Top 5 or 10 Rawhide episodes!
In vague order (bear in mind there’s 217 episodes, most of which I’ve only seen once):
IOT Devil and His Due (everything)
IOT Road to Yesterday (good plot, Rowdy’s drunk act)
A Man Called Mushy (Mushy, Favor/Rowdy tension, Mushyates feelings)
IOT Town in Terror (sick!Rowdy)
IOT Roman Candles (Pete!)
IOT Sharpshooter (good Favor episode)
Rio Salado (poor Rowdy)
IOT Red Wind (Favor/Rowdy tension, Neville Brand!)
IOT Running Man (50 minutes of bad things happening to Rowdy)
IOT El Toro (the focus on Jesús, good Favor/Rowdy stuff)
That is an excellent list!
In totally random order apart from #1: 1. The Race 2. IOT Devil and His Due 3. A Woman’s Place (good treatment of sexism, including Favor’s and Rowdy’s) 4. Season 8, Ride a Crooked Mile (hints of Jed/Rowdy) 5. Season 8, The Pursuit (one of the series’ best villains, and hints of Jed/Rowdy) 6. Incident in the Middle of Nowhere (decent plot, funny F/R moments) 7. The ep where F and R are stuck in a town that wants to hang a man hiding in a well (tension, lovely F/R moments, someone please find the title) 8. The two-part ep with Burgess Meredith playing an executioner (title please) 9. IOT Red Wind (Favor wrong, and admits it) 10. The S 1 or 2 ep where Favor is horrible to everyone, so everyone quits, but at the end they recover the herd and re-join (Favor wrong, and admits it, lovely F/R interaction at the end, title please)
Another good list!
Except that I’m just really not fond of “A Woman’s Place” (I’d rather not see our protagonists be that sexist, honestly–and Rowdy punches Favor in the face out of nowhere at one point (for trusting a woman doctor with another drover’s life) and I’d rather not see that either). At some point, I think I got a little tired of the kind of social commentary in fiction that mostly involves basically going, “See how bad it was back then? See how realistic we’re being by showing that?” Idk. Why not show me what a good alternative could be instead. I guess it’d be weird and maybe frustrating to have the lead characters just be idealized white knights too. But the thing is, the show does make them out to be like that half of the time–like in the season 1 episode “Power and Plow” where Favor and Rowdy stand up for a Comanche man and clearly denounce racism, maybe a little anachronistically. Maybe it’s the inconsistency which rubs me wrong.
7. That’s “Incident of Fear in the Streets” from season 1. I love that one a lot too.
10. You may be thinking of “Incident of the Dog Days” from season 1? (But Rowdy and Wishbone never quit in that one, and Rowdy in particular keeps defending Favor throughout.)
Final (?) thought on A Woman’s Place. Agree re inconsistency on ideological viewpoints (Native Americans occasionally constructed as dignified in their difference, as opposed to women who on the whole are not allowed to be equal). This is why I liked A Woman’s Place: I focused in the representation of the dictor. A woman approx Favor’s age, who does not have or need a man. She knows what she is up against and rationally holds her ground. She does not fall in love with anyone, nobody falls for her, she deals with issues acknowledging her emotions without being overcome by them. Idk, I see her as someone who looks like a woman, does not have any masculine mannerisms, yet implicitly wants to deal with the world as first and foremost a human being, irrespective of gender. My perspective is that of a cis woman who spent her life believing in differences needing to be “on the table” in any discussions of “equal value” (equal to what, anyway?).




















