Toby Rogers x F!Reader (NSFW)
Words: 2.5k
Time to read: 20min
Summary: You're drunk at a bar with your friends, when you notice this bartender giving you a couple of free drinks..
CW: 18+ Content, Alcohol, Mention of readers past relationship, drunk reader (also she consents), female reader, reader is a heavy drinker & smoker, Toby also smokes (yes it's hot) -toby seems to get a somewhat normal life but he still had that car accident, uhh fingering, unsafe sex, praising
Side note from the author: I am intoxicated and it´s 1AM so please note the spelling mistakes, THAT´S also my first blog SO have mercy on me thank you!! Also English is my second language. Tips on how to write better are always appreciated just don't be harsh/mean. - HAPPY FRIDAY 13th 😆
-NSFW UNDER THE CUT! MINORS DON`T INTERACT-
You and your friends decide to go out on a Friday, typically you always go out on Fridays. But this one, this one is different, it´s Friday the 13th and in your town there's always a party on that day. It´s been a year since you moved on from your ex but it seems you still haven't found anyone or any situationship at that matter. It feels like there is no one right for you. It´s difficult to find the perfect partner although today is different.
You guys meet up at your house and continue going to some random´s party. You first buy alcohol at the near by gas station - everything is already closed so it´s your only choice. You go up to the registers buy some cheap alcohol and head out. Layla, your friend, tells you the party is right at the corner.
„Better hurry up drinking this bottle of Eristoff." she says.
You down the rest of what´s left. The syrupy-vodka burning your throat but who cares you love doing it every time.
"HEyYy Y/N!" some people at the party are greeting you, you're not really popular but you know some people from going out this much. You say hi back, a bit tipsy but continue through the home. You sit on a couch, knowing it hasn´t been cleaned for ages, a matter of fact never. Still you sit down grabbing another bottle that's lying around and try to drink it. Fuck this tastes awful you think. Nevertheless you drink it empty and suddenly.
Shit... you see your ex, he didn't see you, but in a moment you get up and try to go to your other friend that came with you.
"Y/N do you see him?? Holy shit why is this piece of shit here??" Nova yells.
"PSSSH keep it down. God are you already drunk??" you try to keep her quiet but she is already walking up to him and you try not to make ANY eye contact.
Why is he here? He doesn't know anyone here and why now? I need to get the fuck out. You sneak out by a backdoor and light up the last cigarette you have. The smoke looks so beautiful in the moonlight. Layla coming out of nowhere asking for a cigarette, you just stare at her and share the one in your hand.
"Oh.. sorry didn´t know that's your last one but anyways do you want to go to a bar? It´s really boring in here and the alcohol tastes like shit."
"Sure but what about Nova she looks like she wants to stay?" you ask.
"Oh don´t worry, her boyfriend is here too and he has to drive, so he will look after her!" Layla replied.
So the next thing you both do is putting out the cigarette and go away from the party. You walk from bar to bar until it´s midnight and lastly you find the last bar to go to tonight. It’s cramped up in a small alleyway. Shaby but in a cool way, dark and small lightening. Inside there is playing metal music. You notice that the song that is playing in the background is Aerials by System of A Down. You sit on a near by window, cool summer air blowing into the room. Cozy yet mysterious, a bartender is coming, he asks
"What can I-I girls get you for tonight?"
"Two rum and cokes, please." you reply to the stuttering waiter.
You don´t think much of it. Continuing the conversation with Layla. You talk about how dumb your ex is and why he shows up in the first place.
"Man I can't believe he STILL is wearing ripped skinny jeans and that awful cap with his oily hair" Layla says laughingly.
"Yeah, why did I ever date that guy? Please remind me!!"
"Oh I don´t know but you have a SHITTY taste" she exclaims.
Right as she says the last word the brunette is handing you both the drinks. You didn't notice at first but HE was tall, he had a tape on his mouth - no wait, a bandage, you wonder what was up with that. He winked at you when he notices you staring at him. Gosh the alcohol must be finally working. Your friend still talking about your ex and sipping her drink while you drift away in your thoughts. I must be crazy for thinking he is so hot by just serving me a drink. He was. Oh how he is just cleaning the cups and putting away the dirty dishes. His arms circling the glass with the semi-wet towel. It made you feel something. Thinking about his hands rubbing you.
"Earth on Y/N!! Are you listening? I am talking to you.!"
"Yeah sorry I was just thinking why I dated that asshole" you lied but could you possibly tell your friend that you think the bartender is just hot by serving you both drinks?
"OHH I know what's going on!" your friend states.
"You think about how to get revenge on your ex."
"Y-yea you're right" you reply.
"Come on let´s go outside smoke a cigarette."
"Um I don't know if you forgot but we don't have any anymore" you state.
"Fuckk you are right. Well let's just ask the bartender he seems like he smokes." she implies.
Both of you get up. You adjusted yourself without knowing it.
"Heyyy uh.. sir" Layla asks unknowingly.
"Toby! You c-can call me Toby. What can I g-get you?"
"Just some cigarettes if you have any of course."
God my friend is so embarrassing.
"Y-Yeah no problem, the only thing is, I h-have rolling cigarettes but if you w-want t-to -twitch- I can roll them for you." Toby smiling says.
"YES thank you!" you loudly say and push your friend away before she says something rude or even more embarrassing things.
"Can you stop shoving me?"
"No! before you do any more stupid shit."
You wait outside of the bar. No one is around but it is 1AM. How could there be no one at this time? You tap your foot, badly needing a cigarette when finally Toby is approaching both of you.
You both thank him, he is trying to leave when you say "Hey uh do you want to join us? Tell us, why do you work here? I kinda want to get to know you." that's when you realised what the hell you said.
Ugh what the fuck. WHY did I just ask him that he has a job to do.
"Mhmm? Oh yeah I d-don´t see why not. She is a p-pretty straightforward lady mhm?" Toby asks your friend who is minding her own business.
She doesn´t reply so instead he goes up to you and asks again.
"Well if you say it like that maybe I am and maybe you know what I want from you" the alcohol hits more than ever.
You are completely drunk but you don´t care anymore, you only think about Toby. He's so shy but smug at the same time, like he never really talked to a woman before. He was caught off guard by the last sentence but brushes it off
"You kn-know you are pretty drunk, yo-you better be careful or else something is going to happen to you!" he leans forward to tell you.
You get red, he is so close to your face. You practically can feel his breath. Smoking the cigarette faster, you inhale so much, the smoke gets in your eye.
"Huh are you o-okay?" Toby asks.
"Yea just smoke. in my. eye." ouch it hurts.
All of a sudden he holds up your chin to look if everything is alright. She is so mesmerising, I could look into her eyes forever toby thinks. After your eye stops burning you notice how close both of your faces are. You want to kiss him so badly and so does he. He saw how you swung into the bar, laughing and smiling. He knows you'll get to know each other better after this night. He was already captivated by your beauty the first time you stepped into the bar. He couldn't help but flirt with you. Her skin is so soft. He could kiss you but you are drunk this would totally go wrong. You try to lean in for a kiss when you get interrupted by Layla.
"Hey uh buddy. Do you mind letting go of my friend? We would like you to serve us more drinks now."
Buddy? I barely know her.
"Oh-h s-sorry.. Let me make you s-some drinks."
Layla is just looking out for you but you want this, you want him to look at you and hold him, you wanted more than just looks. Still all three of you went inside. Toby making some shots. After one there were two and then three shots, Toby actually drinking with the both of you due to being the last two people in the bar.
You look at your phone 3.56 AM. Layla has gone home earlier with a cap, leaving Toby and you alone. She was so drunk, she forgot trying to "protect" you. But you know Toby would be the one protecting.
You both are chatting and flirting "You know you're a good bartender and a hot one at that!"
" You think t-there are only ugly bartenders?" Toby laughing.
"I mean NoO but you are so so handsome. I can't resist your beautiful eyes." you just stare at him happy and drunk.
He can't help but also feel tipsy.
"Sorry but I h-have to close the bar n-now, it is already 4AM." he announces.
I better bring her home, she seems to fall at every step she takes. I can't risk her getting hurt.
"I w-will walk you home, it´s not safe and it's late"
"Alright big guy, but don't expect sleeping at my place. IT´S a mess."
Even if it is, he wouldn't mind it. His place has always been a mess. But maybe he can crash at your place, he wouldn´t try to convince you but the way you have been flirting with him all night tells him differently.
"You know yo-you´re pretty cute when you stare and giggle at m-me. It t-tells me you want me." you are stunned but it's true.
The whole night you've been thinking how he could touch you. With his rough hand, kissing your neck, fingering you. God maybe you really really need him badly. It´s not even the alcohol in your system. It´s your body that is craving for his touch. Imagining him on top of you caressing your face. The thought of it melts your brain.
You both stumble to your home, your arms hugging him not even letting go when you try to put your key into the keyhole. He's warm, you can feel his toned muscles. You're getting wetter the more you both touch each other.
"There y-you go gorgeous, do you need anything e-else?"
"Mhmm I need you, I want you Toby please" you beg not even recognising what you just said but that's all Toby needed to hear.
He picks you up, closes the door behind him and looks for your room. You kiss him, slowing on his neck.
After walking for a while he finds your room settling you down on the bed. He gets on top of you and starts kissing you sloppily.
"S-So good- you taste so f-fucking- good."
You were practically clinging to his body slowing taking off your clothes.
"That's it baby hmm~" his breath getting heavier.
One hand holding your hip and the other one travelling down.
"Hah.. you are so soaked f-fuck. That's all because of me?" He laughed breathlessly, you can't help but moan as he circles your clit slowly..
Fuck I barely know him but why is he so fucking hot. Your moaning turning his dick harder, throbbing against his jeans. He starts to put one finger in, stretching you open, slowly working a second on in and curling them forward.
"Y/N-..please fuck.. Let me f-feel, mhm.. you" He can barely keep it together, craving your touch all night. You can feel his cock behind his jeans on your thigh, rubbing it, only getting painfully harder.
He pushes his finger deeper inside you, grinding them against your g-spot, his palm pressing down on your clit. You struggle to keep it together. Your whole body belongs to him, you can't keep up with his pace. You were so close when he unexpectedly stops.
"You are such a good girl f-for me do you know that, yeah?" You tried to focus but you only feel your pussy pulsating.
"Y-You do want my cock pretty girl, right?" You eagerly nodded. He stood up pulling off his shirt and zipped open his pants to yank them away.
"You really r-really want it that bad baby, huh.?" He was slim yet muscular, a weird tattoos on his arm and chest, scars and scratches. He seemed to be through a lot.
You could feel his impatience, ripping off your panties than his. His tip, a light pink, teasing your entrance. It was coated with pre-cum.
"Fuck..You are so wet. Only mine."
"Please.. I- I can´t take it anymore...Toby". you whimpered. Feeling his throbbing cock against your clit was too much. You needed him inside you. now before you went insane.
"C´mon you can beg nicer than that" He keeps running the tip over your swollen cunt. "Please Toby.. I need your cock inside of me"
"That's a good girl." He groans before slowly pushing his cock inside. He needs to stop for a moment, trying to not loose control. But when he sees you rolling your eyes back, he thrusts harder and deeper.
"God.. Fuck.. How could I have ever lived without this pretty cunt of yours." You were melting by every thrust.
One deeper than the one before. You look so pretty being fucked by him. His hands wrapping around your waist to get a better grip fucking you. He can feel him getting close and so were you. His cock slamming harder into your cervix, pressing so deep, practically a moaning mess.
"Fuck.. baby-" The feeling of you milking his cock while you also experienced a wave of ecstasy brought the thrusting to a stop.
He carefully pulled out when you realise he didn't wear a condom.
"Fuck.." you breathe heavily.
You don't care right now but you look at Toby who also stupidly smiles
"I uh I will give you the money for the m-morning after pill. How much is it? Like 20 bucks?"
You stare at this idiot and just snuggle up to him "More like 80."
You both will just get it the following morning. Now you just need rest.
Side note from the author: sooo Its now 6:40AM It was fun to write it but holy fuck I should NOT do all-nighters. Anyways I am sorry if the time is wrong I think I have a mix of past and present but its early in the morning my brain is functioning on water and energy.
TELL ME IF YOU WANT ANOTHER PART - I am going to sleep goodnight y'all 🫶
Inspired by @noctiva please check out her blog she is probably my biggest inspiration 🫶