Louis Faustian deal & Claudia’s turning
So… s2 really revealed something interesting that reframed Louis’s maternity leave & housewife era and his passivity in it for me.
Louis is not afraid to let people know his thoughts and opinions. Even as a human he is brave enough to be a part of white exclusive spaces (but he still has to navigate these spaces as to not be harmed or killed). He stands up to Lestat when Lestat makes microaggressive comments the first time they meet.
We see him stand up to Lestat several times during their marriage before Claudia was born, such as the infamous ‘it’s starting to sound a bit like slave’, the Antoinette & Jonah debacle, and Louis deciding to leave Lestat s1e3…
After Claudia is born this changes… Louis keeps quiet, is passive and takes everything on the chin. So what happened?
In comes the Faustian deal for Claudia with its terms and conditions.
”I'll stay. I'll stay. I'll never leave you ever again. I promise. I'll be happy, for you, for her.” -Louis
As I’ve talked about consent in my series Louis turning and consent, is Louis in any state to consent to such a deal? Hell no.
In both Lestat's and Louis's retellings of events, Louis is having a mental breakdown here, while in both versions Lestat is mentally stable. Lestat is the responsible party in this situation, since Louis is in no state to make any type of deal or give consent.
This reminds me so much of when a loved one who is an addict was in withdrawal begging me to give them what they wanted, Louis isn’t stable. You can’t just agree because they offer you what you want. That’s taking advantage.
Lestat can claim Louis manipulated him, and I’m sure Louis was intentionally very manipulative, but Lestat is the one who has the power in the situation. Lestat made the active choice to take this deal to ensure Louis stayed with him and remained submissive.
Most importantly CLAUDIA CAN’T GIVE CONSENT TO ANY OF THIS.
This is not to say that Louis is innocent in this. He’s not. Louis decides to hide the truth of her turning from Claudia, this is incredibly deceptive and selfish.
“A child interfering in her parent’s affairs.” - Lestat.
What Claudia perceives as passivity is actually Louis upholding his part of the deal. He doesn’t comment on Lestat’s affair with Antoinette while Louis can’t have sex with anyone else. He doesn’t stand up for Claudia when he thinks that Lestat is treating her wrong. He won’t leave Lestat. A deal was made. Lestat expects Louis to uphold his part. And only death can free him.
Or is it? Nope! What’s interesting is that Louis does decide to break this deal. For Claudia. He decides to leave NOLA with her. Part of it is his love for Claudia. Part of it is that I think he feels he is responsible for damning Claudia’s soul.
Claudia doesn’t find out about this deal until the trial, and it reframes her entire relationship with Louis. As it should. Not for the actions he took when he was mentally unstable and “manipulating” Lestat. But for keeping this a secret from her.
For not realizing that the deal was unfair to begin with and for not breaking it much sooner. For allowing himself to be lost in Lestat. Louis has a tendency to keep secrets from Claudia thinking it’s preserving her happiness.. but we’ll get to that some other time.