truth. It was a cowardâs game he longed to play, but he didn't care. Bold declarations had been replaced by drunken pleas, his need for her far outweighed by his need to know. If no one else would agree to lie to him, then he was content enough to lie to himself.Â
âThat's not true,â Nate argued, but the words were weak. She knew better than anyone else what really held him back. She had thrown it in his face mere hours ago.Â
He didn't put up a fight as she led him to her room. Fingers running along the hem of his shirt, he made to pull it off, stopping only when she made it clear she didn't intend to join him. That desperation flooded him again, his mind reaching out for her like spindly, clawing fingers, as if willpower alone would keep her from leaving. âStay. Please.â The words sounded much calmer than he felt, and he took a single step forward. âI know what comes in the morning.â The same thing that always came for them in the end: reality. The sun would rise again and he would slip painstakingly back into his armor, his second skin. This version of him would be lost to her once more. The bravery hidden amongst the cowardice. âCan you justâŠâ His mind changed courses mid-sentence and he stopped, looking at her for a long moment. âCan I ask you a question?â It wasn't a fair question by any means, and knowing Verity, he wouldn't get an answer, anyway. But his conversation with Avery haunted him, her words affixing themselves to the insecurities he carried around like ghosts. But he figured she'd know the answer more than anyone else. Maybe even more than his own father. And if he hadn't been drunk, he'd have known better than to ask it. âWhat is it about me that's so hard to love?âÂ