Why ‘The marvelous Mrs Maisel’ is worth a shot in a feminist view
After watching both second seasons of Westworld and The handmaids’s tale (both nominated for a lot of Emmy’s - and well deserved!), I though I could give myself a break with all this drama and watch a more humorous show.. After having taking a deep look at the Emmy nominations, I decided to give ‘The marvelous Mrs Maisel’ from Amazon, a shot.
The show takes place in 1958 Manhattan where the life of Midge Maisel takes a turn when her husband Joel leaves her for his secretary (yes, how original!). In her quest to deal with this situation, she discovers a new talent: stand-up comedy. With the help of her friend and manager, Suzie, they work together into making it something more than a hobby..
All this material of course leads into analyzing the show a little deeper and how we could find some feminist aspects in it.
After reading the following article, I decided to reply to it with a few points:
https://medium.com/colored-lenses/the-marvelous-mrs-maisel-and-the-celebration-of-white-feminism-3396a66563c1
Midge criticizes Sophie because she intentionally says to her that she has to become a character to be funny and taken seriously by men. For me, this shows the superficially of society: the thought that if a woman is beautiful, she can't be smart or successful; the thought that men or people in general won't take Midge seriously. So I believe Midge was right to point this out and to be mad that she would have to lie to become successful; isn't that what feminism is also about ? Women being taken seriously without playing a role and pretend to be more fragile or less smart than what they are?
Midge being portrayed 'perfect' along the other women of the show is maybe how others have always treated her and mostly her husband : he says to her that she was so perfect that it was hard to equivalent her or he was afraid to fail and how she would see him. This may also be a symbolism of how women were portrayed in movies during the 50's? Like the perfect housewife you see in television spots etc (pretty, smiling and waiting for her husband after cooking the perfect meal).
The part about not seeing the racism: maybe this is also a way to show how 'ignorant' some women or housewives were at the time and lived in their own bubble with the same group of friends they kept over the years? Like the example of the project of building a road to a park that we see in an episode ; the article writes it: she's from a middle class society, never had problems with money etc ; I believe that maybe, back then, when you didn't bond with a certain group of people (maybe like fervent feminism, or a group against racism etc), you never happened to be in contact with those people so no, you didn't have the same fights, unfortunately. Most of your opinions are forged by the social groups you hang out with, by the kind of information you got to read etc. If you notice, the word 'feminism' is not even mentioned in the show; probably because she didn't even realize that what she was doing would be considered as feminism or progress. Please never forget that we, millennials, like to comment those type of shows (and of course, it's always positive to be able to see the flaws of it) but we watch it with our perspective from the 21st century and with all the information we have now. Of course we know that sexism is not over, that racism is not over. With the raise of internet, everyone can tell their story and we for sure know that those fights are far away from over, but those were the fifties.. You never see Midge with a paper but why would she, like she pointed out during her sketch about Sophie: women should pretend to stay stupid. But at the time, Midge, and her entourage, didn't even know all those changes would come, and they probably didn't even realize what they could do to change it. So like the article points out, 'racism doesn't affect her so it doesn't concern her', because the show is portraying the little pink bubble in which she is living, and she probably don't even realize what other struggles other people or dealing with. And maybe this can be one of the purposes of the show: pointing out that a certain group of people didn't get to deal with racism or other struggles, and therefore, there was no talking about it, but, after all, has this really changed now ? We know that racism and sexism exist, but does this mean that everyone is concerned by it? I believe not.