alright Iāve been thinking about it all weekend and Iāve figured out that what I find so compelling about exu: calamity is how, for the first time in a critical role campaign, weāre working from the point of view of The Establishment.
Itās weird because the thing that really set cr apart for me in the grand scheme of high fantasy media is that in the mainstream campaigns so far, theyāve been incredibly dedicated to playing the underdog. One of the things I really like about Matt and the cast is that they donāt generally go in for the Star Wars/Harry Potter bullshit of āoh it seems like this character comes from nothing but theyāre actually secretly special because [insert weird theme of genealogy as an indicator of good character]ā. In a wide sprawling world of Lost Princesses and One True Kings, critical role gives us genuine, bona fide nobodies. Iām so in love with the fact that Orym was only ever supposed to be a random bodyguard standing in the corner, that Nottās big backstory reveal was that she used to be a housewife, that Laundaās character is literally meant to embody the idea of collateral damage.
Even Vox Machina, to date our most respectable party with connections/claims to power from the outset of their arcs (as opposed to clawing their way to legitimacy through adversity Mighty Nein style), only have that to a very limited extent. Percy is an aristocrat, yes, but in a place so small and isolated that it could be seized and ruled by necromancers for a solid half-decade without the neighbouring royal power noticing. Vax and Vex are the children of a high-level ambassador but theyāre outcast, bastards, literally illegitimate. Pike is a respected cleric of a god nobody follows. Grog would have led his herd, but was first ousted by his uncle and then willingly ceded the position of power to his cousin. Keyleth was in the same position as Percy, royalty in a way that didnāt matter to anyone outside her civilisation before the conclave arc dragged them into relevance. As a party they spent a pretty big chunk of their early arc half-fighting with Sovereign Uriel in their quest for respect. Compared to our new exu folks theyāre still very definitely underdogs. And, yāknow, thereās a reason for that ā underdogs make for some of the most compelling stories. Itās immensely satisfying watching maligned people gain respect, unloved people become loved, weak people become strong, disempowered people become powerful, etc.
So then I was thinking about all that and wondering why I find these new six so interesting, especially because. It really cannot be overstated how much power they have. Weāre shown up front how competent and respected they all are, but more than that, we get all these hints in the build-up to the gala ā Nydus being confronted with an NPC whose concerns are ātoo lowā for him as if thatās ever been a thing at the cr table before now; that comment about Laerryn being so fundamental to the workings of the city that most people donāt recognise her on sight because they straight up donāt understand what it is she does; Patiaās exchange with Eldemir the wise ā this guy is supposed to be one of the cityās seven highest government officials, and heās senile. The way as we meet them we bounce from public to secret, statesman to merchant, the very guts of the city to its absolute peak. By the time they all converge at the party and Brennan says that thing about these being the six people who actually get shit done, itās like. Oh. These are the people who are physically keeping the city afloat. They control infrastructure, information, public opinion. In a room full of the most powerful people in the most powerful city on Exandria, these are the ones who direct it all.
And then itās hammered home by Purvanās entrance, because in any other story, heād be the audience-surrogate character. He walks into this glittering party with his muddy boots and his wolf pal, brings a message from the gods into this monument to arcane hubris, gets laughed at for his trouble by a roomful of wizards in fancy robes. The contrast between this young low-ish level ranger and the ring of brass is so fucking strong. And then even more, by the time he gets done asking to meet with the septarium, we already know that wouldnāt do him any good. Weāve seen what those guys are like already, we know that if he wants to get anywhere heāll have to speak to our six. Theyāre the ones who are gonna be able to fix it.
And then I was like, oh. Wait. Calamity.
The reason we like underdogs is because we like watching them rise up, but these folks have already risen as high as itās possible to go. And we already know how this story ends. Ā
Weāre not just gonna see them fall. Weāre gonna see them fall further and harder and faster than any other group of people possibly could.
Not to be too dark about it, but. Iām quite excited. Ā