I am listening to Kat Blaque discuss Chud the Builder, where she covers a white, autistic trans woman's testimony about dating said man. Poor soul. Autistic vulnerability supports many poor decisions that cause embarrassment in retrospect. ANYWAY.Ā
The longer I think about the TME/TMA crowd, the more, and less, they make sense to me. From what I've seen, they're overwhelmingly trans lesbians and cis lesbians. Classic TERFs but Uno Reverse.Ā
But, my takeaway is this: It feels fundamentally incomplete to talk about transmisogyny without centering women who have experienced it in the context that severely impacts the 'misogyny' part. Unless I'm mistaken, Black and Latina trans women dating men face the highest rates of violence, which makes awful lot of sense.
Yet "protect all dolls" got centered around people whose primary interactions with men involved the sexist white peers they were expected to fit in with growing up. Half of them were probably nazis. That is a real and miserable experience if you're a closeted queer kid, one worth talking about, but somehow, it seems, few affected are willing to. Then, years later, "The Men" those transitioned sadasses interact with the most become trans men on the internet or irl queer spaces, and suddenly all of that unresolved baggage gets unloaded onto them. Cishet men out there wouldn't bother with any of this anyway.
That's my thesis, at least.
Sure, that's a deliberately hyperbolic way of putting it. But really, what do you actually know about transmisogyny if you've never tried dating (cis) men as a trans woman nor had close friends who told you all the horror stories? Or, at the bare minimum, listened to trans women talking about those experiences in interviews, podcasts, and so on?
You can't have a vast outlook on how various misogyny's shades and tints intersect with everything unless you've observed The Gays. Or trans men. Or both! All of them damned queers, actually. But some people have no queer experience outside of being closeted, WASP, and terrified of losing social standing. That's just how it is. And I don't want to downplay that. It sucks. Patriarchy suck for everyone. Thus... I suggest feminism???
ā¦And so I thought ātransā in transfeminism was for trans people?
So can you stop trying to colonize all the shit other people need too, thank you very much?Ā
Welcome to the TMA/TME Homeowners Association. Transfeminism was nice, but we've renovated it. Please identify yourself first. This is for community safety.
No, we have no interest in putting an intellectual strain on ourselves, finding common denominators, or sharing space across differences. And if we can't immediately tell from your mannerisms or face which side of our invented fault line you belong on, we get very uncomfortable figuring out which slurs we're morally licensed to use.
And if your case is unusually complicated⦠Thatās where "please undress" would fit as the punchline, except this whole new Uno Reverse meta in the TERF game makes it a little awkward. But if someone paid me enough, I'm sure I could figure something out.
I think everyone would be better off if we separated the TMA/TME badge from transfeminism to save the latter, though I think it's already too late. It sucks! But it is what it is.Ā
If people keep noticing that some of the loudest voices in that ecosystem have an odd habit of sharing audiences, rhetoric, or enemies with crypto-fascists, the solution isn't to insist everyone is secretly calling all trans women Nazis. If you feel called out by that, maybe examine yourself, or at least the company you keep. And then yourself. There might be many different reasons why you sleep on it. I wouldnāt be judging those reasons alone, as a sick fuck myself.
Going back to Kat Blaque: notice how she has never seemed to have a problem saying, when it's relevant, āI grew up as a gay Black teenage boy.ā She can acknowledge the social position she occupied without that being a threat to her identity or current social position. The other girl in this vid also went āI know what Iām talking about, I was gay.ā No damn biggie. Trans men say āI lived 20 years of my life as a womanā and nothing explodes. Meanwhile, some people would rather punch three faggots (various) and one elderly Black guy in a wheelchair on their way out than ever utter the words, āI grew up being perceived as a heterosexual white boy.ā
Intersectionality? Oh, we're besties. She just goes to a different school...
However we chose to phrase it, you probably get what I mean.
I think everyone is better off once they reconcile with the uncomfortable realities that shaped them just for mental health, if nothing else. Emotional honesty with oneself is crucial for intellectual honesty, which in turn is a must for any good activism or social commentary. It's of the utmost value, actually. Everyone has a blind spot they don't examine, and thatās fine. The problem starts when you build an entire ideology around refusing to look at it. And then others join you.
I don't care how many "I have gay friends" or "I have POC friends" or "I had sex with a XYZ and they liked it" they collect along the way. I genuinely hope those friends and sex buddies get their shit together, find Jesus and get woke. These people are nobody's friends but their own, no matter how many experience points they've invested in the debate rhetoric skill tree. Gaslight 82/100.Ā
I know people get dysphoric about the whole "socialization" conversation, but I'm sorry, we can't be that precious.
What are you going to do, become an anti-vaxxer for the social sciences? "Yes, I love feminism. Also every study about how gendered social perception shapes people's lives is bullshit." Become a tankie version of Hillary Clinton combined with manifested destiny? "Yes, I care about material conditions first and foremost. Also mine never influenced me at all, I was born pure and suffered for it. Don't you dare bring society into this, you MRA."
Sorry to bother you.Ā I guess.
Get your shit together, why wonāt you. Please?