Getting so very very tired of people moralizing fictional romance preferences. Reading is not an ethical or unethical action. Liking the nastiest, most disgusting shit in fiction does not hurt another living, breathing person. And having Booklist label shit as "ethical" - and by extension labeling anything outside of that sphere "unethical" - is fucking exhausting.
editing in a screenshot in case they change it
"Ethical Romantasy: All of the Swoon, None of the Ick.
By Maren Flessen. BLOG. First published July 16, 2026 (Booklist Online).
[image of a woman and a man standing among large potted plants. one of the plants is growing around the two, supposedly due to magic.]
We all love a good romantasy, but even the staunchest fans among us can admit that some depict problematic relationships. While dynamics like emotional manipulation or toxic “protectiveness” can usually be explained away by a desperate circumstance or a restrictive, medieval-coded setting, you might find patrons longing for modern sensibilities in their fae castles. For those yearning for green flags like explicit consent, mature grounded characters, and equal power dynamics, look no further. Below are thoroughly-vetted romantasy tales that deliver all of the swoon, with none of the ick."















